Gabler v Queenstown Lakes District Council

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND INVERCARGILL REGISTRY

CIV-2016-425-84 [2017] NZHC 2086

UNDER

The Judicature Amendment Act 1972 and

Part 30 of the High Court Rules

IN THE MATTER OF

An application for judicial review

BETWEEN

JONATHAN PAUL GABLER, JENN BESTWICK AND GLENORCHY HOMESTEAD LIMITED

Applicants

AND

QUEENSTOWN LAKES DISTRICT COUNCIL

First Respondent

THE PLAYGROUND LIMITED Second Respondent

Hearing:

13 December 2016

and resumed hearing 16 August 2017

Appearances:

M J Slyfield for Applicants
J C Campbell and A H Balme for First Respondent

Judgment:

29 August 2017

JUDGMENT OF NICHOLAS DAVIDSON J

GABLER & ORS v QUEENSTOWN LAKES DISTRICT COUNCIL & ANOR [2017] NZHC 2086 [29 August 2017]

TABLE OF CONTENTS

A.       INTRODUCTION  ……………………………………………….     [1]

The genesis of this judicial review ………………………………..      [6] Notification principles …………………………………………….   [10] Grounds of this judicial review ……………………………………   [11] A late stage consideration …………………………………………   [14]

B.       THE APPLICATION FOR RESOURCE CONSENT ……………..  [16]

The application …………………………………………………....   [16] Council process ……………………………………………………   [24] Dr Chiles  ………………………………………………………….   [30]

C.       THE DECISIONS …………………………………………………   [32]

Summary …………………………………………………………..   [32]

Limited notification – “Effects on persons”  ………………………  [41]

D.       LAW ………………………………………………………………   [44]

Schedule 4 …………………………………………………………   [45] The obligation to inform the consent authority ……………………   [46] “Discount Brands” …………………………………………………  [47] “Coro Mainstreet”  ………………………………………………     [48] Supreme Court ……………………………………………………..   [54] Discussion ………………………………………………………….  [58]

E.        ANALYSIS ………………………………………………………..   [67]

Approach …………………………………………………………..   [67] The s 92 request for further information, and s 95C of the Act ……  [70] Relevance of noise limits …………………………………………..   [81] “Less than minor” and reliance on Dr Chiles’ report ……………..  [90] Rural Amenity …………………………………………………….    [96] The “lens” used by the Council …………………………………..  [101] Conclusion as to sufficiency of relevant information …………….   [102] The strictness of s 95C ……………………………………………. [105] Exercise of discretion on judicial review …………………………  [107]

F.        CONCLUSION AND DISPOSITION …………………………..    [109]

Disposition ……………………………………………………….   [112]

A.      INTRODUCTION

[1]      This application for judicial review challenges the decision of Queenstown Lakes District Council (“QLDC” or “the Council”) made on 10 June 2016 not to serve limited notice or publicly notify an application for resource consent made by the second respondent, The Playground Ltd (“The Playground”).

[2]      The  outcome  of  this  review  thus  bears  directly  on  the  resource  consent granted the same day to establish commercial recreational activities at Alan Reids Rd in the Wakatipu Basin at the foot of Coronet Peak, on land zoned Rural General in the District Plan.

[3]      The consented activities, which the Court is told have commenced, include paintball, archery combat, a high ropes course, bubble soccer, mountain boarding and sumo wrestling.   The infrastructure is not significant in the context of this judicial review.  The proposal includes a car park.  Hours of operation are restricted to daylight, seven days a week, with customer and vehicle movement limits per day.

[4]      The applicants in this judicial review own or occupy land to the south and west of The Playground’s site.  Mr Gabler has consent for a residential building close to the southwest corner of the subject property.  Ms Bestwick, as trustee, owns…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gabler v Queenstown Lakes District Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 2086
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Jonathan Paul Gabler, Jenn Bestwick and Glenorchy Homestead Ltd, challenge the Queenstown Lakes District Council's decision not to serve limited notice or publicly notify an application for resource consent made by The Playground Ltd. The consent granted commercial recreational activities at Alan Reids Rd in the Wakatipu Basin at the foot of Coronet Peak, on land zoned Rural General in the District Plan. The activities include paintball, archery combat, a high ropes course, bubble soccer, mountain boarding and sumo wrestling. The proposal includes a car park. Hours of operation are restricted to daylight, seven days a week, with customer and vehicle movement limits per day. The applicants own or occupy land to the south and west of The Playground's site. The Council's decision not to publicly notify the application was made under s 95A(1) of the Resource Management Act 1991. The Council also decided that no person was an “affected person” for the purposes of limited notification pursuant to s 95B(1) and 95E(1) of the Act. The applicants say they and others are “affected persons” and should have been served with the application by way of limited notification so they might participate in the consenting process. Mr Slyfield, counsel for the applicants, submits that the notification decision was flawed and should be declared invalid, as should the resource consent, and the Council needs to return to first base and address it properly before any decision is made as to notification and whether consent should be granted. At the heart of the applicants’ case is the contention that the Council did not have sufficient relevant information before it to reach a decision about notification and the consent, in particular about the effects of noise from the activities, and as a result it made an error of law, or its decision was otherwise unreasonable. The relief sought is comprised of declarations of invalidity and quashing of decisions as to notification and consent. The Court found that the Council applied the correct test of “less than minor” effects for the non-notification decision. Although the s 92 request for further information should have been the subject of a particularised and better reply as to an overview of the sources of noise, and their effect, the Council was by then aware of the sources of noise, site characteristics, and separation distances. It understood there was no obvious noise making equipment, and the sound emitting qualities of each activity. The discrete location, separation distances, screening, the ambient sound, the noise limits, time of operation and numbers of patrons and their activities, and traffic noise were all brought to account. It did overall have adequate information on which to make a relevant and informed decision. The Decision reflects consideration of all the factors which were relevant. Nothing “missing” has been identified. The applicants and others did put the Council on notice with their expressed concerns and they were addressed in a considered way. This helped the Council in its decision making. The Council was entitled to bring the noise limit to account. That was relevant, whether the permitted baseline test was adopted or not. It allowed Dr Chiles to express an opinion which involved his recognition as an expert of the noise made by paintball guns, and assisted the Council to reach a decision. Sound effects without the limits were not “disregarded” but recognised for what they were. More than five people will “play” at The Playground. They will make noise. It will at times be heard. But if it is, it will be within the noise limit or The Playground should not be allowed to operate. The Council had sufficient relevant information to make its decision, brought to account no irrelevant considerations, applied the correct test, and the decision was reasonable. Section 95C does not operate to require public notification in this case. The application for judicial review is dismissed. Costs are reserved, but I observe that this is a case where the Council by its process left itself open to challenge, which will influence the outcome of any costs application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.