| IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND |
| SC 59/2013 SC 60/2013 SC 61/2013 SC 62/2013 [2013] NZSC 104 |
| BETWEEN | DOUGLAS ARTHUR MONTROSE GRAHAM, MICHAEL HOWARD REEVES, WILLIAM PATRICK JEFFRIES AND LAWRENCE ROLAND VALPY BRYANT |
| AND | THE QUEEN |
| Court: | Elias CJ, William Young and Glazebrook JJ |
Counsel: | J A Farmer QC, M A Corlett, D H O'Leary and M A Sissons for Applicants |
Judgment: | 25 October 2013 |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
AThe applications for leave to appeal are allowed in relation to sentence but dismissed as to conviction.
BThe approved question in relation to sentence is whether the Court of Appeal was in error in allowing the Solicitor-General’s appeals, and in particular, as to the necessity for sentences of imprisonment for the offending.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS
The convictions
The applicants were all directors of Lombard Finance and Investments Ltd, a company which raised money from the public pursuant to, inter alia, an amended prospectus of 24 December 2007. Lombard was placed in receivership in April 2008. Following trial before Dobson J sitting without a jury, the applicants were found guilty on four counts alleging offences under subss 58(1) and (3) of the Securities Act 1978. Count one (laid under s 58(3)) related to the amended prospectus. Counts two–four (laid under s 58(1)) related to advertisements for particular investment products marketed by Lombard. For present purposes, it is sufficient to focus on the prospectus count. This is because the advertisements were found to be untrue for reasons which were very similar to those which the Judge relied on in relation to the prospectus.
The approaches taken by the Judge and the Court of Appeal
An untrue prospectus?
The Judge found that the prospectus was untrue by reason of:[1]
The omission of material information relating to adverse liquidity issues including the deterioration in the company’s cash position from the balance at 30 September 2007 and the failure to achieve forecast cash receipts and loan payments.
For this reason, it was also untrue because it asserted that there were no other material matters relating to the offer of securities under the prospectus. The Judge rejected other Crown contentions as to untruthfulness, in particular the non-recognition in the prospectus of impairment in relation to the recoverability (or otherwise) of Lombard’s loans to five major borrower groups.
[1]R v Graham [2012] NZHC 265, [2012] NZCCLR 6 [HC judgment] at [92], [104]–[106], [118] and [123].
The section of the prospectus that dealt with liquidity risk is set out at [57] of the Court of Appeal judgment.[2] Developments relevant to liquidity from mid-September through to 24 December 2007 are reviewed in the Court of Appeal judgment from [36] to [52]. By 19 December (which was the date of the last board meeting of the year), cash on hand had decreased significantly, both in absolute terms (as against the cash on hand at 30 September) and as compared to earlier forecasts. This was primarily a…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Graham, Reeves, Jeffries and Bryant v The Queen and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] NZSC 104
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues the Court had to decide were whether the Court of Appeal was correct in finding the prospectus to be untrue and whether the applicants were guilty of the offences under the Securities Act 1978. The Court also had to decide whether the applicants were entitled to appeal their sentences on the grounds that the Court of Appeal erred in allowing the Solicitor-General's appeals and in particular, regarding the necessity for sentences of imprisonment.
The Court found that the Court of Appeal had not erred in its assessment of the prospectus as being untrue. The Court of Appeal's evaluation of the evidence and the Judge's conclusions on the matter were consistent, and there was no appearance of a miscarriage of justice. The Court also found that the Judge and Court of Appeal had not conflated the elements of the offence and the defence and that the proposed appeal did not raise a point of law of general or public importance.
The Court allowed the applications for leave to appeal in relation to sentence but dismissed the appeals as to conviction. The approved question in relation to sentence was whether the Court of Appeal was in error in allowing the Solicitor-General's appeals, and in particular, as to the necessity for sentences of imprisonment for the offending.
Background
Background to the litigation
The applicants sought leave to appeal against their convictions and sentences to the Supreme Court of New Zealand. The applications were heard by Elias CJ, William Young, and Glazebrook JJ. The applicants' counsel included J A Farmer QC, M A Corlett, D H O'Leary, and M A Sissons, and the Respondent's counsel was C R Carruthers QC and D R La Hood. The Supreme Court delivered its judgment on 25 October 2013, allowing the applications for leave to appeal in relation to sentence but dismissing them as to conviction.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Court of Appeal was in error in allowing the Solicitor-General's appeals, particularly regarding the necessity for sentences of imprisonment for the offending.
Held
1. The applications for leave to appeal are allowed in relation to sentence but dismissed as to conviction.
2. The approved question in relation to sentence is whether the Court of Appeal was in error in allowing the Solicitor-General’s appeals, and in particular, as to the necessity for sentences of imprisonment for the offending.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The applicants, all directors of Lombard Finance and Investments Ltd, were found guilty on four counts alleging offences under subss 58(1) and (3) of the Securities Act 1978. The primary issue focused on whether the Court of Appeal was in error in allowing the Solicitor-General’s appeals concerning the necessity for sentences of imprisonment. The Court examined the findings of the Judge and the Court of Appeal regarding the untruthfulness of the prospectus issued by the company.
The Judge found the prospectus to be untrue due to the omission of material information relating to adverse liquidity issues and the failure to achieve forecast cash receipts and loan payments. The Court of Appeal evaluated the evidence and construed the prospectus differently, considering it to be incorrect in asserting that Lombard would be unable to meet its repayment obligations only if the reduction in the level of reinvestment was extreme. The Court of Appeal also found that the reference in the prospectus to the Board being "confident" that Lombard would have sufficient cash to fund all payments to investors was incorrect.
The Judge rejected the defence based on s 58(4) of the Securities Act, concluding that it was not reasonable for the directors to omit reference to the relative inaccuracy of the previous projections of loan repayments and their concerns over liquidity. The Court of Appeal dismissed the challenge to this part of the Judge’s reasons, concluding that the Judge’s rejection of the defence on the facts was open to him.
The applicants' proposed appeal primarily turned on issues of fact, including the relevance of events that occurred after the signing of the prospectus and the Court of Appeal’s evaluation of the prospectus's truth. The Court found no appearance of a miscarriage of justice in the critical findings and concluded that the statutory criteria for the grant of leave to appeal in respect of conviction were not made out. The appeal was thus dismissed as to conviction but allowed in relation to sentence.