Estate of Underwood

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2023-485-615565

[2025] NZHC 788

IN THE ESTATE of the late NANCY CARRUTHERS UNDERWOOD

BETWEEN

MARGARET MAUD UNDERWOOD AND HELENE AGNES PHYLLIS YOUNG

Applicants

AND

STEPHEN UNDERWOOD AND ALISTAIR HOUGHTON UNDERWOOD

Caveators

Hearing:

19 November 2024

Further affidavit evidence received 29 January and 18 February 2025

Further submissions received 12 and 26 February and 13 March 2025

Appearances:

R T Wilson for Applicants

A S Cavanaugh for Caveators

Judgment:

4 April 2025


JUDGMENT OF McHERRON J


[1]    The children of the late Nancy Underwood disagree about how her estate should be divided. Nancy’s sons, Stephen and Alistair Underwood, question the validity of Nancy’s last will dated 22 June 2020 (the 2020 Will).1 Stephen and Alistair have concerns about Nancy’s testamentary capacity at the time  she  signed  the  2020 Will. They also have concerns about whether Nancy was the subject of undue influence before signing that will.


1      I use first names in this judgment for ease of reference because key individuals share the same surname. No disrespect is intended.

ESTATE OF UNDERWOOD [2025] NZHC 788 [4 April 2025]

[2]    The High Court has jurisdiction to grant and revoke probate of wills and letters of administration of the estates of those who have died.2 An application for a grant of administration can be made:3

(a)without notice where a will’s validity is not contested or questioned (often referred to as an application in “common form”);4 or

(b)in solemn form when the applicant elects to do so or is ordered to do so.5

[3]    Because of their concerns, Stephen and Alistair say Nancy’s 2020 Will should be the subject of an application for probate in solemn form. That will involve a formal hearing before a judge at which their concerns about lack of testamentary capacity and undue influence can be fully aired.

[4]    Therefore, the primary issue in the present judgment is to determine whether to order the applicants to make a solemn form application for probate.

Background

[5]    Nancy Underwood died aged 100 on 24 June 2023. She had three children, Stephen, Alistair and Margaret Underwood.

[6]    In a will dated 19 April 2011, Nancy left the residue of her estate in equal proportions to her three children. However, in the 2020 Will, Nancy left:

(a)to Alistair and Stephen, a painting each and Woolworths shares worth approximately AUD60–75,000;

(b)to Margaret, Nancy’s house and its contents, and jewellery.


2      Administration Act 1969, s 5.

3      High Court Rules 2016, 27.3.

4      Rule 27.4.

5      Rule 27.6; John Earles and others Dobbie’s Probate and Administration Practice (7th edition, LexisNexis, Wellington, 2025) at 429.

(c)any remaining residue (which Stephen understands will be minimal, particularly after a debt owing to his father’s estate is repaid) to Alistair and Stephen equally.

[7]    For a large part of her adult life, Margaret lived in the United States. There, she  married  her  husband  James.  In  2015,  Margaret  and  James  returned  to  New…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Estate of Underwood and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NZHC 788
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court considered a dispute between the children of the late Nancy Underwood over the validity of her last will dated 22 June 2020. Nancy's sons, Stephen and Alistair, challenged the will, questioning Nancy's testamentary capacity and alleging undue influence from Margaret, Nancy's daughter and primary caregiver. The primary issue before the court was whether to order the applicants to make a solemn form application for probate, allowing for a formal hearing on the concerns about testamentary capacity and undue influence. The court concluded that there was a sufficient basis to question Nancy's capacity at the time she executed the 2020 Will, justifying a full inquiry in a solemn form application. The court did not find sufficient evidence of undue influence at this preliminary stage, but this issue remains open for consideration in the formal probate process. Consequently, the court ordered the executors to apply for probate in solemn form. Costs were reserved pending the outcome of the solemn form application.