Sardan Trustees Limited v Magson's Hardware Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2013-404-4684 [2014] NZHC 460

UNDER The Construction Contracts Act 2002

BETWEEN

SARDAN TRUSTEES LIMITED Plaintiff

AND

MAGSON'S HARDWARE LIMITED Defendant

Hearing: 20 February 2014

Appearances:

Mr J Heard for plaintiff
Mr D Smyth for Defendant

Judgment:

13 March 2014

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE J P DOOGUE

This judgment was delivered by me on

13.03.14 at 5 pm, pursuant to

Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

SARDAN TRUSTEES LIMITED v MAGSON'S HARDWARE LIMITED [2014] NZHC 460 [13 March 2014]

Introduction

[1]      The present dispute arises out of events that occurred in 2013.  The plaintiff, Sardan Trustee Limited, is the trustee for a trading trust called Dansar Investment Trust (“Dansar”).  Dansar carried on business which included excavation, laying of building slabs and related concrete work.   The defendant is Magsons Hardware Limited  (“Magsons”), trading  as  Mitre 10  Mega in  Botany.    Dansar  wished  to contract with Starplus Homes Developments Limited (“Starplus”), a company that developed residential homes in South Auckland.

[2]      Mr Desmond Sharp, the agent for Dansar, was aware that other contractors had  come  to  an  arrangement  with  Magsons.    Magsons  was  not  only  a  general supplier of materials to Starplus but also acted as a financier of Starplus’ contracts with building and related trade contractors which it employed.  The basic structure of the arrangement was that Magsons would contract to accept responsibility for paying contractors within 30 days of invoice which was a more attractive arrangement from the perspective of contractors than that which was offered by Starplus.   Starplus’ terms of payment provided for contractors not to receive payment before 90 days after invoicing.

[3]      It follows that a builder who contracted under Magsons’ arrangement would perform work for Starplus but invoice Magsons who would then recover the amount it had paid from Starplus.   It is not known what the overall arrangement between Magsons and Starplus involved but so far as the payment of contractors was concerned, Magsons would receive a margin comprised of a deduction from the gross amount that was payable to the contractor.  In addition, Starplus was required to pay an additional margin over and above the invoice value to Magsons.

[4]      Dansar claims that it provided services on 28 different sites which were being developed by Starplus with the total value of the work which it performed being

$267,492.44.   It claims the outstanding amount of $218,123.56 and has issued payment claims under the Construction Contracts Act 2002 (“CCCA”).   It further alleges in the statement of claim that Magsons did not file a payment schedule disputing the amounts claimed.

[5]      The position that Magsons takes is that there is no contract between the plaintiff Sardan and Magsons.   Instead, Magsons entered into certain individual construction  contracts  with  Mr Sharp, trading as  Dansar.    I interpolate that  the significance of this contention is that Magsons is not prepared to recognise that any contract it entered into was with the plaintiff.

[6]      To continue, Magsons asserts in its notice of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sardan Trustees Limited v Magson's Hardware Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 460
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The present dispute arose out of events that occurred in 2013. The plaintiff, Sardan Trustee Limited, is the trustee for a trading trust called Dansar Investment Trust. Dansar carried on business which included excavation, laying of building slabs and related concrete work. The defendant is Magsons Hardware Limited, trading as Mitre 10 Mega in Botany. Dansar wished to contract with Starplus Homes Developments Limited, a company that developed residential homes in South Auckland. Dansar claims that it provided services on 28 different sites which were being developed by Starplus with the total value of the work which it performed being $267,492.44. It claims the outstanding amount of $218,123.56 and has issued payment claims under the Construction Contracts Act 2002. It further alleges in the statement of claim that Magsons did not file a payment schedule disputing the amounts claimed. Magsons asserts in its notice of opposition that there is no contract between the plaintiff Sardan and Magsons. Instead, Magsons entered into certain individual construction contracts with Mr Sharp, trading as Dansar. The court held that the evidence before the court did not allow it to find that Magsons did not have an arguable defence to all or part of the claims which it brings as part of its summary judgment application. The proceeding was classified as non-complex, and a first case management conference was to be allocated not earlier than 17 April 2014. The parties were to confer concerning the question of costs and, if they were not able to agree, were to file memoranda not exceeding five pages on each side within 10 working days of the date of this judgment.