Godfrey Hirst NZ Ltd v Commerce Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA351/2016
[2016] NZCA 560

BETWEEN

GODFREY HIRST NZ LIMITED
Appellant

AND

COMMERCE COMMISSION
First Respondent

AND

CAVALIER WOOL HOLDINGS LIMITED
Second Respondent

AND

NEW ZEALAND WOOL SERVICES INTERNATIONAL LIMITED
Third Respondent

Hearing:

15 September 2016

Court:

Kós P, Harrison and Asher JJ

Counsel:

JCL Dixon and SDJ Peart for Appellant
M N Dunning QC and N F Flanagan for First Respondent
D J Goddard QC and J Q Wilson for Second and Third Respondents

Judgment:

30 November 2016 at 10.15 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellant is ordered to pay one set of costs to the first respondent and another set of costs to the second and third respondents jointly on a band A basis with usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Harrison J)

Table of Contents

Para No.

Introduction  [1]
Background  [3]
Statutory framework and legislative history  [10]

The authorisation test  [10]
Emphasising efficiencies  [14]
The long-term benefit of consumers  [20]
Authorising anti-competitive acquisitions  [21]

Decision  [25]

Introduction  [25]
First ground of appeal  [28]

(a)       Failure to quantify  [28]
(b)     The Commission’s approach  [31]
(c)       Our assessment  [35]

Second ground of appeal — false equation  [45]
New ground of appeal  [48]
Conclusion  [50]

Result  [53]

Introduction

  1. Cavalier Wool Holdings Ltd (Cavalier) and New Zealand Wool Services International Ltd (NZWSI) are the only providers of wool scouring services in New Zealand.  In 2014 Cavalier applied to the Commerce Commission for authorisation under s 67(3)(b) of the Commerce Act 1986 (the Act) to acquire control of NZWSI’s wool scouring business and assets.  The transaction would create a domestic monopoly for wool scouring services.  NZWSI’s foreign parent, Lempriere (Australia) Pty Ltd, would own 45 per cent of the merged entity with an option to increase its shareholding to 72.5 per cent. 

  2. Godfrey Hirst Ltd (Hirst) manufactures woollen carpet in New Zealand for which it purchases scoured wool.  Hirst opposed Cavalier’s application on a number of grounds.  In November 2015 the Commission determined to authorise the proposed acquisition.[1]  In July 2016 the High Court dismissed Hirst’s appeal against the Commission’s determination.[2]  The sole question of law for this Court on Hirst’s second appeal is whether the Commission correctly treated productivity gains flowing to Lempriere (as a foreign shareholder) as a benefit to the public likely to result from the transaction. 

Background

[1]Cavalier Wool Holdings Ltd and New Zealand Wool Services International Ltd [2015] NZCC 31 [Determination].

  1. The Commerce Commission first granted Cavalier authorisation to acquire NZWSI’s wool scouring business in June 2011.  The High Court dismissed Hirst’s appeal against that determination in November 2011.[3]  However, the acquisition did not proceed and the authorisation lapsed.

    [3]Godfrey Hirst NZ Ltd v Commerce Commission (2011) 9 NZBLC 103,396 (HC).

  2. On 23 October 2014 Cavalier applied afresh for authorisation.  On 26 March 2015 and 1 October 2015 respectively the Commission released…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Godfrey Hirst NZ Ltd v Commerce Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZCA 560
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal of New Zealand considered Godfrey Hirst NZ Ltd’s appeal against the Commerce Commission’s authorisation of a proposed acquisition by Cavalier Wool Holdings Ltd of New Zealand Wool Services International Ltd’s wool scouring business and assets. The acquisition would create a domestic monopoly for wool scouring services. Godfrey Hirst opposed the acquisition on the basis that the Commission erred in treating productivity gains flowing to Lempriere (a foreign shareholder) as a benefit to the public likely to result from the transaction. The appeal was dismissed. The Commission was satisfied that the acquisition would result in such a benefit to the public that it should be permitted. The majority of the quantified benefit is expected to arise from productivity gains, essentially cost savings flowing from the release of capital from the sale of excess land and plant, and lower operating costs as the two competing suppliers of wool scouring services consolidate into one monopolistic entity. While 45 per cent of those benefits would go offshore to Lempriere, the Commission concluded that these gains should nevertheless be counted as they provided “other longer-term or wider public benefits”. The Court held that the Commission did not err in treating productivity gains flowing to Lempriere as benefits of the transaction. Cost savings to foreign shareholders are not excluded in the context of flow-on benefits which together satisfy the Commission that the merger is likely to benefit the public. These benefits were properly accounted for within the Commission’s broad evaluation by assuming all efficiencies benefit the public. Without evidence that the New Zealand public will be exploited, gains to foreign shareholders are properly treated as positive elements of the transaction to reflect the correlative benefits of preserving a domestic participant in a competitive global market and encouraging foreign investment. The Commission is not required to adhere rigidly to a quantitative analysis of a transaction which defies its accurate application. Its only effect in a case like this is to invite a challenge to the Commission’s determination on the assumption that the result will always turn on the numbers, albeit with ancillary attention to the quality of the data. While mathematical precision is helpful where it might be available in assessing public benefits, the legislative regime does not require the Commission to quantify all factors. So long as the Commission marshals robust reasons, applying its expertise to quantitative and qualitative factors within its statutory mandate, the courts will not lightly resort to a tangential ground to interfere with its approval or dismissal of a proposed business acquisition. Moreover, when its reasons for this determination are viewed in totality, there is nothing to suggest that the Commission erroneously treated efficiency gains to a foreign shareholder as an arbitrary proxy for anticipated flow-on benefits.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.