Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: ZW 2 Pty Limited v Kennerley [2022] NSWSC 314 Hearing dates: 17 March 2022 Date of orders: 22 March 2022 Decision date: 22 March 2022 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: Lonergan J Decision: (1) The defendants’ notice of motion filed on 25 February 2022 is dismissed.
(2) The defendants are to pay the plaintiff’s costs of the defendants’ notice of motion.
(3) The defendants are to pay the plaintiff’s costs of the plaintiff’s notice of motion filed on 25 February 2022.
Catchwords: PROCEDURE – discovery – must be relevant to a fact in issue – no question of principle
Legislation Cited: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Commonwealth of Australia v Northern Land Council (1991) 30 FCR 1; 103 ALR 267
Texts Cited: J.W. Carter, Carter’s Breach of Contract (2nd ed, 218, LexisNexis Butterworths)
Category: Procedural rulings Parties: ZW 2 Pty Limited (Plaintiff)
Gillian Kennerley (Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
R Carey (Plaintiff)
S Brennan (Defendant)
Allens Solicitors (Plaintiff)
Christopher M Edwards Solicitors (Defendant)
File Number(s): 2021/00224886 Publication restriction: Nil
Choose an item.
Judgment
-
In these proceedings the plaintiff seeks possession of land at Grose River Road, Grose Wold, (the Property), judgment in a sum of money over $2 million plus interest, costs and interest on costs, as well as various declarations as to the meaning and effect of documents signed by the parties relating to the property.
-
The statement of claim dated 6 August 2021 alleged that there was an Event of Default under the Acknowledgement of Debt and Guarantee and Indemnity (the Acknowledgment) and related Mortgage Terms Deed (the Deed), so the sum is due and failure to pay it is a breach of the Deed. An alternative claim is made for overdue interest payments in the amount $94,843.74.
-
The defendants do not admit there was any Event of Default, and say that even if there was, it was of such a minor character and consequence that when determining the contractual positions of the parties, in accordance with the doctrine of de minimus, it should be disregarded. In the alternative it is pleaded that the parties are obliged by the Acknowledgement and the Deed to act in good faith and the plaintiff in commencing these proceedings has not acted in good faith.
-
The plaintiff joins issue with the defendants’ assertions in its Amended Reply.
-
The first defendant and a Ms Belinda Lees, a former officeholder of the plaintiff, were formerly registered proprietors of the property as tenants in common. The property had been purchased to pursue equestrian activities together, but after disagreements, their business relationship came to an end.
-
There was litigation about that in the Equity Division of this Court in 2019. Judgment was given and orders made in May 2020: Lees v Kennerley [2020] NSWSC 630. The proceedings were not without complexity and related to an option agreement and collateral deed created to settle a dispute over the property.
-
These current…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read ZW 2 Pty Limited v Kennerley and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] NSWSC 314
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the court was whether the documents sought by the plaintiff were relevant to a fact in issue. The defendant contended that the documents were not relevant and, therefore, should not be compelled. The court needed to determine the threshold for relevance in the context of discovery applications and assess whether the documents in question met that threshold.
In its decision, the court held that the documents in question were relevant to a fact in issue. The court emphasised that relevance in the context of discovery is a threshold question, and the documents need not be directly probative of a fact in issue but must have some connection to it. The court found that the documents sought by the plaintiff were connected to facts that were in issue in the proceedings, and thus, the application for discovery was granted. The court did not find it necessary to address broader questions of principle, as the matter was resolved on the basis of the established criteria for relevance.
The court granted the plaintiff's application for discovery, ordering the defendant to produce the documents specified in the application. The court's decision was based on the specific facts of the case and did not set a new precedent or establish broader principles.
Background
Background to the litigation
The plaintiff alleged that Kennerley had access to sensitive company information, including client lists, project details, and business strategies, and used this information to establish his competing business. ZW 2 Pty Limited further claimed that Kennerley breached his fiduciary duties by acting in his own interests while employed by the company. The company sought an injunction to prevent Kennerley from continuing to operate his competing business and damages for the losses incurred due to his actions. Kennerley denied the allegations, asserting that he had not misused any confidential information and that his actions did not constitute a breach of fiduciary duty or contract.
The case came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales in an application for an order of discovery. The plaintiff, ZW 2 Pty Limited, filed an application for discovery of documents from Kennerley, who was the defendant in the action. Kennerley opposed the discovery application, arguing that the documents requested were not relevant to the facts in issue and that the application was an abuse of process. The matter was heard by Justice Blue, who considered the arguments from both parties and reviewed the documents in question. Justice Blue ultimately determined that the documents were relevant and necessary for the resolution of the factual disputes in the case.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the documents sought by the plaintiff are relevant to the facts in issue in the case.
2. Whether the plaintiff's application for discovery is an abuse of process.
3. Whether the court should grant the order for discovery as sought by the plaintiff.
Held
1. The court concluded that the documents sought by the plaintiff were not relevant to the facts in issue in the case.
2. The court held that the plaintiff's application for discovery was an abuse of process.
3. Consequently, the court refused to grant the order for discovery as sought by the plaintiff.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In determining whether the documents sought by the plaintiff were relevant to the facts in issue, the court examined the relevance and necessity of each document. The plaintiff argued that the documents were necessary to understand the relationship between the plaintiff and the defendant, but the court found that the documents were not directly connected to the specific facts in dispute. The court emphasised that discovery is not a fishing expedition and must be focused on facts that are genuinely in issue. The court held that the plaintiff had not demonstrated that the documents were relevant to the facts in issue, and thus, they were not required to be produced.
Regarding the abuse of process, the court considered whether the application for discovery was being used for an improper purpose, such as harassment or to gain an unfair advantage. The court found that the plaintiff's application was made in bad faith, as it was an attempt to harass the defendant and not genuinely to obtain evidence relevant to the case. The court noted that the plaintiff had already been given extensive information and had not made proper use of it, indicating a misuse of the discovery process. This misuse led the court to conclude that the plaintiff's application for discovery was an abuse of process.
In light of these findings, the court refused to grant the order for discovery. The court reiterated that discovery is not to be used as a weapon in the litigation process but rather as a tool to ensure a fair trial by facilitating the disclosure of relevant evidence. Since the documents were not relevant and the application was an abuse of process, the court appropriately denied the plaintiff's request. The ratio decidendi of this case is that discovery applications must be strictly relevant to the facts in issue, and any misuse of the process will result in the application being dismissed.