Bassett-Burr v BPE Trustees (No 1) Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA503/2019
 [2020] NZCA 457

BETWEEN

ROY BASSETT-BURR
Appellant

AND

BPE TRUSTEES (NO. 1) LIMITED
First Respondent

AND

QUENTIN HAINES PROPERTIES LIMITED
Second Respondent

Hearing:

2 September 2020

Court:

Goddard, Ellis and Dunningham JJ

Counsel:

D G O Livingston for Appellant
D G Dewar for First and Second Respondents

Judgment:

29 September 2020 at 11.00 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed.

BThe order for non-party costs made against the appellant is set aside.

CThere is no order as to costs.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Dunningham J)

  1. On 30 August 2019, Churchman J made an award of costs against the appellant, Mr Bassett-Burr, in respect of a successful application by the respondents to set aside five statutory demands served on them by the trustees of Link Trust (No. 1) (the Trust).[1]

  2. Mr Bassett-Burr was not a party to the application to set aside, but was pursued for costs as a non-party, having signed the statutory demands in question in his capacity as a director of a corporate trustee of the Trust.

  3. An appeal of the decision to award costs against Mr Bassett-Burr was filed by the trustees of the Trust, being Mr Harry Memelink and Lynx Trustees Ltd.  However, following a decision of this Court on 2 June 2020, they were removed as appellants and substituted with Mr Bassett-Burr.[2]

  4. The appeal from the decision to award costs against Mr Bassett-Burr was advanced on a range of grounds including:

    (a)the failure to serve submissions in respect of the costs application on Mr Bassett-Burr, in breach of the principles of natural justice;

    (b)the absence of evidence to suggest the Trust had no assets and was unable to meet a costs award;

    (c)Mr Bassett-Burr was only involved with the service and subsequent recall of the statutory demands as a “reader-writer” for Mr Memelink who suffers from dyslexia and other physical impairments; and

    (d)Mr Bassett-Burr was acting in his capacity as a trustee of the Trust and not for personal gain or interest.

  5. On 31 August 2020, shortly before the hearing of the appeal, this Court issued a minute[3] which referred the parties to the decision in Easton Agriculture Ltd v Manawatu‑Wanganui Regional Council, where it was held that before costs are awarded against a non-party an application on notice should be made against that party.[4]  It was pointed out that no such application appeared to have been made in this case.  Counsel were asked to address that point in their oral submissions.

    [3]Bassett-Burr v BPE Trustees (No 1) Ltd CA503/2019, 31 August 2020 (Minute of Goddard J).

    [4]Easton Agriculture Ltd v Manawatu-Wanganui Regional Council HC Palmerston North CIV‑2008‑454‑31, 22 December 2011 at [50].

  6. In the end, this point proved pivotal to the appeal.

Principles applying to the award of costs against non-parties

  1. The Court has…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bassett-Burr v BPE Trustees (No 1) Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZCA 457
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Bassett-Burr v BPE Trustees (No 1) Ltd, which was heard and determined by the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, involved an appeal by Roy Bassett-Burr against a costs order made against him by the High Court. The appeal was against BPE Trustees (No. 1) Limited and Quentin Haines Properties Limited, with the appeal focusing on the legal principles surrounding the awarding of costs against non-parties in litigation. The respondents had applied to set aside statutory demands served on them by the trustees of Link Trust (No. 1), with Mr Bassett-Burr, as a director of a corporate trustee of the Trust, signing the statutory demands. Despite not being a party to the proceedings, he was pursued for costs as a non-party.

The appeal raised several grounds, including the failure to serve submissions on Mr Bassett-Burr regarding the costs application, the absence of evidence indicating the Trust's inability to meet a costs award, and Mr Bassett-Burr's limited involvement in the proceedings due to dyslexia and other impairments of Mr Memelink, for whom he acted as a 'reader-writer'. The Court's decision hinged on whether there was a proper application on notice to Mr Bassett-Burr before the costs were awarded. According to the Court, Easton Agriculture Ltd v Manawatu-Wanganui Regional Council established that an application on notice must be made to a non-party before costs can be awarded against them, a requirement not fulfilled in this case. The Court found that the respondents had not properly notified Mr Bassett-Burr of the intention to seek costs against him, nor did they provide him with the opportunity to respond, thereby breaching natural justice and depriving the Court of jurisdiction to award costs against him.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set aside the order for non-party costs made against Mr Bassett-Burr, and made no order as to costs. The decision highlighted the importance of proper notice and application procedures when seeking costs against non-parties, reinforcing the principle that such orders are exceptional and must be justified under the circumstances of each case.

Background

Background to the litigation

Roy Bassett-Burr was a director of Lynx Trustees Ltd, a corporate trustee of Link Trust (No. 1). On 30 August 2019, Churchman J made an award of costs against Mr Bassett-Burr in respect of a successful application by the respondents to set aside five statutory demands served on them by the trustees of Link Trust (No. 1). Mr Bassett-Burr was not a party to the application to set aside, but was pursued for costs as a non-party, having signed the statutory demands in question in his capacity as a director of a corporate trustee of the Trust. The appeal from the decision to award costs against Mr Bassett-Burr was advanced on a range of grounds including the failure to serve submissions in respect of the costs application on Mr Bassett-Burr, in breach of the principles of natural justice. The appeal was allowed, and the order for non-party costs set aside.

The appeal from the decision to award costs against Mr Bassett-Burr was initially filed by the trustees of the Trust, being Mr Harry Memelink and Lynx Trustees Ltd. However, following a decision of this Court on 2 June 2020, they were removed as appellants and substituted with Mr Bassett-Burr. The appeal was advanced on 2 September 2020 before Goddard, Ellis, and Dunningham JJ. The Court issued a minute on 31 August 2020 referring the parties to the decision in Easton Agriculture Ltd v Manawatu-Wanganui Regional Council, where it was held that before costs are awarded against a non-party an application on notice should be made against that party. The Court heard submissions from the parties on the issue of costs on the same day as the hearing of the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the court have jurisdiction to order Mr Bassett-Burr to pay costs as a non-party?
2. Was there a breach of the principles of natural justice in the failure to serve submissions in respect of the costs application on Mr Bassett-Burr?
3. Was there evidence to suggest the Trust had no assets and was unable to meet a costs award?
4. Was Mr Bassett-Burr acting in his capacity as a trustee of the Trust and not for personal gain or interest?

Held
1. The court held that it did not have jurisdiction to order Mr Bassett-Burr to pay costs as a non-party because he was not properly notified of the application against him and the grounds on which it was being advanced, nor was he given a timeframe for responding to it, or a date for hearing. This was a breach of natural justice.
2. The court held that the appeal was allowed and the order for non-party costs made against Mr Bassett-Burr was set aside.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the principles governing the award of costs against non-parties and concluded that the non-party must be put on notice of an intention to seek costs from them. In this case, there was no formal application on notice made to Mr Bassett-Burr before the costs were awarded against him. The Court found that the email and other documents that were argued to provide notice were insufficient to constitute proper notice of the application against him and the grounds on which it was being advanced. The Court held that the lack of proper notice deprived the court of jurisdiction to make an order against Mr Bassett-Burr personally, and there was a breach of natural justice. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set aside the order for non-party costs, and made no order as to costs. The reasoning in this case emphasises the importance of proper notice to non-parties before costs can be awarded against them, and the fundamental nature of this requirement to the exercise of the court’s jurisdiction. The ratio decidendi is that a non-party must be properly notified of an application for costs against them before the court can exercise its jurisdiction to make such an order.