Commerce Commission v Foodstuffs North Island Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2024-485-365

[2024] NZHC 2222

BETWEEN

COMMERCE COMMISSION

Plaintiff

AND

FOODSTUFFS NORTH ISLAND LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 8 August 2024

Counsel:

F J Cuncannon and J P W Leslie for Plaintiff I J Thain for Defendant

Judgment:

8 August 2024


ORAL JUDGMENT OF RADICH J

(Result)


This oral decision, giving a result in the proceeding with brief reasons, was delivered at the conclusion of the hearing today. A fully reasoned decision will follow.

[1]                 Foodstuffs North Island admits contravening s 28 of the Commerce Act 1986 by registering restrictive land covenants in breach of s 28 of the Act. In the reasoned decision that will follow, declarations will be made to that effect.

[2]                 Section 28(1) of the Act provides that no person, either on his own or on behalf of an associated person, shall require the giving of a covenant, or give a covenant, that has the purpose, or has or is likely to have the effect, of substantially lessening competition in a market. The focus on this case is not on effect but is on purpose, for reasons that I will expand upon briefly in a moment.

COMMERCE COMMISSION v FOODSTUFFS NORTH ISLAND LTD [2024] NZHC 2222 [8 August 2024]

[3]                 The restrictive land covenants to which this proceeding relates were used in three locations – Newtown in Wellington, Petone in Lower Hutt and Tamatea in South Napier.

[4]                 The question for the Court today is whether to approve a penalty for those contraventions that is agreed by the parties. The Court makes an assessment of whether the jointly recommended penalty is within the appropriate range. It must be satisfied that it is. In order to be satisfied, it undertakes its own analysis of the facts and circumstances, the relevant statutory provisions, the objectives of the Act, the principles that emerge from the provisions, and previous decisions of the Court imposing penalties under the same or similar provisions in the Act.

[5]                 The restrictive land covenants in question here are documents that are registered on land titles and which restrict the use of that land in some way or another. Documents of that sort were registered over properties near to supermarkets of Foodstuffs North Island’s competitors to limit their expansion, or properties near to Foodstuffs North Island supermarkets to restrict competition nearby.

[6]                 Relevant considerations for me, in looking at the facts and circumstances of the case are these:

(a)The conduct is serious. It gives rise to significant competition issues.

(b)It was intended, when the covenants were put in place, that they would bind the owners and subsequent purchasers of the land in question for periods of up to 99 years.

(c)However, the conduct was historic, it occurred only between June 2014 and February 2015, when one looks at the periods of time in which the most relevant aspects of the conduct occurred.

(d)The covenants reflected a deliberate effort to hinder competitors…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commerce Commission v Foodstuffs North Island Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 2222
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Commerce Commission v Foodstuffs North Island Limited involves a dispute where the Commerce Commission, acting as the plaintiff, accused Foodstuffs North Island Limited, the defendant, of contravening Section 28 of the Commerce Act 1986. Specifically, the defendant admitted to registering restrictive land covenants that were in breach of the Act's provisions aimed at preventing substantially lessening competition. The case was heard in the High Court of New Zealand at Wellington, and the decision was rendered orally on August 8, 2024, with a fully reasoned decision to follow. Foodstuffs North Island admitted to the contraventions and agreed to the declarations that would be made to that effect.

The legal issues that the court had to decide included whether the penalty proposed by both parties for the contraventions was appropriate under the Act. The court had to assess the penalty within the appropriate range by considering the facts and circumstances of the case, the relevant statutory provisions, the objectives of the Act, and previous court decisions imposing penalties under similar provisions. The court's task was to determine whether the penalty of $3.25 million, as agreed upon by the parties, was suitable and aligned with the statutory objectives and principles.

The court found that the contraventions were serious, as they involved significant competition issues and were intended to hinder competitors for up to 99 years. However, the conduct was historic, occurring between June 2014 and February 2015, and Foodstuffs North Island had not sought to enforce any of the covenants. The company began voluntarily discharging all of the covenants in June 2021 and has provided public updates on its website, which served an important educative role. The court also noted that the relevant covenants were limited to specific locations and generated a small fraction of Foodstuffs North Island's overall income. Moreover, the company had cooperated with the Commission throughout the investigation and market study, and it acknowledged the contraventions at the earliest possible stage. Based on these considerations, the court determined that a penalty of $3.25 million, which included a 30 per cent discount for the company's good record and efforts, was within the appropriate range.

The court imposed a penalty of $3.25 million on Foodstuffs North Island Limited under Section 80(1) of the Commerce Act 1986 for all of the contraventions that were in issue. Costs were not sought and were left to lie where they fell.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established