Body Corporate 378351 v Auckland Council

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2018-404-2053

[2020] NZHC 2987

IN THE MATTER OF Washington Apartments

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 378351

First Plaintiff

CATHERINE RACHEL KEMP & ORS
Second Plaintiffs

AND

AUCKLAND COUNCIL

First Defendant

DOWNER NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Second Defendant

…Cont over

Hearing: On the papers

Appearances:

TJ Rainey & GR Grant for the Plaintiffs

SB Mitchell and K Perry for the First Defendant
LL Fraser and Z Wall-Manning for Ninth Third Party

Judgment:

11 November 2020


RESERVED JUDGMENT (No.2) OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SMITH - COSTS


This judgment was delivered by me on 11 November 2020 at 5pm

……………………………………….

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors/Counsel:

Rainey Law, Auckland Heaney & Partners, Auckland Bell Gully, Auckland

Chapman Tripp, Auckland Kensington Swan, Auckland

Chancery Chambers, Auckland

Body Corporate 378351 v Auckland Council & Ors [2020] NZHC 2987 [11 November 2020]

STEPHEN MITCHELL ENGINEERS LIMITED

First Third Party

STEPHEN ROBERT MITCHELL
Second Third Party

MAXINE BRANNIGAN
Third Third Party

WOODHAMS MEIKLE ZHAN ARCHITECTS LIMITED

Fourth Third Party

MICHAEL JOHN STEPHEN

WOODHAMS – Discontinued Fifth Third Party

JEFFREY LAWRENCE BIRD
Sixth Third Party

FAÇADE DESIGN SERVICES LIMITED

Seventh Third Party

RONALD CHARLES HANLEY
Eighth Third Party

BECA CARTER HOLDINGS & FERNER LIMITED

Ninth Third Party

BRIAN CHIN
Tenth Third Party

RACHEL CARTER
Eleventh Third Party

STAHLTON PRESTRESSED

CONCRETE an operating division of Fulton Hogan Limited

Twelfth Third Party

… Cont over

BRADNAM’S WINDOWS & DOORS

an operating division of Altus NZ Limited

Thirteenth Third Party

WARWICK BELL – Discontinued Fourteenth Third Party

GAVIN SMITH
Fifteenth Third Party

[1]    In a reserved judgment dated 15 July 2020 (the judgment),1 I struck out certain parts of the plaintiffs’ claims against the first defendant (the Council). I also struck out the Council’s third party claims against the ninth third party (Beca) and the twelfth third party (Stahlton). I indicated in the judgment that if the parties were unable to agree on costs, memoranda could be filed.

[2]    Since the judgment was issued, the Council has agreed with Beca and Stahlton the amounts to be paid to them for costs. The Council has agreed to pay Beca’s reasonable scale costs and disbursements totalling $14,750.94, and Stahlton’s reasonable scale costs and disbursements totalling $17,798.46. In agreeing those costs figures with Beca and Stahlton, the Council reserved its position to claim reimbursement from the plaintiffs for the amounts paid to Beca and Stahlton.

[3]    The Council has not been able to resolve its claim for costs against the plaintiffs. Specifically, the Council and the plaintiffs have been unable to agree on:

(i)The costs the Council claims from the plaintiffs as a result of the fire and structural defects having been struck out; and


1      Body Corporate 378351 v Auckland Council [2020] NZHC 1701.

(ii)Whether the costs of Beca and Stahlton should be paid by the Council or by the plaintiffs.

[4]    Memoranda have been received from counsel for the Council and the plaintiffs, and a short memorandum has been filed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 378351 v Auckland Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 2987
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Body Corporate 378351 brought proceedings against Auckland Council and others, claiming damages for defects in the Washington Apartments. The Council struck out certain claims and third party claims. The Council then applied for costs, claiming $70,106. The plaintiffs paid $14,750.94 to Beca and $17,798.46 to Stahlton, but reserved their right to seek reimbursement from the Council. The Council claimed that the plaintiffs should reimburse them for those costs. The plaintiffs rejected the Council's claim for costs, and argued that the Council should not be entitled to reimbursement of the costs paid to Beca and Stahlton.

The Court considered the Council's claim for its own costs, and found that the Council's costs claim was limited to the strike-out application, and that it was not appropriate to award costs for steps taken in the proceeding that were not related to the strike-out application. The Court awarded the Council $8,650 in costs and disbursements relating to the strike-out application, and reserved all other costs claimed by the Council.

The Court then considered the Council's claim to recover the costs payable to Beca and Stahlton. The Court found that the Council was not entitled to reimbursement of the costs paid to Beca and Stahlton, as the third party claims against them were unjustified and unnecessary. The Court found that the limitation defence available to Beca and Stahlton rendered the Council's claims against them unjustified, and that it would be unreasonable to visit the third parties' costs on the plaintiffs in those circumstances.

The Court ordered that the plaintiffs pay the Council $8,650 for the Council's costs and disbursements on the strike-out application, and that the plaintiffs were not liable to reimburse the Council for the costs of Beca and Stahlton. The Court also ordered that Beca and Stahlton were entitled to costs from the Council on their applications to strike out the third party claims made against them, and their other costs in the proceeding to date, in the respective sums of $14,750.94 and $17,798.46.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established