Charteris v Ministry for Primary Industries

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA AHURIRI ROHE

CRI-2023-441-014

[2023] NZHC 3321

SIMON JOHN MINSON CHARTERIS

v

MINISTRY FOR PRIMARY INDUSTRIES

Hearing: 26 September 2023 and 11 October 2023

Appearances:

E J Forster for Appellant

J D Bridgman for Respondent

Judgment:

22 November 2023


JUDGMENT OF GRICE J

(Appeal against conviction. Interim suppression request)


Introduction

[1]    Mr Simon Charteris operates a specialist farming business involving aggregating near end-of-life rams from around the country on his property in Hastings. The rams are held for a short period before moving to a meat processing plant, Progressive Meats Ltd (PML) also in Hastings. Mr Charteris’ business requires transportation of the rams to his property, and then on to PML.1


1      Ministry for Primary Industries v Charteris [2023] NZDC 3883 [Liability Decision] at [1]. This appeal was part heard on 26 September 2023 and adjourned to enable the complete District Court file to be transferred to the High Court.

CHARTERIS v MINISTRY FOR PRIMARY INDUSTRIES [2023] NZHC 3321 [22 November 2023]

[2] On 10 March 2023, the Judge found Mr Charteris guilty of three charges under s 23(2)(c) of the Animal Welfare Act 1999 (the AWA); namely, permitting, without reasonable excuse, the transport of an animal while the condition or health of that animal rendered it unfit to be transported.2

[3]    On 18 August 2023 the Court sentenced Mr Charteris to pay a $3800.00 fine on the charges. In that decision, The Judge also declined Mr Charteris’ application for permanent name suppression.3

[4]    Mr Charteris now seeks to appeal his convictions, pursuant to s 229 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011 (the CPA). Mr Charteris has interim name suppression pending the outcome of the appeal. He does not seek continued name suppression beyond the delivery of the appeal decision, nor does he appeal the sentence.

Liability Decision of The Judge

[5]    The Judge began by setting out a summary of the allegations in relation to each of the three charges;4

(a)Charge  one  (CRN  –037):  it  was  alleged  that   Mr  Charteris,  on   5 August 2020, permitted a ram, without reasonable excuse, to be transported to PML whilst it was suffering from severe bilateral foreleg lameness, meaning the ram was not fit for transport.

(b)Charge  two  (CRN  –038):  it  was  alleged  that  Mr  Charteris,  on  11 November 2020, permitted a ram, without reasonable excuse, to be transported to PML whilst it was suffering from severe lameness on its right front leg and was non-weight bearing, meaning the ram was unfit for transport.


2      Liability Decision, above n 1; Animal Welfare Act 1999 (AWA), ss 23(2)(c) and 25(a) (maximum penalty 12 months’ imprisonment or fine not exceeding $50,000 or both).

3      Ministry for Primary Industries v Charteris [2023] NZDC 12477 [Sentence and Suppression Decision].

4      Liability Decision, above n 1, at [2].

(c)Charge  three  (CRN  –039):  it  was  alleged  that  Mr  Charteris,  on  2 December 2020, permitted a ram, without reasonable excuse, to be transported to PML with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Charteris v Ministry for Primary Industries and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 3321
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Simon John Minson Charteris, the appellant, has brought an appeal against his conviction on three charges under s 23(2)(c) of the Animal Welfare Act 1999 (the AWA) in the High Court. Charteris was convicted of permitting the transport of animals while they were unfit to be transported. The Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI), the respondent, brought the charges against Charteris in relation to the transport of three rams to a meat processing plant, Progressive Meats Ltd (PML). The appellant’s primary contentions are that the District Court Judge misapplied the onus and standard of proof, failed to identify the critical issue of whether the injuries could have occurred after transportation, and made a broad conclusory credibility preference in preferring the prosecution’s vet evidence over that of the defence vet’s evidence. The respondent submits that the Judge did not misapply the onus of proof or make a conclusory credibility preference. The respondent submits that the Judge assessed all of the evidence provided and came to the conclusion that the rams were unfit for transport at the relevant time, to the requisite standard of beyond reasonable doubt.

In Charteris v Ministry for Primary Industries, the High Court held that the appeal against conviction was dismissed. The Judge did not misapply the onus of proof or make a conclusory credibility preference. The Judge correctly assessed all of the evidence provided and came to the conclusion that the rams were unfit for transport at the relevant time, to the requisite standard of beyond reasonable doubt. The Judge’s comment that there was “no evidence … supporting that [defence] submission” does not lend itself to the Judge finding there was no evidence at all offered by the defence in relation to a particular point or issue. The statement portrays that there was no evidence that advanced the point sought to be made. This is a finding that was open for the Judge to have made. The Judge did not make sweeping or conclusory credibility preferences in relation to the witnesses. The Judge did not suggest that the defence witness was not a credible witness, rather, he concluded that the evidence of the prosecution witnesses was more accurate given their ability to observe the rams at the relevant time. It is a matter of common sense given the issues in this case as to why first-hand experience evidence may be preferred. Injuries to animals can be detected by senses such as smell. The evaluation of evidence requires assessments of credibility, consistency, and reliability, and there is nothing to suggest that the Judge did not take these considerations into account when evaluating the expert evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.