For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link
ORDER PROHIBITING PUBLICATION OF THE NAMES, ADDRESSES OR IDENTIFYING PARTICULARS OF THE APPELLANTS (AND THE RESPONDENT LAM IN THE CROSS-APPEAL).
THE ORDER OF THE HIGH COURT SUPPRESSING THE NAMES, ADDRESSES AND IDENTIFYING PARTICULARS OF THE APPELLANTS AND LAM ALSO REMAINS IN FORCE.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA453/2011 [2012] NZCA 573
BETWEEN JMM, GLS, SJL, MSB, DAW AND BDR Appellants
ANDLEGAL SERVICES AGENCY Respondent
CA453/2011
AND BETWEEN LEGAL SERVICES AGENCY Appellant
ANDJMM, LAM, GLS, SJL, MSB, DAW AND BDR
Respondents
Hearing: 25-26 September 2012
Court: Ellen France, Randerson and Stevens JJ
Counsel: S M Cooper and A T S Benton for Appellants (and the Respondents in the cross-appeal)
F M R Cooke QC and F M Gush for Respondent (and the Appellant in the cross-appeal)
Judgment: 10 December 2012 at 3.00 pm
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
JMM, GLS, SJL, MSB, DAW AND BDR V LEGAL SERVICES AGENCY COA CA453/2011 [10 December
2012]
A The applications for leave to file further evidence on appeal are granted. B The appeal is dismissed.
C The cross-appeal is dismissed.
D The questions of law as modified in [29] are answered as set out in [36] to
[119] of this judgment.
EOrder prohibiting publication of the names and addresses or identifying particulars of the appellants (and the respondent LAM in the cross-appeal) is granted. A similar order made in the High Court remains in place.
F There is no order as to costs.
G This case may be cited as Meredith v Legal Services Agency.
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Stevens J)
Table of Contents
Para No
Questions of interpretation [1] Some further background [7] The High Court appeals [14] Further evidence on appeal [19] Current status of litigants’ claims [21] Leave to appeal - questions of law [26] Issues on appeal [29] The questions of law [29] The factual questions [31] First issue - role of the Agency on withdrawal [36] The statutory provisions [36] Meaning of “prospects of success” [43] Prospects of success - our views [48] Relevant considerations [55] Required approach - our analysis [61] Level of analysis by Agency [69] Approach to analysis - our views [75] Second issue - reasons for withdrawal of grant [77] Third issue - reconsideration [85]
Fourth issue - reviews under Part 3 [92] Manifestly unreasonable [97] Manifestly unreasonable - our views [99] Wrong in law [100] Wrong in law - our views [103] Fifth issue - Panel’s power to consider additional information [113] Our analysis [116] Result [120]
Questions of interpretation
[1] At the heart of these appeals is the interpretation of some key provisions of the Legal Services Act 2000 (the Act). The appeals arise because Dobson J, who heard the case in the High Court,1 granted leave for the parties to argue a number of questions of law in this Court.2 For the first time, this Court is asked to consider some of the fundamental concepts governing…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read JMM v Legal Services Agency and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] NZCA 573
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Background
Background to the litigation
The case originated in the High Court, where the litigants successfully argued that errors had been made by the Agency and the Panel. The High Court granted leave for the litigants to appeal certain questions of law to the Court of Appeal. The Agency cross-appealed the High Court's decision. The Court of Appeal heard the appeals and cross-appeal on 25-26 September 2012 and delivered its judgment on 10 December 2012. The Court granted leave for further evidence on appeal and dismissed both the appellants' appeal and the Agency's cross-appeal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Where the withdrawal of a grant is on the basis that the aided person is no longer a person who would be entitled to that grant of legal aid by virtue of the provisions of s 9 of the Act, what is the meaning and application of the relevant provision of s 9(4) of the Act? With a consequential issue: what is the meaning of the phrase “prospects of success” in s 9(4)(d)(i)?
2. What is the nature and scope of the requirement of the Agency in s 27(3)(b) to give the aided person and the lead provider “reasons for the withdrawal”?
3. Where the Agency has made a decision to withdraw a grant of legal aid under s 26 of the Act, what is the scope for an aided person to apply to the Agency for a reconsideration of the decision under s 29 if aggrieved by such decision?
4. Where an aided person seeks to review the Agency’s decision to withdraw the grant of aid, what is the scope of the grounds for review under s 54(1) of the Act?
