Graeme Martin Contracting Ltd v Disputes Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA662/2017
 [2018] NZCA 328

BETWEEN

GRAEME MARTIN CONTRACTING LIMITED
Appellant

AND

DISPUTES TRIBUNAL
First Respondent

AND

DISTRICT COURT AT WELLINGTON
Second Respondent

AND

CHORUS NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Third Respondent

Hearing:

15 August 2018

Court:

Cooper, Winkelmann and Gilbert JJ

Counsel:

E J Tait for Appellant
R L Goss and T D Smith for Third Respondent

Judgment:

28 August 2018 at 10.30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellant must pay the third respondent costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Gilbert J)

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal against a judgment of Collins J dismissing applications for judicial review of two decisions, a decision of the Disputes Tribunal and a decision of the District Court dismissing an appeal against the Tribunal’s decision.[1]  The appellant complains that the Disputes Tribunal breached rules of natural justice by refusing to transfer the proceedings from Wellington to Christchurch where the events giving rise to the claim occurred and the witnesses were based and, second, by refusing an adjournment to enable the appellant to locate witnesses and arrange for them to be present at the hearing.

  2. We commence by briefly outlining the dispute.  We then set out the procedural history in some detail before examining the appellant’s essential complaint that it was not given a proper opportunity to be heard.

The dispute 

  1. It is common ground that on 16 January 2015 the appellant, Graeme Martin Contracting Ltd (GMCL) severed a fibre optic cable belonging to the third respondent, Chorus New Zealand Ltd (Chorus).  The cable was housed inside a 100 mm diameter duct laid at a depth of approximately 2.5 metres.  The damage occurred while GMCL was carrying out contract work for Fulton Hogan digging trenches and laying deep sewer mains that were to be connected to a new pump station in Christchurch. 

  2. Chorus repaired the cable at a cost of $17,173 and issued an invoice for this amount to GMCL on 4 July 2015 claiming it was liable in negligence for the repair cost.  GMCL disputed liability on the basis that it took all reasonable steps to locate services and this particular cable was not shown on the service drawings.   

Disputes Tribunal

  1. Chorus filed a claim against GMCL in the Disputes Tribunal for $15,000, being the limit of the Tribunal’s jurisdiction.[2]  The claim was filed in the Disputes Tribunal at Wellington because that is where Chorus is based.[3]  On 16 March 2016 the Tribunal notified the parties that the claim would be heard in Wellington on 5 May 2016. 

    [2]Disputes Tribunal Act 1988, s 10 (1A).

    [3]Disputes Tribunal Act, s 24(2).

  2. On 23 March 2016 GMCL’s solicitors applied for the proceedings to be transferred to Christchurch because this is where the incident took place and all witnesses were located there.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Graeme Martin Contracting Ltd v Disputes Tribunal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZCA 328
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal was brought by Graeme Martin Contracting Ltd (GMCL) against a decision of the Disputes Tribunal and a subsequent decision of the District Court dismissing an appeal against the Tribunal’s decision. GMCL alleged that the Disputes Tribunal breached rules of natural justice by refusing to transfer the proceedings from Wellington to Christchurch and by refusing an adjournment to enable GMCL to locate witnesses and arrange for them to be present at the hearing. The central issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the appellant was denied a proper opportunity to be heard, thus breaching natural justice. The Court of Appeal found that GMCL was given a reasonable opportunity to be heard, and that the witnesses GMCL wished to call could not have provided material assistance on the proper interpretation of the plan. The appeal was dismissed, and GMCL was ordered to pay costs to the third respondent.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 16 January 2015, Graeme Martin Contracting Ltd (GMCL) severed a fibre optic cable belonging to Chorus New Zealand Ltd while carrying out contract work in Christchurch. Chorus repaired the cable at a cost of $17,173 and issued an invoice to GMCL, which disputed liability. Chorus filed a claim for $15,000 against GMCL in the Disputes Tribunal in Wellington, where Chorus is based. GMCL applied to transfer the proceedings to Christchurch, where the incident occurred and witnesses were located, and to adjourn the hearing to allow its managing director to return from overseas. Both applications were declined. GMCL argued at the hearing that the damaged duct was not shown on the Chorus plan, but the Disputes Tribunal referee found in favour of Chorus, concluding that GMCL had failed to positively identify the cable/ducting, despite it being clearly marked on the relevant plans. GMCL appealed to the District Court, which was dismissed. GMCL then applied to the Disputes Tribunal for an extension of time to apply for a rehearing, which was also dismissed.

This case is an appeal against a judgment of Collins J dismissing applications for judicial review of two decisions, a decision of the Disputes Tribunal and a decision of the District Court dismissing an appeal against the Tribunal's decision. The appellant, GMCL, complains that the Disputes Tribunal breached rules of natural justice by refusing to transfer the proceedings from Wellington to Christchurch and by refusing an adjournment to enable the appellant to locate witnesses and arrange for them to be present at the hearing.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Disputes Tribunal breach rules of natural justice by refusing to transfer the proceedings from Wellington to Christchurch?
2. Did the Disputes Tribunal breach rules of natural justice by refusing an adjournment to enable the appellant to locate witnesses and arrange for them to be present at the hearing?

Held
1. The Court of Appeal held that the Disputes Tribunal did not breach rules of natural justice by refusing to transfer the proceedings from Wellington to Christchurch. The appeal against the Tribunal's refusal to transfer the proceedings was dismissed.
2. The Court of Appeal held that the Disputes Tribunal did not breach rules of natural justice by refusing an adjournment to enable the appellant to locate witnesses and arrange for them to be present at the hearing. The appeal against the Tribunal's refusal to grant a second adjournment was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the appellant's submissions that the Disputes Tribunal breached the rules of natural justice by refusing to transfer the proceedings to Christchurch and by refusing to adjourn the hearing to allow the appellant to locate witnesses. The Court noted that the principles of natural justice apply to hearings in the Disputes Tribunal, but the necessary steps to facilitate these principles depend on the specific circumstances of the case. The Court examined the context and purpose of the Disputes Tribunal Act, which is to provide for the prompt resolution of disputes involving modest sums. The Court found that the Tribunal did not breach natural justice as the appellant was given a reasonable opportunity to be heard, and the evidence from the proposed witnesses would not have materially assisted the appellant's case. The Court further noted that the referee conducted the hearing carefully and took into account the difficulties raised by the appellant. The Court concluded that the appeal should be dismissed, and the appellant must pay the third respondent's costs for the appeal.