Brian Green Properties (1971) Limited v Bindon Holdings Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2015-412-000121 [2016] NZHC 2847

BETWEEN

BRIAN GREEN PROPERTIES (1971)

LIMITED Applicant

AND

BINDON HOLDINGS LIMITED Respondent

CIV-2016-409-000048

BETWEEN  BINDON HOLDINGS LIMITED Applicant

ANDBRIAN GREEN PROPERTIES (1971) LIMITED

Respondent

CIV-2016-409-000047

BETWEEN  BRIAN GREEN PROPERTIES (1971) LIMITED

Applicant

ANDBINDON HOLDINGS LIMITED Respondent

Hearing: 28 November 2016 (On the papers)

Appearances:

J W Maassen for Applicant
J M Moran for Respondent

Judgment:

28 November 2016

JUDGMENT OF DUNNINGHAM J RE:  COSTS DECISION

[1]      This application for costs arises out of three sets of proceedings. These are:

BRIAN GREEN PROPERTIES (1971) LIMITED v BINDON HOLDINGS LIMITED [2016] NZHC 2847 [28 November 2016]

(a)       Brian Green Properties (1971) Limited’s (BGPL) application for relief against cancellation (CIV-2015-412-000121);

(b)Bindon   Holdings   Limited’s   (Bindon)   application   for   an   order appointing an arbitrator CIV-2016-409-000047); and

(c)       Bindon’s     application     for    an     order     for     vacant    possession

(CIV-2016-409-000048).

[2]      The proceedings arose out of a dispute over the performance of a covenant in a Glasgow lease between Bindon and BGPL.1     Specifically, Bindon alleged that BGPL had not complied with its obligation to keep the improvements on the land in “good  and  tenantable  condition”.    While  I  found  there  were  breaches  of  the covenant, Bindon was not in any immediate risk of financial loss.  The nature and duration of the lease meant that even if the covenant to “keep in good and tenantable

condition” was not fulfilled, Bindon’s only potential loss was when the lease terminated.  This was because rent was calculated on the unimproved value of the land and the improvements belonged to the tenant.  The landlord might incur the cost of repair or demolition at the end of the lease if one of these options had not been completed by the tenant before then.

[3]      In  the  end,  I  granted  relief  against  cancellation,  albeit  on  terms,  and  I

reserved the issue of costs.

[4]      The remaining application for an appointment of an arbitrator to determine a rental dispute was resolved between the parties.

[5]      Costs on all three applications have not been agreed and the parties have sought a determination from the Court.

1      Brian Green Properties (1971) Ltd v Bindon Holdings Ltd [2016] NZHC 1993.

Submissions

Bindon Holdings Limited

[6]      Bindon submits that costs should be paid by BGPL on the basis that, whilst relief against cancellation was granted, this was an indulgence in the circumstances as the litigation had been precipitated by BGPL’s breach of the covenant to repair under the lease.  It notes my express finding that there had been a clear breach of the covenant, citing the engineer’s report on the large number of items required to be fixed.

[7]      Bindon seek costs on the application and cross application which were heard on 20 July 2016, which, on a 2B basis, it calculates at $15,164 plus disbursements of

$11,030.60.  However, it argues that the circumstances support an award of increased costs pursuant to r 14.6 and submits that an award of costs should be made in the sum of $23,000,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brian Green Properties (1971) Limited v Bindon Holdings Limi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 2847
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves a dispute between Brian Green Properties (1971) Limited (BGPL) and Bindon Holdings Limited (Bindon) over the performance of a covenant in a Glasgow lease. The dispute led to three sets of proceedings: an application for relief against cancellation, an application for the appointment of an arbitrator to determine a rental dispute, and an application for an order for vacant possession. The primary issue was the determination of costs associated with these proceedings.

The court had to decide whether costs should follow the event or be awarded to the party who was successful in their primary objectives, considering the broader policy considerations and the conduct of the parties. Bindon argued that the grant of relief against cancellation was an indulgence and sought increased costs. BGPL, on the other hand, contended that it was the predominantly successful party and should be awarded costs.

The court found that while there were breaches of the covenant, there was no immediate risk of financial loss to Bindon due to the specific terms of the lease. The court held that the grant of relief against cancellation was not an indulgence in these circumstances and that BGPL should be considered the predominantly successful party. The court awarded costs to BGPL, discounted by 25%, totaling $18,680.93, and ordered that costs in the proceeding for the appointment of an arbitrator lie where they fall.

The final orders were that BGPL was to pay costs to Bindon of $18,680.93, and the amount for security to be provided by BGPL to Bindon was not to be amended.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established