Jin v North Shore District Court

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV2012-404-004905 [2013] NZHC 810

BETWEEN  RUJING JIN Applicant

ANDNORTH SHORE DISTRICT COURT First Respondent

ANDYASUKI KONISHI AND MAKIKO KONISHI Second Respondents

Hearing:         (On the papers) Counsel:          Y Lee for the Applicant

First Respondent abiding decision of the Court
D B Hickson for the Second Respondent

Judgment:      18 April 2013

[COSTS] JUDGMENT OF WYLIE J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Wylie

On 18 April 2013 at 4.00 pm

Pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date:

Distribution:

Y Lee: lee1955@gmail.com
North Shore District Court:

D B Hickson: doughickson@vodafone.co.nz

JIN V NORTH SHORE DISTRICT COURT & ORS HC AK CIV 2012-404-004905 [18 April 2013]

[1]      I refer to my reserved judgment dated 19 February 2013.  In that judgment, I held that Ms Jin’s application for review failed.  Indeed, I recorded my view that it was misconceived from the outset.  I recorded that the second respondents, Mr and Mrs Konishi, were entitled to their costs and disbursements, and I invited the parties to file memoranda in that regard.

[2]      Memoranda have now been filed.

[3]      I should record that Ms Jin has filed a notice of appeal against my judgment. That notice of appeal is dated 18 March 2013.   Notwithstanding the filing of the notice of appeal, I am issuing this costs judgment.  In my view, it is appropriate to do so, so that both my substantive decision and my judgment in relation to costs can be put before the Court of Appeal.

[4]      Mr and Mrs Konishi, through their counsel, Mr Hickson, seek indemnity costs against Ms Jin, together with GST and disbursements.   The total amount claimed is $22,262.24.   In addition, they seek $3,306.24, GST inclusive, for preparation of the costs memorandum.

[5]      Ms Jin, through her counsel, Mr Lee, resists the application for indemnity costs.  She argues that an award of indemnity costs is not justified, and complains that the second respondents have not listed the relevant steps contained in Schedule 3 to the High Court Rules, and that therefore, she is not able to respond to how the costs were calculated.  Ms Jin accepts that costs should follow the event, but argues that there are unusual circumstances.  She submits that the respondents have failed to attend alternative dispute resolution.  Further, she argues that the second respondents were not prejudiced by the review.  It is also argued that the second respondents have never sought a refund of the deposit from the stakeholder — the real estate agent. She submits that costs should be reserved, as the substantive matter has not as yet been argued.

[6]      In my judgment, it is appropriate to award costs now.  The judicial review proceedings have been determined, subject to the appeal I have noted above.  It is not necessary to set out the steps detailed in Schedule 3 when indemnity costs are

sought, although a failure to do so could cause difficulty if indemnity costs are declined.   There are no unusual circumstances…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jin v North Shore District Court and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 810
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Jin v North Shore District Court and Others involves Rujing Jin, who filed an application for review against the North Shore District Court and the second respondents, Yasuki and Makiko Konishi. The dispute stems from the District Court's case management directions, which Ms Jin sought to review, arguing that they were ultra vires. The High Court was tasked with deciding whether the application for review was justified and whether it warranted an award of indemnity costs.

The court examined the merits of the review application and found it to be misconceived from the outset. Ms Jin's claims lacked a reasonable basis, and the case management directions were not beyond the authority of the District Court. Additionally, Ms Jin's actions in pursuing the review were vexatious, frivolous, and improper, as she continued despite warnings from the respondents' counsel that costs would be sought against her if she proceeded. The court noted procedural errors in the way Ms Jin served the judicial review proceedings and highlighted deficiencies in the pleadings and affidavits. The court also observed that Ms Jin's attempts to review unpleaded decisions and her refusal to resolve the dispute by refunding the deposit added to the proceedings' inappropriateness.

Given that the review proceedings were unnecessary and caused significant costs to the respondents, the court found that an award of indemnity costs was appropriate. The court considered the detailed invoices provided by the respondents' counsel, which included charges for time spent, GST, and disbursements. The court concluded that the costs claimed were reasonable and that the respondents should not bear the financial burden of defending these unnecessary proceedings. As a result, the court ordered Ms Jin to pay the respondents $25,568.48 in costs and disbursements.