IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY
CIV-2015-412-000030 [2017] NZHC 1109
BETWEEN A P AND A W HUGHES LIMITED
Plaintiff
AND
ALLAN JAMES LYALL Defendant
AND
MARK BENNETT Third Party
Hearing: 20 - 28 March 2017 Appearances:
D R Tobin and R M Reeve for Plaintiffs
JCD Guest for DefendantJudgment:
26 May 2017
JUDGMENT OF DUNNINGHAM J
Contents
Introduction ............................................................................................................[1] What happened when the crop was harvested to make into silage? ......................[7] What was wrong with the silage?.........................................................................[23] What steps did the company take to mitigate its loss? .........................................[28] What damages are claimed? .................................................................................[30] What were the defendant’s contractual obligations?............................................[31] What legal principles govern the implication of terms into a contract? ..............[34] Should the pleaded terms be implied into the contract for harvesting? ...............[39] What was the extent of the duty of care owed by the defendant? ........................[44] The factual issues in dispute ................................................................................[48] Was the crop over-mature at harvest? ..................................................................[50]
Did the defendant use an acceptable harvest method? .........................................[64]
A P AND A W HUGHES LIMITED v LYALL [2017] NZHC 1109 [26 May 2017]
How did so much soil get incorporated into the silage? ......................................[74] Was Mr Lyall responsible for the raking? ............................................................[86] Was the crop negligently left on the ground one day before further processing? [94] Did the level of soil cause a problem? ...............................................................[101]
Did Mr Lyall fail to use the skill expected of a reasonably competent silage contractor? .......................................................................................................... [112]
The damages claim.............................................................................................[122] Outcome .............................................................................................................[132] Costs ...................................................................................................................[133]
Introduction
[1] The plaintiff is a dairy farming company. Tony and Wayne Hughes are its directors and shareholders. In 2014, the company was farming near Balclutha in South Otago. On the advice of a farm consultant, the Hughes decided to plant 31.5 hectares of land in a mixed pea and barley crop. The intention was to convert this into silage for winter feed. Allan Lyall, the defendant, was contracted to harvest the crop and he did so, with the assistance of other contractors, over a four day period in late February 2014.
[2] On 24 May 2014, when the silage pit was opened, the Hughes were dismayed at the quality of the silage. Those concerns were exacerbated when the cows would not eat the silage and one cow had to be put down after falling ill.
[3] Subsequent testing of the silage confirmed the Hughes’ views that the silage was of poor quality. The dry matter (DM) content was too high, the metabolisable energy (ME) content was too low, and it was significantly contaminated with soil. The Hughes attributed this to deficiencies in the harvesting process and advised Mr Lyall they considered him liable for their losses. Mr Lyall denied liability and, in due course, these proceedings issued.
[4] The parties agree that the company entered into an oral agreement with
Mr Lyall for him to harvest the mixed pea and barley crop for silage. They also
agree that it was an implied term of that agreement that Mr Lyall would use the care and skill…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read A P and a W Hughes Limited v Lyall and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] NZHC 1109
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that Mr Lyall owed a duty of care to the company to use the care and skill expected of a reasonably competent silage contractor when harvesting the peas and barley, but denied the particular allegations of breach. The court found that the company's claim for damages was overstated and that the silage would have been of inadequate quality even if it had been harvested correctly. The court held that the soil contamination reduced the utility of the silage as stock feed but that the silage would never have been good quality silage suitable as a complete food for dairy cows over winter. The court held that Mr Lyall did not breach either his implied contractual duties or a general duty of care. The outcome of poorer quality silage was simply the consequence of adopting an option agreed to by the parties to address the exigencies of the circumstances. The plaintiffs' claims were not made out and Mr Lyall, and his sub-contractor, were not liable to the company in damages.
The court awarded costs to the defendant, Allan James Lyall.