Godfrey Hirst NZ Limited v Commerce Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2015-404-002719 [2016] NZHC 1601

UNDER the Commerce Act 1986

BETWEEN

GODFREY HIRST NZ LIMITED Appellant

AND

COMMERCE COMMISSION First Respondent

CAVALIER WOOL HOLDINGS LIMITED

Second Respondent

NEW ZALAND WOOL SERVICES INTERNATIONAL LIMITED

Third Respondent

Hearing: 12 July 2016

Appearances:

J C L Dixon, S D J Peart and A B Richards for Appellant
N F Flanagan for First Respondent
D J Goddard QC and S J P Ladd for Second and Third
Respondents

Judgment:

15 July 2016

JUDGMENT OF GILBERT J

This judgment is delivered by me on 15 July 2016 at 11.45 am pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

..................................................... Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Chapman Tripp, Wellington

Merediths, Auckland

Counsel:
J C L Dixon, Auckland

D J Goddard QC, Wellington

GODFREY HIRST NZ LTD v COMMERCE COMMISSION & ORS [2016] NZHC 1601 [15 July 2016]

Introduction

[1]      Cavalier Wool Holdings Ltd (Cavalier) wishes to acquire the wool scouring business and assets of New Zealand Wool Scouring International Ltd (NZWSI). Cavalier  and  NZWSI  are  the  only  providers  of  wool  scouring  services  in New Zealand so, if the acquisition proceeds, the merged entity will have a domestic monopoly for such services.

[2]      Following a comprehensive investigation extending over a 12 month period, the Commission concluded that although the acquisition would be likely to result in scouring price increases, the public benefits of the transaction were likely to exceed its detriments.  The acquisition will enable significant efficiency gains to be made through the rationalisation of the existing Cavalier and NZWSI scouring operations from five to two, one in the North Island and one in the South Island.   The Commission  accordingly  granted  authorisation  for  the  acquisition  pursuant  to

s 67(3)(b) of the Commerce Act 1986.1

[3]      Godfrey Hirst appealed to this Court against the Commission’s determination

on three grounds:

(a)      The  Commission  ought  to  have  discounted  that  proportion  of  the benefits of the acquisition that will accrue to the foreign shareholder of the merged entity, Lempriere (Australia) Pty Ltd.  Lempriere will own 45 per cent of the merged entity with an option to increase its shareholding to 72.5 per cent.  Godfrey Hirst argued that the benefits that  will  flow  to  Lempriere  are  not  benefits  to  the  public  of New Zealand and should have been disregarded.

(b)The  Commission  underestimated  the  likely  price  increases  for scouring services for wool destined for export following the acquisition.  Godfrey Hirst argued that the likely price increases will be in the range of 10 to 20 per cent, not five to 15 per cent as assessed

by the Commission.

1      Cavalier  Wool  Holdings  Ltd  and  New  Zealand  Wool  Services  International  Ltd  [2015] NZCC 31.

(c)      The Commission overestimated the benefits because it is likely that NZWSI will relocate its scour at Kaputone to Timaru whether or not the acquisition proceeds.

[4]      In a judgment delivered on 8 June 2016, the Court rejected each of these

grounds and dismissed Godfrey Hirst’s appeal.2

[5]      Godfrey Hirst now seeks…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Godfrey Hirst NZ Limited v Commerce Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 1601
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Godfrey Hirst NZ Limited sought leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal against the decision of the High Court dismissing its appeal against the Commerce Commission’s authorisation of the acquisition of the wool scouring business and assets of New Zealand Wool Services International Limited by Cavalier Wool Holdings Limited. Godfrey Hirst had three grounds for its appeal to the High Court, all of which were rejected. It now seeks leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal on the same three grounds. Cavalier opposed the application for leave and requested that the Court require Godfrey Hirst to provide an undertaking as to damages as a condition of granting leave. The Court of Appeal should be given leave to consider whether the Commission was right to treat productivity gains flowing to foreign shareholders as benefits of the transaction. This ground raises a question of general principle and has wider application, beyond the present case. In the present case, at least 45 per cent of the gains will flow to a foreign shareholder. This is a discrete issue of considerable potential public importance and has not been ruled on by the Court of Appeal. Godfrey Hirst should be given leave to pursue this ground. The other two grounds for appeal do not meet the criteria. They concern issues that have already been decided by the Commission and the High Court and are unlikely to succeed if re-litigated in the Court of Appeal. Godfrey Hirst should not be required to provide an undertaking as to damages as a condition of leave being granted. The ground of appeal that will be allowed to proceed raises wider public interest considerations.