Insight Legal Trustee Co Ltd v Stokes

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA511/2012
[2013] NZCA 148

BETWEEN  INSIGHT LEGAL TRUSTEE COMPANY LIMITED AND GRAHAME HEENAN AS TRUSTEES OF THE R M COLEBROOK FAMILY TRUST
First Appellants

AND  ELAINE COLEBROOKE
Second Appellant

AND  BRYAN STOKES, ALEXANDRA STROKES AND OWEN WILLIAMS AS TRUSTEES OF THE STOKES FAMILY TRUST
Respondents

Hearing:         19 March 2013

Court:             Ellen France, Randerson and Harrison JJ

Counsel:         J M McCartney QC and P G Watts for Appellants
A J Steele and J P Scott for Respondents

Judgment:      9 May 2013 at 2.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeal is allowed.  The judgment in the High Court is set aside.

B        The cross-appeal is dismissed.

CThe proceeding is remitted to the High Court for determination of the issues as set out in [64].

DThe respondents are directed to file an amended statement of claim on the terms set out in [65].

E        The respondents are to pay one set of costs to the first appellants for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements. 

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Harrison J)

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction

Facts
The Stokes’ claim

Issues

(a)          Capacity

(i)     High Court

(ii)   RMCFT’s appeal grounds

(b)          Consent

(c)          Indemnity

Decision

Result

Introduction

  1. The Stokes Family Trust (the Stokes) signed an agreement to sell their residential property in Bucklands Beach Road, Auckland to a purchaser described as “E M Colebrook or nominee”.  The sale price was $1.8 million.  Elaine Colebrook signed the agreement as “E M Colebrook”.  However, Mrs Colebrook failed to settle on the due date.  The Stokes cancelled and resold the property at a substantial loss.  They obtained judgment against Mrs Colebrook for the shortfall of $943,033.36.  She is insolvent and unable to pay. 

  2. That story is not uncommon.  However, a different dimension is introduced by the fact that when she signed the agreement Mrs Colebrook was a trustee of the R M Colebrook Family Trust (the RMCFT).  The other trustee was her sister, Shona Carr.  After learning of this fact, the Stokes issued a proceeding against the trustees of the RMCFT for $943,033.36, alleging that (a) Mrs Colebrook signed the agreement in her capacity as a trustee of the RMCFT; (b) she was acting with the authority of and as agent for Ms Carr; and (c) the Stokes had a consequential right of recovery against the trust’s assets.

  3. Ellis J found for the Stokes on all three elements following a trial in the High Court.[1]  The RMCFT trustees now appeal.

  4. Before examining the merits, we must record a central feature of the argument in this Court.  While the Stokes support Ellis J’s primary finding of fact on capacity, they concede that the second finding on agency cannot be sustained.  So, in order to resist the substance of the RMCFT’s appeal, the Stokes have cross-appealed seeking to uphold the judgment on other grounds.  In fairness to Ellis J,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Insight Legal Trustee Co Ltd v Stokes and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZCA 148
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Insight Legal Trustee Company Limited and Grahame Heenan as Trustees of the R M Colebrook Family Trust (the RMCFT) appeal against a decision of the High Court that they are liable to the Stokes Family Trust for a shortfall of $943,033.36, as a result of Elaine Colebrook’s failure to settle a sale of residential property in Bucklands Beach Road, Auckland. The RMCFT trustees contend that the sale agreement was signed by Mrs Colebrook in her personal capacity and not as trustee of the RMCFT. The Stokes cross-appeal on the basis that the RMCFT trustees are liable for the shortfall regardless of the capacity in which Mrs Colebrook signed the agreement, on the ground that Shona Carr, the other RMCFT trustee, subsequently consented to the purchase. The Court of Appeal allows the RMCFT’s appeal and dismisses the Stokes’ cross-appeal. The proceeding is remitted to the High Court for determination of the issues of whether Ms Carr consented to Mrs Colebrook’s purchase of the Bucklands Beach Road property for and on behalf of the RMCFT; and if so, whether Mrs Colebrook is entitled to an indemnity from the assets of the RMCFT for her liability to the Stokes. The Court of Appeal upholds the finding that Mrs Colebrook signed the Bucklands Beach Road agreement in her capacity as a trustee of the RMCFT. The Stokes are directed to file an amended statement of claim in the High Court within 30 days, with leave reserved to the RMCFT to file a statement of defence pleading affirmatively that Mrs Colebrook is not entitled to be indemnified for her liability, if any, from the assets of the RMCFT. Costs must follow the event. The Stokes are to pay one set of costs to the RMCFT for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

The Court of Appeal observes that the case proceeded to trial on the basis of some confusion and misunderstanding. First, the Stokes’ pleadings relied expressly on agency. Second, the RMCFT’s defence was directed to countering that reliance by raising the undisclosed agency rule. Third, the allegation of Ms Carr’s subsequent consent was not pleaded and was not expressly raised until the Stokes’ counsel’s closing address. The Court of Appeal is not in a position to find that Ms Carr, acting in her capacity as a RMCFT trustee, gave retrospective consent to Mrs Colebrook’s purchase of the Bucklands Beach Road property in the same capacity. The evidence is incomplete and unsatisfactory. The Court of Appeal is satisfied that that result would lead to a real risk of an injustice. The Stokes would be deprived of an opportunity to argue and have determined their claim that Ms Carr consented to Mrs Colebrook’s purchase of Bucklands Beach Road for the RMCFT because of a failure to plead this essential element of the claim. The proceeding is remitted to the High Court for determination of the issue of whether Ms Carr consented to Mrs Colebrook’s purchase of the Bucklands Beach Road property for and on behalf of the RMCFT.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.