Graeme Martin Contracting Limited v Disputes Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA

TE WHANGANUI-Ā-TARA ROHE

CIV-2017-485-000436 [2017] NZHC 2636

IN THE MATTER of the Judicial Review Procedure Act 2016

IN THE MATTER

of an application for Judicial Review

BETWEEN

GRAEME MARTIN CONTRACTING LIMITED

Applicant

AND

DISPUTES TRIBUNAL First Respondent

DISTRICT COURT AT WELLINGTON Second Respondent

CHORUS NEW ZEALAND LIMITED Third Respondent

Hearing: 25 October 2017

Counsel:

E J Tait for Applicant
No appearance for First and Second Respondents
R L Goss for Third Respondent

Judgment:

27 October 2017

JUDGMENT OF COLLINS J

Introduction

[1]      On 16 January 2015 Graeme Martin Contracting Ltd (GMCL) severed a fibre optic cable owned by Chorus New Zealand Ltd (Chorus).  The incident occurred on McCormacks Bay Road in Christchurch whilst GMCL was excavating a deep trench to  install  replacement  sewer  mains  that  had  been  damaged  in  the  Christchurch

earthquakes.

GRAEME MARTIN CONTRACTING LIMITED v DISPUTES TRIBUNAL [2017] NZHC 2636 [27 October

2017]

[2]      Chorus  incurred  costs  of  $17,172.91  for  the  repair  of  the  cable  and commenced proceedings in the Disputes Tribunal (the Tribunal) in March 2016 to recover $15,000, being the maximum sum that can be recovered in that jurisdiction.

[3]      The Tribunal ordered GMCL to pay Chorus $15,000.1     That decision was upheld by the District  Court.2     A subsequent application for a rehearing of the Disputes Tribunal’s decision was declined.3    GMCL has now applied to judicially review both the Tribunal and District Court decisions alleging that the processes followed by the Tribunal were procedurally unfair and that the decisions of the Tribunal and the District Court were unreasonable.

[4]      This judgment explains why none of the grounds for judicial review have been established.

Background

[5]      GMCL is a well established contractor in Christchurch that at the relevant time was carrying out a sub-contract for Fulton Hogan.  Before excavating the trench on McCormacks Bay Road, GMCL obtained plans of the area from Fulton Hogan that had in turn been supplied by Chorus (the Chorus plans).  Those working on the site comprised three employees of GMCL and one from Fulton Hogan.  The workers excavated by hand to a depth of about 0.5 metres and located two cable ducts. Because the land in the area was just above the high tide level and the soil very unstable, GMCL had to protect the edges of the trench with sheet piles to stop the trenches collapsing.

[6]      After exposing the two ducts at about 0.5 metres, GMCL used mechanical devices to dig the rest of the trench but in doing so severed a third cable lying at a

depth of about 2.5 metres.

1      Chorus New Zealand Ltd v Graeme Martin Contracting Ltd DT Wellington CIV-2016-085-176,

24 June 2016.

2      Graeme Martin Contracting Ltd v Chorus New Zealand Ltd [2017] NZDC 1622.

3      Chorus New Zealand Ltd v Graeme Martin Contracting Ltd DT Wellington CIV-2016-085-176,

12 April 2017.

[7]      The key factual issue was whether the Chorus plans disclosed the existence of two or three ducts.  If…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Graeme Martin Contracting Limited v Disputes Tribunal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 2636
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Graeme Martin Contracting Limited (GMCL) sought judicial review of decisions made by the Disputes Tribunal and the District Court, which held GMCL liable for the cost of repairing a cable severed during a Christchurch excavation. The High Court dismissed GMCL's application, finding the Tribunal and District Court decisions were neither procedurally unfair nor unreasonable. The Tribunal had ordered GMCL to pay Chorus New Zealand Limited $15,000, the maximum recoverable sum. GMCL argued the Tribunal process was unfair because it was denied a change of venue and further adjournment, and the decisions were unreasonable. The High Court held there were no procedural irregularities because GMCL was granted an adjournment and had ample time to prepare. Further, the Court was not satisfied the Tribunal and District Court decisions were unreasonable because the evidence showed there were three ducts on the Chorus plans, not two.