Khan v New Zealand Muslim Association

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2018-404-1648

[2023] NZHC 802

UNDER the Judicial Review Procedure Act 2016

IN THE MATTER

of an application for judicial review

BETWEEN AND

AND AND AND

ISMAIL RAHIMAN KHAN

First applicant

FARHAZ ASHIK REHMAN
Second applicant

MUNTAJ ALI
Third applicant

AZAD ALI
Fourth applicant

MOHAMMED ATIK
Fifth applicant

Continued overleaf

Hearing: 5–7 September 2022 and 3 April 2023

Appearances:

I M Hutcheson for applicants

P C Murray and K M Paterson for second respondent

Date of judgment:

18 April 2023


JUDGMENT OF JAGOSE J


This judgment was delivered by me on 18 April 2023 at 11.00am.

Pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

………………………… Registrar/Deputy Registrar

KHAN v NEW ZEALAND MUSLIM ASSOCIATION [2023] NZHC 802 [18 April 2023]

ANDMOHAMMED ZAKIR HUSSAIN, MOHAMMED RAFIQ WANIA, MOHAMED AHAMED NADAT,

ABDUL AZIZ as trustees of the ABU HARAIRAH TRUST KELSTON
First respondents

ANDNEW ZEALAND MUSLIM ASSOCIATION

Second respondent

ANDTHE REGISTRAR OF INCORPORATED SOCIETIES AT AUCKLAND

Third respondent

AND  ATTORNEY-GENERAL

Intervener

[1]                  The applicants and first respondents previously together were trustees of the Abu Harairah Trust Kelston (the Kelston trust). The Kelston trust had been riven by internal conflicts for some years, which the parties (including the New Zealand Muslim Association (the NZMA)) and others had sought to resolve in accordance with tenets of their common Muslim faith. No more elaboration is constructive or required.

[2]                  The applicants now claim to recover the assets of the Kelston trust — cash, and land and buildings in Auckland’s Kelston operated as a mosque and Islamic centre, all obtained from charitable donations — after their 16 August 2018 transfer by the first respondents, acting as the Kelston trust’s board, to the NZMA. In either case, the assets were or are held for the benefit of the Kelston Muslim community.

[3]                  Transfer of the Kelston trust’s assets was contended in breach of trust following disputed alterations to the trust’s deed and disputed termination of the applicants’ trusteeships (the disputes). By consent order dated 5 June 2019, this Court declared those alterations and terminations invalid.

[4]                  In July 2022, the applicants and first respondents settled matters as between themselves — including the applicants will withdraw their claims against the first

respondents, the first respondents will have no further involvement in the litigation, and the applicants will not apply to summon them to be witnesses and will not “make any other claims arising out of the same facts” — but were unable to resolve the issue of the assets’ transfer to the NZMA. The settlement agreement recorded it “presume[d] the return of all assets (property and funds) from NZMA to the [Kelston trust] or any successor trust but is not conditional on that”.

[5]                  Outstanding then were the applicants’ second and third causes of action against the NZMA — that it knew of the disputes, or caused the applicants to believe it would not proceed with the transfer, such as to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Khan v New Zealand Muslim Association and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 802
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Ismail Rahman Khan, Farhaz Ashik Rehman, Muntaz Ali, Mohammed Atik, and Azad Ali, sought to recover the assets of the Abu Harairah Trust Kelston (the Kelston trust) from the New Zealand Muslim Association (NZMA), after their transfer by the first respondents, who were also trustees of the Kelston trust. The applicants argued that the transfer was a breach of trust, due to disputed alterations to the trust’s deed and the termination of the applicants’ trusteeships. The applicants also sought to hold the NZMA liable for knowing receipt of the assets, and for equitable estoppel, based on an alleged unconscionable inducement or encouragement of the applicants’ assumption that the transfer would be paused pending the determination of the proceeding. The applicants further sought to have the Registrar of Incorporated Societies revoke the Kelston trust’s deregistration as improper.
The court held that there was no foundation breach of trust by the first respondents in making the transfer, and that the applicants’ claim of the NZMA’s knowing receipt must fail. The court also held that the applicants’ alternative cause against the NZMA or cause against the Registrar were unclear, given the absence of argument on them. The court dismissed the applicants’ second, third and fourth causes of action, and ordered the applicants to pay 2B costs and disbursements to the NZMA.

