AP & AW Hughes Limited v Lyall

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA331/2017
[2018] NZCA 28

BETWEEN

AP & AW HUGHES LIMITED
Appellant

AND

ALLAN JAMES LYALL
First Respondent

AND

MARK BENNETT
Second Respondent

Hearing:

9 November 2017

Court:

Gilbert, Lang and Ellis JJ

Counsel:

R M Reeve and D R Tobin for Appellant
J C D Guest for First Respondent

Judgment:

1 March 2018 at 11 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A.         The appeal is dismissed.

B.The appellant must pay the first respondent costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis together and usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Ellis J)

  1. In the High Court the appellant[1] AP & AW Hughes Ltd (the Hughes) sued the first respondent, Mr Lyall, for breach of contract and/or negligence.  The claim related to the February 2014 harvesting by Mr Lyall of 31.5 hectares of pea and barley crop sown by the Hughes with the intention that it be made into silage to provide the Hughes’ lactating cows with winter feed.     

    [1]AP & AW Hughes Limited is a dairy farming company.  Tony and Wayne Hughes are its directors and shareholders.

  2. There was no dispute that the silage subsequently produced was substandard.  The cows refused to eat it.  Testing confirmed its poor quality. The dry matter (DM) content was too high, the metabolisable energy (ME) content was too low, and it was significantly contaminated with soil.

  3. The Hughes therefore had to make other arrangements to feed their stock over winter.  They said that Mr Lyall should bear the cost of the steps they took. 

  4. In the High Court Dunningham J disagreed.[2]  She found that the poor quality of the silage was largely due to the Hughes leaving it too late to engage Mr Lyall to do the harvesting.  This meant that by the time of harvesting, the crop had become over-mature and lignate and (she said) it was those features that led to the decrease in quality, the protein levels, and the palatability of the resulting silage.[3]

    [3]At [26].

  5. As well, the Judge held that the toughness of the stalks had caused Mr Lyall’s harvesting machine (called a “whole crop front cutting unit”) constantly to jam and, eventually, to break.  Mr Lyall immediately hired a substitute unit, but quickly became concerned that that would break too. 

  6. There was no dispute that using a whole crop front cutting unit was the preferred harvesting method (the whole crop method).[4]  But because of the mechanical difficulties Mr Lyall was experiencing, it was necessary to come up with a different method (“mow, rake, lift”) to which (the Judge found) the Hughes had agreed.[5]  She held that although the raking caused a large quantity of soil to get into the harvested crop, and therefore the silage, that did not mean that it was an unreasonable method to adopt in the circumstances or that the raking had been done carelessly.  The mowing, which was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AP & AW Hughes Limited v Lyall and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZCA 28
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

AP & AW Hughes Limited, a dairy farming company, brought a claim against Allan James Lyall for breach of contract and/or negligence. The claim related to the harvesting of a crop of peas and barley by Mr Lyall in February 2014, which was intended to be made into silage for use as winter feed for the Hughes’ lactating cows. The silage produced was substandard and the cows refused to eat it. The Hughes sued Mr Lyall for the cost of alternative arrangements made to feed their stock over winter. In the High Court, Dunningham J found that the poor quality of the silage was largely due to the Hughes leaving it too late to engage Mr Lyall to do the harvesting. This meant that by the time of harvesting, the crop had become over-mature and lignate, which led to the decrease in quality, the protein levels, and the palatability of the resulting silage. The Hughes appealed Dunningham J’s decision. The Court of Appeal found that there was ample evidence to support Dunningham J’s conclusion that, on the balance of probabilities, the crop was over-mature. The appeal was dismissed and the appellant must pay the first respondent costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

Background

Background to the litigation

AP & AW Hughes Limited, a dairy farming company, contracted with Allan James Lyall for the harvesting of 31.5 hectares of pea and barley crop intended for silage to feed their lactating cows. The harvesting took place in February 2014. The silage produced from the crop was substandard and unsuitable for the cows, leading to additional costs for the Hughes to source alternative feed. The substandard quality was attributed to high dry matter content, low metabolisable energy content, and significant soil contamination. The Hughes sued Mr Lyall for breach of contract and/or negligence, arguing that he should bear the cost of the additional feed. The High Court found in favour of Mr Lyall, concluding that the poor quality of the silage was largely due to the Hughes leaving it too late to engage Mr Lyall for the harvesting, resulting in an over-mature crop.

The case originated in the High Court where AP & AW Hughes Limited sued Allan James Lyall for breach of contract and/or negligence. The High Court dismissed the claim, finding that the poor quality of the silage was primarily due to the Hughes delaying the harvest, making the crop over-mature. The appellant, AP & AW Hughes Limited, appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. The appeal was heard on 9 November 2017, before Gilbert, Lang, and Ellis JJ, and the judgment was delivered on 1 March 2018.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the crop over-mature at the point of harvest?
2. Did Mr Lyall discuss the “mow, rake, lift” method of harvest with the Hughes and did they authorise its use?
3. Was the “mow, rake, lift” method of harvest appropriate/reasonable in the circumstances?
4. Was over-maturity the root cause of the poor silage, rather than Mr Lyall’s actions?
5. Was the Hughes’ mowing partly responsible for the soil contamination?
6. If the answers to questions (a)-(d) are “no”, are the Hughes entitled to the damages claimed, which relate to the cost of replacement feed, replacement grazing, and lost opportunity costs?

Held
1. The Court concluded that the appeal was dismissed, meaning the decision of the High Court was upheld.
2. The Court held that the appellant must pay the first respondent's costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis together with usual disbursements.
3. The Court concluded that the crop was over-mature at the point of harvest.
4. The Court held that Mr Lyall discussed and obtained authorisation from the Hughes for the "mow, rake, lift" method of harvest.
5. The Court concluded that the "mow, rake, lift" method of harvest was appropriate and reasonable in the circumstances.
6. The Court held that over-maturity was the root cause of the poor silage, rather than Mr Lyall's actions.
7. The Court concluded that the Hughes' mowing was partly responsible for the soil contamination, albeit to a lesser extent than Mr Lyall's raking.
8. The Court held that the Hughes were not entitled to the damages claimed, as the poor quality of the silage was primarily due to the over-maturity of the crop.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal addressed the appeal by first reiterating the approach to appeals from findings of fact, where the appellate court must form its own independent judgment on the merits of the appeal. The Court then proceeded to consider the six issues identified by the parties. Regarding the first issue, the Court found ample evidence to support the Judge's conclusion that the crop was over-mature at the point of harvest, as various witnesses observed the crop to be overripe, and the silage tests confirmed its high dry matter content. As for the second issue, the Court held that it was reasonable for Mr Lyall to propose the "mow, rake, lift" method of harvest as an alternative to the whole crop method, given the urgency and unavailability of other options. The Court also concluded that the method was appropriate and reasonable in the circumstances, as there was evidence that it was a commonly used harvesting method in the industry. On the fourth issue, the Court agreed with the Judge's finding that the over-maturity of the crop was the principal cause of the poor silage quality, rather than Mr Lyall's actions. The Court also held that the Hughes' mowing contributed to the soil contamination, but to a lesser extent than Mr Lyall's raking. Finally, the Court concluded that the Hughes were not entitled to the damages claimed, as the poor quality of the silage was primarily due to the over-maturity of the crop, which was not caused by Mr Lyall's actions. The Court found no error in the Judge's approach to the evidence and her conclusions on each issue. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in cases of silage production disputes, the over-maturity of the crop can be a primary cause of poor silage quality, and alternative harvesting methods can be deemed appropriate and reasonable in certain circumstances.