McFarland v Disputes Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2013-409-1257 [2013] NZHC 2885

UNDER  Judicature Amendment Act 1972

BETWEEN  MARIE RHODA McFARLAND Plaintiff

ANDTHE DISPUTES TRIBUNAL First Defendant

BELFAST TIMBER PROCESSING LIMITED

Second Defendant

Hearing:                   16 October 2013

Counsel:                  D M Lester for Plaintiff

P J Shamy as Amicus Curiae

Judgment:                31 October 2013

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF MACKENZIE J

I direct that the delivery time of this judgment is

4.30 pm on the 31st day of October 2013.

Solicitors:           Dale Lester Barrister, Christchurch for Plaintiff

Crown Solicitor’s office, Raymond Donnelly & Co, Christchurch, as Amicus

McFARLAND v THE DISPUTES TRIBUNAL [2013] NZHC 2885 [31 October 2013]

[1]      This is an application for an order quashing the Disputes Tribunal’s decisions of 25 June 2010, 2 February 2011 and 12 December 2011 in proceedings in which the plaintiff, Mrs McFarland, was the applicant.

[2]      Mrs McFarland  was  a  shareholder  of  two  companies,  Paragon  Homes Limited (Paragon Homes) and Outside In Properties Limited (Outside In).   Her husband was a director of both companies.   Both companies were placed in liquidation on 18 February 2009.  Mrs McFarland is also a trustee of the Lochsloy Trust.  Paragon Homes had, before liquidation, contracted to purchase some timber from Belfast Timber Processing Limited (Belfast Timber).  A payment of $6,806.25 was made, by way of Barter Card transaction, by Outside In.  None of the timber was received.   When the two companies were placed in liquidation, the liquidator of Paragon Homes took the matter up with Belfast Timber.  That company required a further payment for storage costs and other expenses, which it claimed were payable before the timber could be uplifted.   The liquidator advised Mrs McFarland that Belfast Timber had said that the timber could be picked up on payment of $3,000. The liquidator advised that he would also require payment of $1,000 plus GST for his attendances.   No further payment was made, and the liquidator subsequently disclaimed the timber.

[3]      Mrs McFarland bought the claim in the Disputes Tribunal in her capacity as a trustee of the Lochsloy Trust, claiming that the funds paid to Belfast Timber had come from the Lochsloy Trust.

[4]      The claim was heard in the Disputes Tribunal and a decision was given on

25 June 2010.  The Tribunal found that Mrs McFarland had not proved her claim on the balance of probabilities.  It found that the parties to the contract for the sale of the timber were Belfast Timber and Paragon Homes.   The Tribunal appeared to accept that the payment by Barter Card transaction had been made by Outside In, but did not accept that the Lochsloy Trust was an undisclosed principal so that Outside In was the agent of the Lochsloy Trust.

[5]      Mrs McFarland appealed to the District Court under s 50 of the Disputes Tribunal Act 1988.  In his judgment delivered on 24 November 2010, Judge Moran said:1

So the case boils down to this.   The Tribunal found that Paragon Homes purchased the timber from Belfast Timber Processing.  Outside In paid…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McFarland v Disputes Tribunal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 2885
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this matter, the plaintiff, Marie Rhoda McFarland, sought to quash decisions made by the Disputes Tribunal. The disputes stemmed from a claim regarding a timber transaction involving two companies, Paragon Homes Limited and Outside In Properties Limited, both of which were placed in liquidation. McFarland, as a shareholder and trustee of the Lochsloy Trust, contended that funds paid to Belfast Timber Processing Limited for timber that was never delivered should be returned. Belfast Timber had received payment but refused to deliver the timber without further payment of storage costs and other expenses.

The legal issues at the core of this case revolved around the interpretation of the Disputes Tribunal Act 1988 and the extent of the Court's jurisdiction to review decisions made by the Disputes Tribunal. The Tribunal had ruled against McFarland, finding that she had not proved her claim on the balance of probabilities and that the Lochsloy Trust had no entitlement to the timber or the money paid. McFarland challenged this decision, arguing that the outcome was unfair and that the Tribunal had procedurally erred in not recognizing her rights to the timber.

The Court considered the limited scope of judicial review available under the Disputes Tribunal Act 1988, emphasizing that review is not meant to be an appeal on the merits but rather to address whether the Tribunal acted in a manner that was unfair or prejudicial. The Court noted that the Tribunal's role is to provide a speedy and inexpensive resolution of claims without strict adherence to legal technicalities. Given the limited grounds for review, the Court concluded that there was no basis to overturn the Tribunal's decisions. The Court found that there was no clear legal or moral entitlement for the Lochsloy Trust to recover either the money or the timber, and thus, the application for review was dismissed.

The Court's judgment clearly articulated the limited jurisdiction for reviewing Disputes Tribunal decisions and affirmed the finality of the Tribunal's rulings in this case. The Court's decision underscored the importance of adhering to the legislative framework governing the Disputes Tribunal and the constraints on judicial intervention.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.