Crown Health Financing Agency v P

Link copied
Case Copied 83 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

PUBLIC VERSION: INFORMATION THAT IS CONFIDENTIALTO ONE OR MORE PARTIES HAS BEEN REMOVED

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA173/07
[2008] NZCA 362

BETWEENCROWN HEALTH FINANCING AGENCY


Appellant

ANDP


First Respondent

ANDB AND ORS


Second Respondents

CA149/07 & CA376/07

AND BETWEEN             P


Appellant

ANDCROWN HEALTH FINANCING AGENCY


Respondent

CA150/07 & CA383/07

AND BETWEEN             B AND ORS


Appellants

ANDCROWN HEALTH FINANCING AGENCY


Respondents

Hearing:9, 10 and 11 June 2008

Court:Glazebrook, Hammond, O'Regan, Robertson and Baragwanath JJ

Counsel:Dr D B Collins QC, Solicitor-General, L M Hansen and J D Kerr forAppellant in CA173/07 and Respondent in CA149/07, CA376/07,CA150/07 and CA383/07


R Chapman and L M McKeown for First Respondent in CA173/07and Appellant in CA149/07 and CA376/07
S M Cooper and K R Ross for Second Respondents in CA173/07 andAppellants in CA150/07 and CA383/07

Judgment:16 September 2008 at 10 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal of the Crown Health Financing Agency in CA173/07 is allowed to the extent set out at [77] ‑ [80].

BThe appeals of Mr P and Mr B and others in CA149/07, CA376/07, CA150/07 and CA383/07 are dismissed.

CThe proceedings before us are remitted to the High Court for resolution in terms of this judgment.

DThere are no costs orders.

ENone of the names of or other identifying information about the parties (other than the Crown Health Financing Agency) or any persons named in this judgment or in any documents filed in these appeals are to be published in any media reports or in publicly available databases.  Publication in Law Reports or Law Digest is, however, permitted.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

Glazebrook J  [1]

Hammond J   [87]

O’Regan and Robertson JJ  [280]

Baragwanath J  [291]

Appendix I: Statutory Provisions

Appendix II: Pleadings

Appendix III: Cases on Leave Provisions

GLAZEBROOK J

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction  [1]
Retrospectivity  [2]
Extent of requirement to seek leave and procedure to be followed       [14]

The parties’ submissions  [14]
Associate Judge Abbott’s approach  [16]
Simon France J’s approach  [17]
Hammond J’s approach  [20]
The legislation  [23]

Issues  [25]

What is the correct approach to interpreting immunity and

associated leave provisions?  [27]

Are the immunity and leave provisions limited to committals
 or acts otherwise expressly covered by the legislation?
  [31]

Is the interpretation of the phrase “in pursuance or intended
pursuance of any of the provisions of this Act” coloured by the
exclusions from the immunity?
  [35]

Should the CHFA’s formulation of the test be accepted?  [43]

What is the correct interpretation of the phrase “acts in
pursuance or intended pursuance” of the provisions of the Act?
     [48]

Summary of the test to be applied  [62]

What is the procedure that should be followed in these cases?             [63]

How does my suggested procedure differ from that of the other
Judges?
  [70]

What should happen in these appeals?  [77]

Result and costs  [81]

Introduction

[1]       Hammond J’s judgment sets out the background to these appeals and identifies the issues.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Crown Health Financing Agency v P and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NZCA 362
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case concerns the scope and application of immunity and leave provisions contained in sections 6 of the Mental Health Amendment Act 1935 (MHAA 1935) and 124 of the Mental Health Act 1969 (MHA 1969). The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether these provisions apply to informal patients, whether they are limited to acts relating to the committal process or acts expressly authorised by the legislation, and what is the correct interpretation of the phrase "acts in pursuance or intended pursuance of the provisions of the Act". The Court also had to decide on the appropriate procedure to be followed in these cases.

The Court held that the immunity and leave provisions apply to informal patients and cover more than acts or omissions in the committal process or acts or omissions expressly authorised by the legislation. The Court rejected the Crown Health Financing Agency's formulation of the test for whether leave is required, but agreed with its proposition that the provisions should be interpreted in a manner that does not rob them of all force. The Court concluded that the correct interpretation of the phrase "acts in pursuance or intended pursuance of the provisions of the Act" includes acts and omissions that relate to the committal process, to the running of the institution, to the care and treatment of patients or to necessary auxiliaries, such as control and the protection of those both inside and outside of the institution. The Court also held that the appropriate procedure is for a defendant to apply to have the leave question tried as a preliminary issue and/or to strike out the proceedings, but that the Court should not grant a conditional stay in all cases.

The Court allowed the appeal of the Crown Health Financing Agency to the extent set out in the judgment, dismissed the appeals of the claimants, and remitted the proceedings before the High Court for resolution in terms of this judgment. There were no costs orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.