Construction Advantage Limited v Eljayej Holdings Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND HAMILTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA KIRIKIRIROA ROHE

CIV-2024-419-314

[2025] NZHC 1749

BETWEEN

CONSTRUCTION ADVANTAGE LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

ELJAYEJ HOLDINGS LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 12 February 2025

Appearances:

KA Lomas and JM Perry for the Plaintiff CT Gudsell KC for the Defendant

Judgment:

1 July 2025


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SUSSOCK


This judgment was delivered by me on 1 July 2025 at 4 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Braun, Bond & Lomas, Hamilton

Evan Henderson Woodbridge, Marton

CONSTRUCTION ADVANTAGE LTD v ELJAYEJ HOLDINGS LTD [2025] NZHC 1749 [1 July 2025]

Introduction

[1]    Construction Advantage Limited (CAL) applies for summary judgment for payment of the amount claimed in its final payment claim of $417,859.26 on the basis that the payment schedule issued by Eljayej Holdings Limited (EHL) in response does not meet the requirements of s 21 of the Construction Contracts Act 2002 (CCA). Where a compliant payment schedule is not issued within the required time, the party issuing the payment claim is entitled to recover the amount claimed as a debt due pursuant to the “pay now, argue later” regime provided by the CCA.1

[2]    Section 21 of the CCA requires a payment schedule to state a scheduled amount and, if less than the amount claimed, indicate the reasons for the difference and, if the payer is withholding payment on any basis, the payer’s reasons for doing so.

[3]    CAL submits that the reasons given by EHL in its payment schedule are not sufficient to meet the s 21 requirements.

[4]    The timing of the payment schedule and the recording of the scheduled amount as nil are not in issue. The sole issue is whether the reasons provided are sufficient to meet the requirements of the CCA.

[5]    I set out the principles applying to summary judgment and the relevant provisions of the CCA before considering the above question.

Summary judgment principles

[6]Rule 12.2(1) of the High Court Rules 2016 (HCR) provides:

The court may give judgment against a defendant if the plaintiff satisfies the court that the defendant has no defence to a cause of action in the statement of claim or to a particular part of any such cause of action.


1      Construction Contracts Act 2002, ss 22–23. See also SRG Global Remediation Services (NZ) Ltd v Body Corporate 197281 [2023] NZSC 22 at [6].

[7]    The principles applying to a plaintiff’s application for summary judgment are well established and are summarised by the Court of Appeal in Krukziener v Hanover Finance Ltd:2

(a)The question on a summary judgment application is whether the defendant has no defence to the claim; that is, that there is no real question to be tried.3

(b)The court must be left without any real doubt or uncertainty. The onus is on the plaintiff, but where its evidence is sufficient to show there is no defence, the defendant will have to respond if the application is to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Construction Advantage Limited v Eljayej Holdings Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NZHC 1749
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Construction Advantage Limited (CAL) filed for summary judgment against Eljayej Holdings Limited (EHL) for the sum of $417,859.26 as claimed in its final payment claim. CAL argued that EHL's payment schedule did not comply with section 21 of the Construction Contracts Act 2002 (CCA), and therefore, it was entitled to recover the amount claimed under the "pay now, argue later" regime. The court's task was to determine whether the reasons provided by EHL in its payment schedule were sufficient to meet the requirements of the CCA.

The court considered the principles of summary judgment and the relevant provisions of the CCA. The court noted that a payment schedule must indicate the reasons for the difference between the scheduled amount and the claimed amount and, if the payer is withholding payment on any basis, the payer's reasons for doing so. The court also noted that the New Zealand courts have adopted a pragmatic, common sense and contextual approach to whether a payment claim complies with the CCA. The court further noted that the requirement is to indicate the reason or reasons for the deduction, and how that is done may vary according to the circumstances of the contract and the practice of the parties, provided that the reason or reasons are adequately indicated.

The court then considered the payment schedule issued by EHL in response to CAL's final payment claim. The payment schedule stated that the reason for the difference between the scheduled sum and the claimed amount was that the principal disputed the claimed sum was owed. The payment schedule further stated that the claimed sum was disputed for the reasons set out in previous letters from EHL's solicitors to CAL's solicitors. The court noted that the 19 January 2024 letter was marked "without prejudice" and did not set out any substantive reasoning for the variations being disputed. However, the court considered that the letter clearly recorded that EHL did not accept any new information was provided in December 2023 and asked CAL, if they dispute that, to specifically identify the new information. The court further noted that the letter specifically referred to the four variations that were the subject of the payment claim and correspondence between the parties in respect of those variations since April 2023.

The court then considered the 28 February 2024 letter, which stated that quoting from earlier letters in selected fashion was not getting their clients anywhere and that EHL did not consider that there was any additional information in the December correspondence. The court noted that the letter expressly recorded that EHL did not accept the assertions made by CAL in relation to its dealing with Waikato Decorators for the reasons stated in its earlier emails and that nothing provided since those emails changed their view. The court further noted that the letter stated that EHL considered it had exhaustively attempted to address matters both in direct communication and through legal input without success and that as matters currently stood, EHL saw no reason to make any additional payments in respect of the remaining disputed variations and did not now see any merit in a meeting of the parties.

The court then considered whether the payment schedule sufficiently indicated the reasons. The court noted that there was no question that the payment schedule sufficiently indicated both the reasons for why the scheduled amount was less, because variations 7, 10, 12 and 13 were disputed, and that those disputes arose because EHL considered the variations were not properly claimed in accordance with the contract or evidenced as required. The court further noted that the fact that EHL had paid part of variations 10 and 12 did not affect this conclusion because EHL's solicitors expressly recorded that EHL preferred to adopt a pragmatic rather than overly legalistic response.

The court then considered whether the payment schedule allowed CAL to assess whether to accept the deduction or follow the dispute resolution provisions. The court noted that the requirement was not for EHL to indicate the reasons to allow CAL to understand the dispute itself but simply to allow CAL to assess whether to accept the deduction or follow the dispute resolution provisions. The court further noted that if a common understanding of the dispute were required, the "pay now, argue later" regime would be significantly undermined as it would create considerable uncertainty as to whether a payment schedule complied.

In these circumstances, the court declined to grant summary judgment and reserved costs. The court directed EHL to file and serve its statement of defence by a specified date and for the parties to file a joint memorandum addressing the matters referred to in the rules by another specified date.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.