Environmental Law Initative v Canterbury Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2024-409-409

[2025] NZHC 2515

BETWEEN

THE ENVIRONMENTAL LAW INITATIVE

Applicant

AND

CANTERBURY REGIONAL COUNCIL

First Respondent

MHV WATER LIMITED

Second Respondent

Hearing: 19 and 20 May 2025

Appearances:

A McDonald and K Calder for Applicant

P A C Maw and K T Dickson for First Respondent
B G Williams and R E Robilliard for Second Respondent

Judgment:

1 September 2025


JUDGMENT OF MANDER J


This judgment was delivered by me on 1 September 2025 at 3 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules 2016

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date:     .

THE ENVIRONMENTAL LAW INITATIVE v CANTERBURY REGIONAL COUNCIL & ANOR [2025]

NZHC 2515 [1 September 2025]

Contents

Background........................................................................................................... [4]

Planning framework  [7]

The discharge consent......................................................................................... [13]
Description of the affected environment............................................................. [19]

Ground water  [20]

Surface water  [21]
The discharge consent decision........................................................................... [24]
Grounds for judicial review................................................................................. [29]

The notification decision..................................................................................... [31]

The legislative framework  [32]

Recommendation analysis  [33]

Outcome of the decision  [37]
ELI’s challenge to the notification decision  [38]

The respondents’ position  [41]
Council’s request for further information  [42]

Analysis  [62]

Conclusion  [73]

Alleged failure to consider special circumstance as a mandatory relevant consideration    [75]

Analysis  [81]

Conclusion  [91]
Failure by the Commissioner to consider impact on drinking water supplies     [92]
Alleged misapplication of s 107 of the RMA...................................................... [97]

Relevant statutory provisions  [100]

The challenge  [103]

The Council’s position  [110]
MHV’s position  [111]

Analysis  [115]

Conclusion  [134]

Alleged failure to consider relevant plans and policies..................................... [137]
ELI’s argument  [139]

The NZCPS  [141]

The RCEP  [152]

Canterbury Land and Water Regional Plan  [156]

The respondent’s argument  [161]

The coastal environment  [162]

To discharge  [166]

MHV’s application considered under different planning framework            [171] Different factual findings  [176]

Analysis  [187]

Conclusion  [203]
Failure to revoke other decisions....................................................................... [212]

Conclusion  [240]

Relief................................................................................................................. [241]

Overall conclusions............................................................................................ [254]

Result................................................................................................................. [259]

Costs.................................................................................................................. [260]

[1]    MHV Water Ltd (MHV) is a farmer owned cooperative that operates an irrigation scheme in the Hinds/Hekeao Plains area of Canterbury. It receives and supplies water to its shareholders. Pursuant to the decision of an independent hearings commissioner (the Commissioner) acting under delegated authority, the Canterbury Regional Council (the Council) granted MHV’s application for a resource consent to discharge nutrients onto or into land from farming activities in respect of properties located between the Hinds/Hekeao Plains area (the discharge consent).

[2]    The Environmental Law Initiative (ELI)1 has applied to judicially review the Council’s decisions regarding its notification of the application for the discharge consent and its substantive decision to grant the consent. It claims the Council made errors of law in making its notification decision and failed to comply with the requirements of the Resource Management Act 1991 (the RMA). It also alleges the Council failed to consider and apply relevant planning instruments. As a further cause of action, it claims the Council erroneously failed to revoke the discharge consent in the wake of a decision of this Court setting aside a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Environmental Law Initative v Canterbury Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NZHC 2515
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Environmental Law Initiative (ELI) sought to judicially review the Canterbury Regional Council's (Council) decisions regarding its notification of MHV Water Ltd's (MHV) application for a resource consent to discharge nutrients onto or into land from farming activities in the Hinds/Hekeao Plains area of Canterbury and its substantive decision to grant the consent (the discharge consent). It was alleged the Council made errors of law in making its notification decision and failed to comply with the requirements of the Resource Management Act 1991 (the RMA). ELI also alleged the Council failed to consider and apply relevant planning instruments in its decision to grant the discharge consent. As a further cause of action, it was claimed the Council erroneously failed to revoke the discharge consent in the wake of a decision of this Court setting aside a similar consent issued in respect of another irrigation scheme. ELI sought declarations and orders quashing the notification and discharge decisions, and a declaration that its decision not to revoke MHV's consent was unlawful.

The Council and MHV maintained the notification decision was made in accordance with the RMA. In respect of its decision to grant the discharge consent, the Council abided the Court's decision regarding whether it correctly applied s 107 of the RMA. However, both respondents submitted there were important differences between this case and the circumstances of the other invalidated discharge consent. MHV contended the discharge consent was lawfully issued and supported the Council's opposition to ELI's claim that it acted unlawfully by not revoking the consent.

The Court found no error of law in the Council's notification decision. It was satisfied the Council acquired sufficient relevant information and knowledge to assess the effects of the issues identified by ELI which had been the subject of the s 92 requests and that it was sufficiently informed to determine this aspect of the resource consent application did not give rise to special circumstances that warranted public or further limited notification. The Court found the Commissioner made a material error of law in her approach to the application of s 107 of the RMA, as that provision was enacted at the time of her decision. However, the Court declined to grant relief because the outcome of any reconsideration of the consent application would inevitably lead to the same result. While the Court accepted the Commissioner erred in omitting to take into account various relevant provisions of coastal policy and planning instruments, it did not consider that error constituted a material error of law that was sufficient to invalidate the consent authority's decision to grant the discharge consent. The Council's decision not to revisit or revoke its previous decision to grant a resource consent that was made in the exercise of its jurisdiction as a consent authority was lawful. The Court declined to make any declaration regarding the application of s 46 of the Legislation Act to resource consent decisions.

The application for judicial review was dismissed. Costs were awarded to lie where they fell.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established