New Zealand Bus Ltd v Commerce Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA149/06
CA227/06
[2007] NZCA 502

BETWEENNEW ZEALAND BUS LIMITED


First Appellant

ANDINFRATIL LIMITED


Second Appellant

ANDCOMMERCE COMMISSION


Respondent

CA151/06

AND BETWEEN             BLAIRGOWRIE INVESTMENTS LIMITED & ORS


Appellants

ANDCOMMERCE COMMISSION


Respondent

Hearing:19 September - 21 September 2007

Court:Hammond, Arnold and Wilson JJ

Counsel:L A O'Gorman and J White for Appellants in CA149/06 and   CA227/06


J W Tizard for Appellants in CA151/06
D J Goddard QC and L Theron for Respondent in all appeals

Interim

Judgment:14 November 2007

Judgment:6 June 2008 at 10 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AWe confirm the dismissal of the appeal by New Zealand Bus Limited against liability in respect of s 47 of the Commerce Act 1986.

BWe allow the appeal by the Blairgowrie Investments Limited & Ors as to the liability of the Waddell interests as accessories under s 83 of the Act.

CWe dismiss the cross-appeal by the Commerce Commission against Infratil Limited, as to its liability as an accessory under s 83 of the Act.

DWe dismiss the cross-appeals by the Commerce Commission and New Zealand Bus Limited as to the amount of the penalty ($500,000) ordered by the High Court.

E        We dismiss the costs appeal by New Zealand Bus Limited.

F        In this Court, there will be no order for costs.

REASONS

HAMMOND J[1]

ARNOLD J  [227]
WILSON J[269]

HAMMOND J

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction  [1]
The narrative

The Wellington bus companies[10]
         Competition begins  [13]
         The Mana interests  [16]
         The Waddells’ wish to sell  [23]
         The Commission becomes concerned, and brings proceedings            [27]
         The legislation  [31]
         The respective positions of the parties  [36]
The High Court decisions  
Introduction  [45]
The result in the High Court, as to liability  [53]
         The reasoning in the High Court, as to liability  [54]
         Penalties  [62]
         Costs  [64]

The appeal against the finding of an anti-competitive transaction
         Introduction  [65]
         The more specific grounds of appeal  [68]
         Areas of agreement  [71]
         The heart of it all  [75]

A cosy arrangement?  [77]
         A substantial lessening of competition?  [91]

Accessory liability

Introduction  [106]
         The legislation  [110]
         The construction of s 83 in the High Court  [117]
         The Waddells’ appeal  [123]

THE SUBMISSIONS FOR THE COMMISSION[126]
THE LAW

(I)    SOME GENERAL OBSERVATIONS  [127]

(II)   THE CRIMINAL LAW ANALOGY  [137]
(III)  SECTION 83 REDUX: DISHONEST (OR UNLAWFUL) PARTICIPATION?      [141]

APPLICATION TO THIS CASE

(I)    THE WADDELLS  [162]

(II)   INFRATIL[166]
PENALTY
INTRODUCTION[186]
THE JURISPRUDENCE OF PENALTIES  [192]

Potential gains  [202]
         The Commission staff indicator  [206]
Other factors  [209]
         Conclusion on penalty[210]
Costs
Background[213]
The High Court determination  [216]
The relevant legal principles  [217]
Conclusion on costs[220]
Conclusion  [223]

Introduction

[1]       The Commerce Commission brought proceedings in the High Court to restrain New Zealand Bus Limited (NZ Bus) from completing the acquisition of the 74 per cent of Mana Coach Services Limited (Mana) that it did not already own.  The Commission was of the view that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read New Zealand Bus Ltd v Commerce Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NZCA 502
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal was brought by the first and second appellants, New Zealand Bus Limited (NZ Bus) and Infratil Limited (Infratil), against the finding of the High Court that they had breached s 47 of the Commerce Act 1986 (the Act) by acquiring the remaining 74 per cent of shares in Mana Coach Services Limited (Mana) that they did not already own. The third appellants, Blairgowrie Investments Limited & Ors (Blairgowrie), appealed against their being found liable as accessories under s 83 of the Act. The respondent, the Commerce Commission (the Commission), cross-appealed against the finding that Infratil was not liable as an accessory. This Court dismissed the appeal by NZ Bus and Infratil against liability in respect of s 47 of the Act, and allowed the appeal by Blairgowrie as to the liability of the Waddell interests as accessories under s 83 of the Act. This Court dismissed the cross-appeals by the Commission and NZ Bus as to the amount of the penalty ($500,000) ordered by the High Court, and the cross-appeal by the Commission against Infratil, as to its liability as an accessory under s 83 of the Act. Finally, this Court dismissed the costs appeal by NZ Bus. In this Court, there will be no order for costs. The essential legal issue in this appeal was whether the acquisition of 74 per cent of the shares in Mana by NZ Bus would substantially lessen competition to a degree that could be described as "real" under s 47 of the Act. It was common ground that the High Court had correctly applied the principles of s 47. The issue was whether those principles had been correctly applied to the facts of this case. The Court found that the High Court was correct in finding that the acquisition would substantially lessen competition in the Wellington regional market for rights to supply subsidised scheduled public and school bus services. The Court also found that the High Court was correct in finding that the Waddell interests were accessories under s 83 of the Act because they had the requisite knowledge to establish accessory liability. The Court found that the High Court was correct in dismissing the claim against Infratil because the Commission could not show that Infratil deliberately assisted NZ Bus with knowledge of the essential facts sufficient to establish contravention of s 47.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.