Brian Green Properties (1971) Limited v Bindon Holdings Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2015-412-000121 [2016] NZHC 1993

IN THE MATTER OF

AND

the Property Law Act 2007

IN THE MATTER OF

an application by BRIAN GREEN PROPERTIES (1971) LIMITED for relief from cancellation of a Lease Instrument dated 27 April 2009

BETWEEN

BRIAN GREEN PROPERTIES (1971) LIMITED

Applicant

AND

BINDON HOLDINGS LIMITED Respondent

CIV-2016-409-000048

IN THE MATTER OF

AND

the Property Law Act 2007

IN THE MATTER OF       an application by BINDON HOLDINGS LIMITED for an order for vacant possession

BETWEEN  BINDON HOLDINGS LIMITED Applicant

ANDBRIAN GREEN PROPERTIES (1971) LIMITED

Respondent

Hearing: 20 July 2016

Appearances:

J W Maassen for Applicant
J M Moran for Respondent

Judgment:

25 August 2016

BRIAN GREEN PROPERTIES (1971) LIMITED v BINDON HOLDINGS LIMITED [2016] NZHC 1993 [25

August 2016]

JUDGMENT OF DUNNINGHAM J

Introduction

[1]      This is a dispute over the performance of a covenant in a ground lease (or Glasgow   lease)   between   Bindon   Holdings   Limited   (Bindon)   as   lessor   and Brian Green Properties (1971) Limited (BGPL) as lessee.   The leased property is located at 112 Anzac Avenue, Dunedin.   It is located in an area that is zoned for campus use, although it is adjacent to industrially zoned land, and is near to the new, covered Forsyth Barr stadium in Dunedin.   On the property stands a large, rather run-down warehouse (the building).

[2]      The dispute between BGPL and Bindon is over whether BGPL has complied with its obligations to keep the improvements on the land in “good and tenantable condition”.   Bindon says that BGPL’s failure to comply with notices to undertake repairs warranted cancellation of the ground lease.  That prompted an application by BGPL  for  relief  against  cancellation  of  the  lease  pursuant  to  s  253  of  the Property Law  Act  2007  (PLA).     In  response,  Bindon  has  applied  for  vacant possession, pursuant to s 250 of the PLA or, in the alternative, for orders which include  requiring  BGPL to  meet  the  cost  of  bringing  the  premises  back  to  the standard required or, alternatively, to demolish the premises.

[3]      At issue in the proceedings is:

(a)       whether there has been a breach of the covenant to repair given:

(i)BGPL’s position that the lease commenced on 1 October 2008 when the building was in substantially the same condition at that time as it is now; and

(ii)      having regard to the terms of s 223 of the PLA;

(b)if there has been a breach, has a loss been suffered such as would warrant cancellation?

(c)       if there is a right to cancel, should the Court exercise its discretion to grant relief against cancellation?

The leasing arrangements

[4]      To place the issues in context, it is necessary to set out some of the history of the lease arrangements for the property.

[5]      The property is subject to a Glasgow lease.  A description of such leases was given in Mandic v Cornwall Park Trustboard Inc as follows:1

[25]     Long-term ground leases (usually of 14 or 21 years) renewable in perpetuity with rent calculated either…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brian Green Properties (1971) Limited v Bindon Holdings Limi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 1993
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bindon Holdings Limited, the lessor, filed an application for an order for vacant possession against Brian Green Properties (1971) Limited, the lessee, pursuant to s 250 of the Property Law Act 2007 (PLA). This followed Bindon's cancellation of the lease due to the lessee's failure to comply with notices to undertake repairs. In response, the lessee filed an application for relief against cancellation of the lease pursuant to s 253 of the PLA. The court was required to determine whether the lessee's failure to maintain the leased premises constituted a breach of the covenant to repair, whether such a breach warranted cancellation, and if relief against cancellation should be granted. The court found that a new lease had been created in 2009, and the covenant to repair required the lessee to put the building in good and tenantable condition. The lessee's failure to maintain the building constituted a breach of the covenant. However, relief against cancellation was granted on the condition that if the covenant was not complied with within 24 months, the lessee must provide security to the lessor for the sum of $1,549,000 or such other sum as the parties agree or as is fixed by the court.

The dispute in this case was between Bindon Holdings Limited, the lessor, and Brian Green Properties (1971) Limited, the lessee, over the performance of a covenant in a ground lease to keep the improvements on the land in "good and tenantable condition". The lessor claimed that the lessee's failure to comply with notices to undertake repairs warranted cancellation of the ground lease. The lessee, on the other hand, sought relief against cancellation of the lease. The court had to decide whether there had been a breach of the covenant to repair, whether such a breach warranted cancellation, and if relief against cancellation should be granted.

The court found that a new lease had been created in 2009, and the covenant to repair required the lessee to put the building in good and tenantable condition. The lessee's failure to maintain the building constituted a breach of the covenant. However, relief against cancellation was granted on the condition that if the covenant was not complied with within 24 months, the lessee must provide security to the lessor for the sum of $1,549,000 or such other sum as the parties agree or as is fixed by the court. The court considered that there was no immediate risk of loss to the lessor, and the lessee was solvent and was the owner of the building. The court also noted that the lessor had been content for many years to allow the maintenance obligations to slide. However, the court was not prepared to grant the relief sought by the lessee, as it would render the covenant unenforceable except in an action for damages. The court considered that a fairer exercise of the discretion would be to allow the lessee relief against cancellation, but on certain conditions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established