IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE
CIV-2024-485-365
[2024] NZHC 2306
BETWEEN COMMERCE COMMISSION
Plaintiff
AND
FOODSTUFFS NORTH ISLAND LIMITED
Defendant
Hearing: 8 August 2024 Counsel:
F J Cuncannon and J P W Leslie for Plaintiff I J Thain for Defendant
Judgment:
16 August 2024
JUDGMENT OF RADICH J
(Reasons)
[1] In early 2015 and early 2016, Foodstuffs North Island Ltd caused restrictive covenants to be registered over titles to land in order to hinder its competitors.
[2] It did not intend to breach the Commerce Act 1986 at the time but it accepts now that, in breach of s 28 of the Commerce Act, the covenants had the purpose of substantially lessening competition in relevant markets.
[3] Foodstuffs North Island and the Commerce Commission have, together, settled the terms of an agreed statement of facts in the proceeding and, on the basis of it,1 they have agreed upon the penalty to be recommended to the Court.
1 In a notice of admissions, given by Foodstuffs North Island in accordance with r 15.16 of the High Court Rules 2016, Foodstuffs North Island admitted the facts set out in the agreed statement of facts and the causes of action in the statement of claim.
COMMERCE COMMISSION v FOODSTUFFS NORTH ISLAND LTD [2024] NZHC 2306 [16 August 2024]
[4] Nonetheless, the Court must be satisfied for itself that the proposed penalty is within the appropriate range having regard to the objectives of the Act and the circumstances of the case.
[5]For the reasons that follow, I am satisfied that it is.2
The industry, the participants and the markets
[6] Consumers can choose from a range of retailer operations when purchasing groceries. They include supermarkets, smaller format grocery stores, specialist grocery operators (such as butchers, greengrocers, delicatessens, chemists and bottle shops), mixed grocery general retailers (such as The Warehouse), international food stores, meal kit operators (such as Hello Fresh and My Food Bag), general merchandisers (such as K Mart), retail convenience stores (such as dairies) and online shopping sites for home delivery or store pick-up (such as the Honest Grocer and Supie).
[7] But large retail grocery stores continue to have a prominent place in relevant markets. The two largest grocery retailer operations in the North Island are Foodstuffs North Island3 and Woolworths New Zealand Ltd.
[8] Foodstuffs North Island’s retail banners are PAK’nSAVE, New World and Four Square. Woolworths NZ’s retail banners are Countdown, Woolworths, FreshChoice and SuperValue.4 In competing for retail customers, relevant factors for Foodstuffs North Island and Woolworths NZ are the location, size and ease of access to stores, as well as the price of the goods sold at those stores.
[9] The bounds of the many local markets within which individual supermarkets are located are not able to be defined easily, given the differences that exist between geographic areas, the distribution of populations relative to stores and transport
2 This decision follows an oral results decision, with…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Commerce Commission v Foodstuffs North Island Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NZHC 2306
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine the appropriate penalty under s 80 of the Commerce Act. The court assessed the appropriate starting point for the penalty, taking into account factors such as the nature and seriousness of the conduct, the duration of the contravention, and the market in which Foodstuffs operates. The court also considered mitigating factors, such as Foodstuffs' cooperation with the Commission and its efforts to discharge the restrictive covenants.
The court concluded that a starting point of between $4.5 million and $5.5 million was appropriate, given the seriousness of the conduct and the market in which Foodstuffs operates. The court then applied a 30% discount for mitigating factors, resulting in a final penalty of $3.25 million. The court found that this penalty was within the appropriate range and reflected the application of the totality principle to the conduct in question.
The court made declarations that Foodstuffs contravened s 28 of the Commerce Act in relation to the restrictive covenants registered over the titles to the properties. The court ordered Foodstuffs to pay a pecuniary penalty of $3.25 million to the Crown. No order for costs was made in accordance with the agreement of the parties.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi