Ace Education New Zealand Limited v Pan

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2017-404-000360

[2019] NZHC 390

UNDER Part 18 of the High Court Rules

IN THE MATTER OF

the Companies Act 1993

BETWEEN

ACE EDUCATION NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

QIFEI PAN

Defendant

LANHUA ZHANG

Third Party

Hearing: [On the Papers]

Counsel:

B P Rooney for the Plaintiff and the Third Party D B Hickson and G J Ussher for the Defendant

Judgment:

8 March 2019


JUDGMENT OF EDWARDS J

[re Costs]


This judgment was delivered by Justice Edwards on 8 March 2019 at 3.30pm, pursuant to

r 11.56 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date:

Counsel:            B P Rooney, Auckland

Solicitors:           Fortune Manning, Auckland

D B Hickson, Auckland G J Ussher, Auckland

ACE EDUCATION NEW ZEALAND LTD v PAN & ANOR [2019] NZHC 390 [8 March 2019]

[1]    In this proceeding ACE claimed that its former director, Mr Pan, had breached his director’s duties under the Companies Act 1993 by using ACE’s funds for his personal benefit, or for the benefit of third parties. In my judgment dated 26 November 2018, I found that Mr Pan had breached his duties in relation to some, but not all, of the disputed transactions. I ordered Mr Pan to pay ACE the sum of $78,112.13.1

[2]    The parties have been unable to reach agreement on costs, and both now seek costs orders to be made in their favour. The issues to be determined are as follows:

(a)Who was the successful party?

(b)Who should be awarded costs for the discontinued counterclaim and third party claim?

(c)Are there grounds to reduce costs?

(d)Are the claimed disbursements reasonable?

Procedural history

[3]    ACE commenced its claim on 7 March 2017. It comprised 10 causes of action, with a total of approximately $420,000 claimed at that time. The statement of claim annexed schedules of transactions which formed the basis of each cause of action.

[4]    Mr Pan defended that claim, and counterclaimed for approximately $38,800, which he said was due to him once advances he had made to the company were accounted for. He also counterclaimed for the sum of approximately $9,000 in respect of the lease of ACE’s premises which Mr Pan had personally guaranteed. Mr Pan also joined Ms Zhang, a former shareholder, as a third party claiming that she owed ACE approximately $24,700, not him.

[5]    ACE filed an amended statement of claim in August 2017. That claim comprised 11 causes of action, and claimed damages totalling approximately


1      Ace Education NZ Ltd v Pan [2018] NZHC 3074.

$425,000. Mr Pan’s amended pleadings in response repeated the counterclaim and the third-party claim.

[6]    The trial commenced on 21 May 2018. On the first day of trial, ACE informed the Court that it was no longer pursuing two of the eleven pleaded causes of action, and that the quantum of damages had reduced to approximately $116,000. Mr Pan received a copy of ACE’s expert brief…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ace Education New Zealand Limited v Pan and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 390
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ace Education New Zealand Limited took legal action against its former director, Mr Pan, alleging that he had breached his director's duties under the Companies Act 1993 by using the company's funds for personal or third-party benefit. The matter was heard in the High Court of New Zealand, Auckland Registry. The court found that Mr Pan had breached his duties in relation to some transactions but not all. It ordered Mr Pan to pay Ace Education New Zealand Limited the sum of $78,112.13. Both parties were unable to agree on costs and sought costs orders in their favour. The issues to be determined included who was the successful party, who should be awarded costs for the discontinued counterclaim and third-party claim, whether there were grounds to reduce costs, and whether the claimed disbursements were reasonable.

The court found that Ace Education New Zealand Limited was the overall successful party despite not succeeding in all the causes of action. The court noted that a realistic appraisal of the end result showed that Ace Education New Zealand Limited succeeded on more limited terms. However, this still amounted to success. The court concluded that there were grounds to reduce the costs because Ace Education New Zealand Limited only succeeded to a limited extent, and the defence of the claims on which it lost significantly increased Mr Pan's costs. The court reduced the costs to 18% of what Ace Education New Zealand Limited would otherwise be entitled to claim. The court also found that the claimed disbursements, including the fees of Ace Education New Zealand Limited's expert witness, were reasonable, except that the expert's fees should be reduced by the same amount to ensure proportionality with the overall costs award.

Ace Education New Zealand Limited is awarded category 2B costs for the filing of a statement of defence to the counterclaim. The claim to costs on the third-party claim is dismissed. Ace Education New Zealand Limited is awarded 18% of the remaining category 2B costs. Ace Education New Zealand Limited is awarded reasonable disbursements, except that only 18% of the claim for expert fees is allowed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established