IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA AHURIRI ROHE
CRI-2024-441-002
[2024] NZHC 353
BETWEEN SIMON JOHN MINSON CHARTERIS
Appellant
AND
MINISTRY FOR PRIMARY INDUSTRIES
Respondent
Hearing (via VMR): 27 February 2024 Appearances:
E J Forster for Appellant
J D Bridgman for Respondent
Judgment:
28 February 2024
JUDGMENT OF GRAU J
[Sentence appeal]
Introduction
[1] On 10 March 2023, following a Judge-alone trial, Mr Charteris was found guilty of three charges under s 23(2)(c) of the Animal Welfare Act 1999. The charges related to the transportation of rams which were found to have been unfit to be transported by Mr Charteris’ specialist farm business, where end-of-life rams were aggregated onto his property at Hastings and held for a short period before they were sent for processing through Progressive Meats Ltd, also in Hastings.1
1 Ministry for Primary Industries v Charteris [2023] NZDC 3883. The maximum penalty for each charge is 12 months’ imprisonment and/or a $50,000 fine.
CHARTERIS v MINISTRY FOR PRIMARY INDUSTRIES [2024] NZHC 353 [28 February 2024]
[2] On 18 August 2023, Judge Matenga declined Mr Charteris’ application to be discharged without conviction under s 106 of the Sentencing Act 2002, convicted Mr Charteris, and fined him $3,800.2
[3] Mr Charteris appealed to this Court against his convictions. He did not appeal his fine or the refusal to discharge him without conviction. Justice Grice dismissed the appeal against conviction on 22 November 2023.3
[4] On 11 January 2024, Mr Charteris filed a notice of appeal against sentence; advanced only in relation to the Judge’s failure to grant him a discharge without conviction. The appeal was out of time. The Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) did not oppose the application for leave to extend the time to appeal his sentence and, on 2 February 2024, Grice J granted leave.4
[5] The basis of Mr Charteris’ appeal is that the Judge did not adequately consider his previous good character, nor did he consider factors that might have had a detrimental impact on his business. He argues it was inconsistent for the Judge to have found a real and appreciable risk of future employability being impacted by a conviction, but that it would not be so impacted because Mr Charteris was self- employed, despite Mr Charteris’ evidence that he would need to seek employment in light of pressures on his business.
[6] Although MPI did not oppose Mr Charteris’ application for leave to appeal, MPI now submits that this Court has no jurisdiction to hear the appeal against the refusal to grant a discharge without conviction because it is an appeal against conviction, and this Court has already heard and determined Mr Charteris’ conviction appeal.
[7] The appeal thus raises a preliminary jurisdictional question. After considering the issue and discussing it with counsel, I consider this issue needs to be determined
2 Ministry for Primary Industries v Charteris [2023] NZDC 12477. An application for permanent name suppression was also declined.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Charteris v Ministry for Primary Industries and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NZHC 353
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal has established that an appeal against a refusal to discharge without conviction is a composite appeal against conviction and sentence. The essence of the challenge is to the entry of a conviction, with setting aside the conviction being the necessary prerequisite to the appeal. The Court of Appeal in Jackson v R clarified that if the conviction appeal fails, the Court must proceed to determine whether the end sentence imposed was correct. The Criminal Procedure Act 2011 governs sentence appeals, but it does not provide for a second conviction appeal to the High Court. Instead, any second appeal must be by a grant of leave to the Court of Appeal.
The Court determined that it lacked jurisdiction to hear Mr Charteris' appeal. Although Mr Charteris argued that a strict interpretation of the appeal pathways in the Criminal Procedure Act 2011 was inconsistent with the right to appeal against conviction, sentence, or both, the Court found that this right of appeal existed but to a different Court. The Court of Appeal had already clarified the nature of such an appeal. The Court acknowledged some sympathy for Mr Charteris' position, but it could not entertain a second appeal under the Court's inherent jurisdiction due to the existence of an alternative effective remedy.
The Court dismissed the appeal, finding no jurisdiction to hear the second appeal against conviction. To the extent the appeal was an appeal against sentence, it was also dismissed. Mr Charteris had not appealed his sentence of a $3,800 fine.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.