5. In the context of the review process, what material may the Panel consider arising from the powers under s 55A and s 56 of the Act when it determines the review?
Held
1. The meaning of "prospects of success" under s 9(4)(d)(i) of the Legal Services Act 2000 is the likelihood of achieving a successful outcome, which should be assessed pragmatically and in the circumstances of the particular case, weighing the likely benefits against the likely costs. The court held that the phrase should be interpreted in light of the circumstances then pertaining and the stage the proceeding has reached.
2. The nature and scope of the requirement of the Agency to give the aided person and the lead provider "reasons for the withdrawal" under s 27(3)(b) of the Act is that the Agency must set out in the notification the essence of the reasons for its decision, providing sufficient detail to enable the aided person to decide whether to exercise the statutory rights to challenge the decision either by means of a reconsideration or through a review by a Panel. However, the written notification is not required to meet the level of detail of a judicial judgment or formal legal opinion.
3. The scope for an aided person to apply to the Agency for a reconsideration of the decision under s 29 if aggrieved by the decision to withdraw a grant of legal aid is limited to situations in which new or additional information has come to light after the original decision has been made, providing a relatively informal opportunity for the aided person to draw such new or additional information to the attention of the Agency in the hope that it might lead to a different decision.
4. The scope of the grounds for review under s 54(1) of the Act is that a decision of the Agency may be reviewed on the grounds that the decision is either manifestly unreasonable or wrong in law. The court held that a decision will only be overturned if it was not reasonably open to the Agency and that the Panel should apply a narrow approach to the wrong in law ground, limited to situations where the Agency misinterpreted or misapplied either the law primarily directed to the underlying litigation in issue or the provisions of the Act.
5. The material the Panel may consider arising from the powers under s 55A and s 56 of the Act when it determines the review is that the Panel can gather information from a range of sources, including the Agency and any person, and is not limited to the content of the withdrawal letter.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court addressed the five issues raised by the parties, which were central to the correct approach for the Agency and the Panel to follow when dealing with the determination of the withdrawal of a grant of legal aid under s 26 of the Act. Firstly, the court considered the meaning and application of the relevant provision of s 9(4) of the Act and the phrase "prospects of success" in s 9(4)(d)(i). The court held that the term should be interpreted in light of the circumstances then pertaining and the stage the proceeding has reached, weighing the likely benefits against the likely costs. The court also held that the Agency must conduct an individual assessment of each litigant and whether their prospects of success are sufficient to justify the grant of legal aid.
Secondly, the court addressed the nature and scope of the requirement of the Agency to give reasons for the withdrawal of a grant of legal aid under s 27(3)(b) of the Act. The court held that the Agency must set out the essence of the reasons for its decision, providing sufficient detail to enable the aided person to decide whether to exercise the statutory rights to challenge the decision. However, the written notification is not required to meet the level of detail of a judicial judgment or formal legal opinion.
Thirdly, the court examined the scope for an aided person to apply to the Agency for a reconsideration of the decision under s 29 if aggrieved by the decision to withdraw a grant of legal aid. The court held that the reconsideration process provides a relatively informal opportunity for the aided person to draw new or additional information to the attention of the Agency in the hope that it might lead to a different decision.
Fourthly, the court considered the scope of the grounds for review under s 54(1) of the Act. The court held that a decision of the Agency may be reviewed on the grounds that the decision is either manifestly unreasonable or wrong in law. The court held that a decision will only be overturned if it was not reasonably open to the Agency and that the Panel should apply a narrow approach to the wrong in law ground, limited to situations where the Agency misinterpreted or misapplied either the law primarily directed to the underlying litigation in issue or the provisions of the Act.
Lastly, the court addressed the material the Panel may consider arising from the powers under s 55A and s 56 of the Act when it determines the review. The court held that the Panel can gather information from a range of sources, including the Agency and any person, and is not limited to the content of the withdrawal letter.
The binding legal principle established or applied by the decision is that the court provided detailed guidance on the interpretation of key provisions of the Legal Services Act 2000 in the context of the withdrawal of a grant of legal aid, including the meaning and application of the phrase "prospects of success", the requirement of the Agency to give reasons for the withdrawal, the scope for an aided person to apply for a reconsideration, the scope of the grounds for review, and the material the Panel may consider when determining the review.