A P and a W Hughes Limited v Lyall

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CIV-2015-412-000030 [2017] NZHC 1573

BETWEEN

A P AND A W HUGHES LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

ALLAN JAMES LYALL Defendant

AND

MARK BENNETT Third Party

Hearing: 7 July 2017 (On the papers)

Appearances:

D R Tobin and R M Reeve for Plaintiff
J C D Guest for Defendant

Judgment:

7 July 2017

JUDGMENT OF DUNNINGHAM J (RE:  COSTS DECISION)

[1]      After granting judgment in the defendant’s favour in these proceedings I reserved the issue of costs, although I signalled that, in the usual course, they would be calculated on a 2B basis.1

[2]      The parties have been unable to agree costs and have filed memoranda on

costs seeking the Court’s determination.

[3]      While the parties had agreed in case management conferences, that costs on a

2B basis would be appropriate, the defendant now seeks 2C costs for some steps.  He also seeks disbursements for his expert witness fees.

1      A P and A W Hughes Ltd v Lyall [2017] NZHC 1109.

A P AND A W HUGHES LIMITED v ALLAN JAMES LYALL [2017] NZHC 1573 [7 July 2017]

[4]      The plaintiff contests the defendant’s claim for 2C costs, submitting that costs should be awarded on a 2B basis or, for some items, on a reduced basis.  It also seeks a reduced amount for the fees of one of the defendant’s expert witnesses.

Submissions

Defendant’s submissions

[5]      The defendant acknowledges that while the case was heard over seven days, these were not all full days.  Therefore, he claims for a hearing time of six days.  The plaintiff agrees with this.

[6]      The defendant claims costs for a number of steps taken in the proceedings. These are mostly on a 2B basis, except for:

(a)       The amount allowed for the preparation of briefs.2

(b)      The amount allowed for preparation of hearing.3

[7]      The defendant seeks a band C categorisation for both steps (which allocates five days for each step) because of the nature of the proceeding.   The defendant submits that the matter required detailed evidence on complicated factual matters and  that  the  outcome  was  significantly  influenced  by  expert  evidence.     The defendant  briefed  ten  witnesses,  although  only  nine  were  called.    A  five  day allocation would be reasonable as that would average a half day per witness.  The defendant submits that this case involved significant preparation, beyond what might ordinarily  be  expected,  because  counsel  had  to  prepare  eight  witnesses  for cross-examination, three who were  giving expert evidence,  and prepare detailed closing submissions on the facts.

[8]      The defendant also claims for an additional amount for the preparation of submissions of costs and for sealing judgment.  Neither step is listed in Schedule 3

but the defendant submits that these matters are analogous to other steps and costs

2      Item 30 of High Court Rules, Schedule 3.

3      Item 33 of High Court Rules, Schedule 3.

are commonly allocated for them by the Court.  The defendant seeks only a half day allocation for the two matters, which it…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read A P and a W Hughes Limited v Lyall and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 1573
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, A P and A W Hughes Limited sought costs from Allan James Lyall following the granting of a judgment in Lyall's favour. The plaintiff and defendant were unable to agree on the quantum of costs and subsequently filed memoranda seeking the Court's determination. The defendant sought 2C costs for certain steps and also sought disbursements for expert witness fees. The plaintiff contested the defendant’s claim for 2C costs, submitting that costs should be awarded on a 2B basis or, for some items, on a reduced basis. It also sought a reduced amount for the fees of one of the defendant’s expert witnesses.

The Court found that the plaintiff’s submission that the amount claimed by the defendant for the preparation of the bundle and associated tasks should be reduced was not persuasive. In relation to the reduction sought for item 2, because of a failure to complete disclosure obligations, the Court accepted there was a failure to provide timely or complete disclosure of relevant telephone records. However, the defendant did not rely on the telephone records in preparing the statement of defence, so there was no reason to reduce the amount of time awarded to the defendant for this step.

The Court found that the defendant's claim for a band C categorisation for items 30 and 33 was not warranted. Although there were a reasonably large number of witnesses, several of the briefs were very short and confined to one or two factual issues. Similarly, the Court did not consider that a comparatively large amount of time was reasonably required to prepare for the hearing. While the factual scenario was novel, it was not out of the ordinary in respect to its complexity. The Court found that when looked at overall, the costs award calculated on a 2B basis was not unduly disproportionate to the defendant’s actual legal costs.

The Court also found that the plaintiff fairly took issue with the initial failure to appropriately particularise Dr Gibbs’ fee. However, the defendant's reply submissions did adequately remedy this, and the Court accepted this disbursement was properly claimable. The Court found that there was scope to award costs for the preparation of costs memoranda; however, given it had not acquiesced to the defendant’s request for a departure from 2B costs, it did not think it would be appropriate to do so in this case. Accordingly, no costs were awarded for the preparation of the costs memorandum.

The Court awarded costs of $47,053 along with $21,650 for disbursements as set out in the schedule attached to this decision.