Green & McCahill Holdings Ltd v Ara Weiti Development Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA147/2021
 [2022] NZCA 218

BETWEEN

GREEN & MCCAHILL HOLDINGS LIMITED
Appellant

AND

ARA WEITI DEVELOPMENT LIMITED
First Respondent

ARA WEITI BAY DEVELOPMENT LIMITED
Second Respondent

Hearing:

20 October 2021 (further submissions received 27 January, 8 and 25 February, 5 March, 6 and 7 April 2022)

Court:

Kós P, Cooper and Brown JJ

Counsel:

J W A Johnson, K C Francis and W L Porter for Appellant
D J Chisholm QC, M H L Morrison and L R Green for Respondents

Judgment:

1 June 2022 at 9 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appellant’s application for leave to adduce further evidence is granted.

BThe appeal is allowed.

CThe re-imposition of caveats and the conditions therefor are remitted to the High Court.

DCosts are reserved.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Kós P)

Table of Contents
Para No

Background
The contracts

Master agreement for the sale of Weiti Station
Development agreement
Limited partnership agreement
Quadripartite deeds

The relationship breaks down
The caveats imposed
The case made before the Associate Judge for a proprietary remedy
The judgment appealed
The caveats lapse
Issues on appeal
Some issues of timing, further evidence and background material
Issue 1:  Is liability of the respondents for knowing receipt reasonably arguable?

Submissions
Discussion

(1)    Principles governing applications to sustain caveats

(2)    Did Mr Williams arguably owe fiduciary duties to GMHL?

(3)    Did any fiduciary duties arguably exist still as at June 2020?

(4)    Were the properties arguably subject to a trust as at June 2020?

(5)    Was the transfer to the respondents arguably in breach of trust?

Conclusion

Issue 2:  Is primary liability of the respondents as a fiduciary reasonably arguable?

Discussion

Issue 3:  If a proprietary right is reasonably arguable, should discretion be exercised against a re-imposition of the caveats?
Issue 4:  If the caveats are sustainable, what relief should be ordered in this appeal?
Costs
Result

[2]
[17]
[18]
[21]
[23]
[28]
[34]
[46]

[48]
[53]
[61]
[62]
[63]

[68]
[69]
[78]
[80]
[88]

[101]

[109]

[122]
[123]

[124]
[126]

[127]

[129]
[133]
[134]

  1. The appellant, a participant in a complex property development, contributes the land, which is then mortgaged to a third-party lender.  The development fails.  The lender sells the land by mortgagee sale to the respondents, who are associates of the other participant in the development.  The question in this appeal is whether the appellant may now sustain caveats asserting a proprietary interest in its former land, based upon an alleged constructive trust.

Background

  1. The background is set out in some detail in the judgment appealed.[1]  The essential facts are uncontested, although the inferences to be drawn from them are.  We need only provide a summary at this stage.  In subsequent sections of the judgment we will look in more detail at the contracts entered between 2010 and 2018 governing the respective parties’ interests in the Weiti land development project, the breakdown of their relationship, and the caveats…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Green & McCahill Holdings Ltd v Ara Weiti Development Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZCA 218
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Green & McCahill Holdings Ltd (GMHL) and Ara Weiti Development Ltd (AWDL) were involved in a legal dispute concerning the development of a property at Weiti Station. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The central issue revolved around whether Williams Land, a party to the development agreement, breached its obligations by not reporting to Liu on the progress of the development and by not adequately cooperating with Liu. This dispute arose from a complex web of agreements, including a master agreement, a development agreement, and a limited partnership agreement.

The court had to determine if Williams Land's failure to report and cooperate constituted a breach of contract. Key clauses in the agreements, particularly those in the master agreement and the development agreement, outlined specific reporting and cooperation obligations. Additionally, the court examined the extent to which Williams Land's actions might have violated the fiduciary duties expected in their partnership with Liu.

The court concluded that Williams Land did not breach its obligations under the agreements. The reporting requirements were found to be discretionary rather than mandatory, and the cooperation clause was deemed too broad and vague to impose specific duties. The court also noted that the agreements explicitly excluded fiduciary duties between the partners, further supporting the conclusion that Williams Land's actions did not constitute a breach.

As a result, the court ruled in favour of Williams Land, finding no breach of contract. The final orders reflect this decision, dismissing GMHL's claims against AWDL.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Williams Land is obligated to report to Liu monthly on development progress (cl 9). Clause 13 sets out other general obligations, including a sub-clause regarding cooperation between Liu and Williams Land:Co-Operation: Liu and [Williams Land] will co-operate with each other to enable each to obtain the benefits of this agreement and Liu and [Williams Land] will do all things reasonably necessary to give effect to this agreement. GMHL and WCNL then entered a development agreement for Weiti Station in February 2011. The development agreement is the first “stage agreement” referred to in the master agreement and sets out the agreement reached as to stage 1 of the development. The development agreement sets out various matters agreed as to the development of stage 1. In it, GMHL also grants WCNL an option to purchase the land that was to be developed (cls 24–26). It includes similar reporting obligations to the master agreement in cl 23 and an agreement to co-operate. Clause 37 provides WCNL will not receive any return until GMHL has received $180 million from the sale of the development land. As already outlined above, in June 2012, Messrs Williams and Liu agreed to form a limited partnership, WDLP, under the Limited Partnerships Act 2008. The initial general partner was Weiti Development General Partner Ltd (controlled by Mr Williams). There were two limited partners: Weiti Trustee Ltd (controlled by Mr Liu, with a 60 per cent share in the limited partnership) and Weiti General Partner Ltd (controlled by Mr Williams, with a 40 per cent share in the limited partnership). Pursuant to cl 6, those shares were agreed in recognition of the contributions of the parties towards the development so far. Clause 10.2 provides the general partner may be removed by a special resolution of WDLP or by a resolution at a limited partners’ meeting if the general partner acted fraudulently, negligently, or was wound up. Clause 13 concerns the advisory committee. Clause 13.1 established the advisory committee. The committee was to be consulted by the general partner, with reports every eight weeks. But members of the advisory committee are not, under cl 13.2, to take part in the management of the partnership in their capacity as a limited partner. That is commonplace in such agreements: participation by a limited partner in management of the partnership imperils the limited liability of a limited partner.[5] By cl 13.5, each member of the advisory committee has one vote and resolutions are passed by simple majority. Clause 13.10(a) provides advisory committee members be appointed by each partner holding a 10 per cent or greater share in the partnership — each partner could appoint one member for each 10 per cent shareholding it held in the partnership. Clause 13.9 provides advisory committee members do not owe duties (fiduciary or otherwise) to any partner in respect of the activities of the advisory committee.[5]Limited Partnerships Act 2008, ss 30 and 31. Clause 14 sets out the rights and duties of partners. Clause 14.1 provides the general partner has responsibility for the management and control of the business of the partnership — the development of the Weiti land. Specific powers and responsibilities are listed, including the cl 14.1(i) duty to operate the partnership “in accordance with consultation with the Advisory Committee”. Clause 14.2 sets out the authority and powers of the general partner. Important for present purposes are cls 14.9–14.11. Clause 14.9 provides the general partner and advisory committee members may exercise powers and discretions notwithstanding any conflict of interest. Clause 14.10 states:Exclusion of fiduciary duties: Except as specifically outlined in this Agreement, no Partner owes fiduciary duties or any other duties at law or in equity to another Partner or [WDLP], and the application of section 49 of the Act is excluded.