Hampton v Canterbury Regional Council (Environment Canterbury)

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA745/2013
[2015] NZCA 509

BETWEEN

SIMON JOHN MOFFATT HAMPTON
Appellant

AND

CANTERBURY REGIONAL COUNCIL (ENVIRONMENT CANTERBURY)
Respondent

Hearing:

5 May 2015  

Court:

Wild, Miller and Cooper JJ

Counsel:

I G Hunt for Appellant
P J Shamy and M C Dysart for Respondent

Judgment:

2 November 2015 at 11.30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for leave to adduce fresh evidence is granted.

BThe appeal is dismissed.

CThe respondent is entitled to costs calculated for a standard appeal on a band A basis, together with usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Cooper J)

Table of Contents

Para No
Introduction  [1]
Regional control of water  [6]        
Simon’s resource consents and related Court proceedings                  [17]
Robert’s resource consent (CRC110662)  [29]
The High Court judgment  [49]
Simons’ subsequent consent (CRC042233.4)  [62]
The appeal
      The arguments on appeal  [67]
      Analysis  [76]
Result  [114]

Introduction

  1. The appellant, Simon Hampton, commenced a proceeding in the High Court at Christchurch challenging the decision of the respondent, the Canterbury Regional Council (the Council) to grant a water permit to Robert Hampton.[1]  Simon Hampton and Robert Hampton are cousins, who occupy farm properties on Back Track, Barrhill between Rakaia and Methven on the Canterbury Plains.[2]  Parts of their respective farms adjoin each other.

    [1]Hampton v Canterbury Regional Council [2013] NZHC 2433, [2013] NZRMA 482 [High Court judgment].

    [2]We will differentiate between them by using their first names.

  2. As a result of a series of resource consent applications, Simon obtained a water right allowing him to take water to irrigate Robert’s land.  However, the men could not reach agreement on terms on which the water could be taken and used on Robert’s land. 

  3. Because water in the area is already over-allocated, Robert could not simply get a consent to take additional water.  The Council adopted an elegant solution.  It granted Robert a right to take water to the extent that Simon’s right to use water to irrigate Robert’s land was not being exercised.  Simon now complains that this decision interfered with his property rights, specifically his right to sell his water right.  Simon claims the Council’s decision was affected by various errors of law, breached his legitimate expectations, amounted to a derogation from the right conferred by the permit granted to him, and was affected by predetermination and bias.  The substance of his position is that Robert has only two options: to buy Simon’s right or, there being no new water available, to do without. 

  4. All of these claims were rejected by Gendall J in the High Court, and Simon now appeals to this Court. 

  5. Before setting out the relevant facts, it is appropriate to say something about the regime in place in the Canterbury region for the allocation of rights in respect of water, which reflects the scarcity of the resource.

Regional control of water

  1. For most of the period relevant to this appeal, the Council had a proposed Natural Resources Regional Plan (the PRP) which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hampton v Canterbury Regional Council (Environment Canterbur... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZCA 509
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Simon Hampton sought review of a decision by the Canterbury Regional Council (the Council) to grant a resource consent to Robert Hampton to take water to irrigate his land. Simon and Robert own adjacent farms in Canterbury. Simon had obtained a consent to take water from a bore on his land and use it to irrigate Robert’s land. However, the two men could not agree on the terms on which that water could be taken and used. As a result, Robert applied for and was granted his own resource consent. The consent allowed Robert to take water to irrigate his land only if Simon was not using his consent to irrigate Robert’s land. Simon challenged the grant of Robert’s consent in the High Court and his claim was dismissed. Simon appeals to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and Simon’s claims were rejected. The Court of Appeal held that Simon’s consent was only exercisable to the extent that Robert’s consent was not being exercised. The Court of Appeal held that the grant of Robert’s consent did not amount to a derogation from the grant of Simon’s consent, nor was it a breach of a legitimate expectation. The Court of Appeal held that Simon had no property right in the water permit and that the grant of Robert’s consent did not affect any right Simon had under the Resource Management Act 1991. The Court of Appeal held that the grant of Robert’s consent did not affect any right Simon had under the Act. The Court of Appeal held that Simon’s claim for damages was not available to him. The appeal was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Simon Hampton applied for a water permit to irrigate land, which included a portion of Robert Hampton's adjacent land. Simon obtained the permit (CRC042233) to irrigate 173 hectares, including 88 hectares belonging to Robert. Simon and Robert could not agree on terms for the water use on Robert's land. Robert applied for his own water permit (CRC110662) to irrigate his land, which the Council granted. The permit for Robert could only be exercised if Simon's permit was not being used for irrigation on Robert's land. Simon argued that the grant of Robert's permit interfered with his rights under his own permit and that the Council's decision was affected by various errors of law, breached his legitimate expectations, amounted to a derogation from the grant of his permit, and was affected by predetermination and bias.

Simon filed an application in the High Court challenging the Council's decision to grant Robert a water permit. Simon's claims in the High Court included errors of law, derogation from grant, breach of legitimate expectation, failure to take relevant matters into account, taking irrelevant matters into account, predetermination, bias, and unreasonableness. The High Court dismissed Simon's application for review. Simon then appealed to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the grant of Robert's consent (CRC110662) substantially interfere with Simon's rights pursuant to his own consent (CRC042233)?
2. Did the grant of Robert's consent (CRC110662) result in an interference with and derogation from the grant of Simon's consent (CRC042233)?

Held
1. The Court granted the application for leave to adduce fresh evidence.
2. The Court dismissed the appeal.
3. The respondent is entitled to costs calculated for a standard appeal on a band A basis, together with usual disbursements.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the arguments presented by Simon Hampton that the grant of Robert Hampton's resource consent (CRC110662) substantially interfered with his rights under his own consent (CRC042233.3) and resulted in a derogation from the grant of his consent. The Court of Appeal found that Simon's resource consent (CRC042233.3) was subject to specific conditions that limited its use to Robert's land, and Simon had agreed to these conditions when they were imposed. The Court of Appeal held that the grant of Robert's consent (CRC110662) did not interfere with or derogate from Simon's consent (CRC042233.3), as both consents operated within the statutory regime established by the Resource Management Act 1991 (the Act). The Court of Appeal noted that a resource consent is neither real nor personal property, and the Act excludes certain common law incidents of property ownership. The Court of Appeal found that Simon's inability to charge Robert for water taken under CRC110662 and used on Robert's land did not constitute a resource management issue. The Court of Appeal concluded that Simon's claims, including those of bias and predetermination, were properly dismissed by the High Court and that it was unnecessary to consider the issue of damages. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that the grant of a resource consent does not automatically confer a property right, and the statutory regime established by the Act governs the allocation and use of water resources.