The applicants and first respondents, who were trustees of the Kelston trust, had been in conflict for some years, which they and others had sought to resolve in accordance with tenets of their common Muslim faith. The applicants now sought to recover the assets of the Kelston trust, cash, and land and buildings in Auckland’s Kelston operated as a mosque and Islamic centre, all obtained from charitable donations, after their transfer by the first respondents to the NZMA. The applicants contended that the transfer was a breach of trust following disputed alterations to the trust’s deed and disputed termination of the applicants’ trusteeships. By consent order dated 5 June 2019, the court declared those alterations and terminations invalid. The applicants and first respondents settled matters as between themselves in July 2022, but were unable to resolve the issue of the assets’ transfer to the NZMA. The settlement agreement recorded it “presume[d] the return of all assets (property and funds) from NZMA to the [Kelston trust] or any successor trust but is not conditional on that”. The applicants’ second and third causes of action against the NZMA, that it knew of the disputes, or caused the applicants to believe it would not proceed with the transfer, such as to make its retention of the assets unconscionable, and fourth cause of action against the Registrar, seeking revocation of the Trust’s “de-registration” as “improper”, remained. The proceeding’s 5–7 September 2022 hearing was adjourned part-heard on conclusion of the evidence, at the parties’ request “to accommodate completion of the parties’ anticipated settlement of all issues between them”. The parties’ optimism regrettably proved unfounded, and closing arguments then were addressed on 3 April 203. Opening and closing arguments focused exclusively on NZMA’s alleged ‘knowing receipt’.
The first respondents, acting as the Kelston trust’s trustees, resolved on 27 July 2018 “to come under the banner of NZMA” as being in “the best interest of the [Kelston trust] and wider community at large within the Kelston and surrounding area”. On 30 July 2018, they advised the NZMA of their resolution, proposing to “transfer all our assets to NZMA as per rules of Charities Commission once the transfer is complete” and hoping for NZMA’s “favourable consideration”. The NZMA responded on 1 August 2018 to “welcome Kelston as a branch of NZMA” and “to discuss the process of transitioning from the current trust structure to NZMA”. The Kelston trust filed deregistration documents dated 30 July 2018 (but including the NZMA’s 1 August 2018 response) with the Charities Commission, advising “it is merging or has merged with another registered charity”. On 14 August 2018, the first respondents formally resolved to execute deeds of the same date transferring all assets of the Kelston trust to the NZMA and winding up the Kelston trust. The Kelston trust also sought its charitable trust board be dissolved as no longer carrying on its operations, as occurred. On 10 August 2018, the applicants’ counsel, Iain Hutcheson, wrote to the NZMA, advising of their then-filed application for judicial review in relation to the disputes. He explained the proceeding “if successful will undermine the purported authority of the respondents” to transfer the Kelston trust’s assets to the NZMA, and sought an undertaking “not to progress or proceed with the proposed transactions” until this Court determined matters, absent which the applicants would “make urgent application for an interim injunction”. Mr Hutcheson sought the undertaking by5.00 pm on 15 August 2018. In the event, the deadline passed without either undertaking or application. There is uncertainty as to the formality by which the applicants’ allegations and then-intended judicial review proceeding were notified to the first respondents, and if they then or later were known to NZMA. A pre-commencement letter dated 3 July 2018 from the applicants’ lawyers to the first respondents, indicating judicial review would be sought of the disputes, appears not to have been followed up. A version of Mr Hutcheson’s 10 August 2018 letter to the NZMA marked “Draft” and unsigned was provided by one of the applicants, Ismail Khan, to the NZMA. In subsequent correspondence between the first respondents’ and the NZMA’s lawyers engaged on the transfer, the NZMA’s lawyer observed “[i]t seems in view of the pending court proceedings we have agreed to put everything on hold”. The first respondents’ lawyer responded he understood the NZMA considered “the letter ought not inhibit the transfer”, with which the first respondents agreed. The NZMA accepted the transfer in the morning of 16 August 2018, asking the first respondents to “release” the property’s electronic transfer. The transfer’s mechanics followed that day. In the afternoon of 16 August 2018, in response to Ismail Khan’s follow up that day of his earlier provision of the draft letter to NZMA, the NZMA’s Saiyad Khan provided his email address. On 18 August 2018, Mr Khan requested by email NZMA’s response to the 10 August 2018 letter. The NZMA’s president, Gul Ikhlaq Kashkari, responded the same day: 1. NZMA has only the best interests at heart for both Kelston Mosque and the community that it serves. 2. I will arrange a meeting with you all in September to try and understand your concerns and outcomes that you are looking for. 3. Discuss what can

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established