IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE
CIV-2023-404-1349
[2024] NZHC 1385
BETWEEN KIM DOTCOM
Appellant
AND
THE OLD CHURCH LIMITED
Respondent
Hearing: 9 April 2024 Appearances:
Further submissions completed:
S L Cogan for the Appellant
J G Donkin for the Respondent
23 April 2024
Judgment:
31 May 2024
JUDGMENT OF POWELL J
This judgment was delivered by me on 31 May 2024 at 11.00 am.
Pursuant to R 11.5 of the High Court Rules.
…………………..
Registrar/Deputy Registrar
Solicitors:
S L Cogan, Auckland J G Donkin, Auckland
KIM DOTCOM v THE OLD CHURCH LIMITED [2024] NZHC 1385 [31 May 2024]
[1]The appellant, Kim Dotcom, has appealed a judgment of Judge M-E Sharp:1
(a)finding him liable for $207,988, being the costs of remediating an apartment where he had been a tenant; and
(b)dismissing his counterclaim seeking damages from the landlord for breach of quiet enjoyment.
[2] The respondent, The Old Church Limited (“OCL”), as the owner of the apartment rented for two years by Mr Dotcom, had sought $304,000 for reinstatement. By the end of the hearing, OCL accepted it could only prove loss to a maximum of
$171,140.47.2 In her Honour’s judgment, Judge Sharp accepted that Mr Dotcom had damaged the apartment by making various unauthorised alterations, or otherwise damaged the apartment to a degree that exceeded fair wear and tear. The District Court found that Mr Dotcom was not however required to compensate OCL for the cost of reinstating the “consented alterations” and, when this cost was deducted, it meant that OCL could only prove remediation costs of $102,191.69.3 Despite this, the District Court found that this figure was “much less than OCL actually spent” and “the amount OCL has proved it spent only represents a part of the damage”.4 As a result, Judge Sharp assessed OCL’s loss by using the evidence of OCL’s quantity surveyor as to the estimated cost of the works as if they had been carried out, less the quantity surveyor’s estimate of the costs of the consented works. This resulted in the Court ultimately finding that OCL was entitled to damages of $207,988 plus interest.5
[3] The District Court went on to dismiss Mr Dotcom’s counterclaim, finding that OCL had not breached Mr Dotcom’s right to quiet enjoyment, despite a “glaring omission” by OCL which meant that, while OCL was required to give third-party rights of access to the apartment to Docklands, Mr Dotcom’s right to quiet enjoyment was not to be breached.6
1 The Old Church Ltd v Dotcom [2023] NZDC 8085 [the Judgment] at [77].
2 At [45].
3 At [47].
4 At [47]–[48].
5 At [49].
6 At [67].
Background
[4] Judge Sharp succinctly set out the background to the dispute in the following terms:
[1] From April 2013 until February 2021 [OCL] was the registered owner of a leasehold interest in Apartment 64, Shed 24, Princes Wharf, Auckland (the apartment). On 1 September 2015 the parties signed a tenancy agreement…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Dotcom v The Old Church Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NZHC 1385
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In relation to the condition of the apartment at the beginning of the tenancy, the Court found that even if the condition of the apartment was not as represented in the marketing materials, it did not affect the District Court's conclusions about the damage caused by Mr Dotcom. Regarding unreasonable withholding of consent, the Court held that the tenancy agreement did not permit Mr Dotcom to undertake alterations without first seeking consent from the landlord, and any unconsented alterations constituted damage to the property. The Court also found that the damage caused by Mr Dotcom was not the result of fair wear and tear, notwithstanding some evidence to the contrary. However, the Court found that there was insufficient evidence to conclude that certain categories of damage were not the result of fair wear and tear. Consequently, the Court allowed the appeal in part and directed the parties to provide further submissions on the appropriate deductions to be made.
As for the loss suffered by OCL, the Court found that it was not open to the District Court to use the quantity surveyor's report as a substitute for proof of expenditure. The Court concluded that the maximum amount of damages payable by Mr Dotcom to OCL was $102,191.69, less other deductions to be determined. The Court dismissed the issue of mitigation as it did not affect the outcome of the appeal. Finally, the Court found that there was no breach of Mr Dotcom's right to quiet enjoyment and dismissed the counterclaim.
The appeal was allowed in part with regard to the claims for damage/fair wear and tear and loss (if any) suffered by OCL, and dismissed otherwise. Further submissions are to be filed by the parties on the appropriate amounts to be deducted under each heading. The Court's preliminary view is that costs should lie where they fall, but if either party seeks costs, memoranda seeking costs are to be filed by 21 June 2024 and memoranda in response are to be filed by 8 July 2024.