Airlie Group Pty Ltd v John Fairfax Group Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

Re: THE AIRLIE GROUP PTY. LIMITED AND ORS and THE DREXEL BURNHAM LAMBERT GROUP
INC.
And: JOHN FAIRFAX GROUP PTY. LIMITED and ORS
Nos. G100 and 28 of 1991
FED No. 416
Practice and Procedure

COURT

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Sheppard J.(1)
CATCHWORDS

Practice and Procedure - security for costs - complex litigation - applicants outside jurisdiction and having no assets in Australia - Court's discretion to order security - evidence of amounts incurred by respondents for costs down to inspection of documents - evidence consisting in part of evidence by costs consultants - reference of costs consultants' material to taxing officer for report on appropriateness of the amount to be awarded.

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976, s.56

Federal Court Rules, Order 28, rule 3

HEARING

SYDNEY

#DATE 7:6:1991

Counsel for the Applicants: Mr C.P. Comans

Instructed by: Phillips Fox

Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr M. Speakman

Instructed by: Blake Dawson Waldron

Counsel for the Second Respondent: Mr N.A. Cotman

Instructed by: Baker and McKenzie

Counsel for the Third Respondent: Mr N.C. Hutley

Instructed by: Mallesons Stephen Jacques

ORDER

Each of the applicants in matter No. G28 of 1991 and the applicant in matter No. G100 of 1991 provide, by way of security for each respondent's costs of the proceedings, the sum of $100,000.

The amounts so ordered are provisional and are not to be treated as a finding that they represent the costs incurred by any respondent for any particular period or for any particular work.

Each of the amounts is to be available in its entirety to meet any order for costs which any respondent may recover against any one or more of the applicants.

Such security is to be provided on or before 14 June next in such manner and form as the parties may agree or, in default of agreement, as the Registrar or, on reference by him to a judge, a judge, may determine.

A Deputy Registrar of this Court make a further report setting out a provisional estimate of the costs incurred, or to be incurred, by each respondent since the commencement of the litigation down to and including 31 July next.

Each respondent furnish to the Deputy Registrar such evidence or other material as it may wish to rely upon for the purposes of the report referred to in paragraph 5 on or before 21 June 1991.

The applicants furnish to the Deputy Registrar such affidavits or other material as they may wish to rely upon for that purpose on or before 28 June 1991.

The Deputy Registrar give such further directions as he may think necessary, including directions as to when, and in what manner, each party is to be heard on or before 5 July next.

The Deputy Registrar circulate to the parties and to me a draft report on or before 12 July 1991, and afford parties an opportunity then of making further submissions to him.

The Deputy Registrar…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Airlie Group Pty Ltd v John Fairfax Group Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1991] FCA 416
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Airlie Group Pty Ltd and another brought proceedings against John Fairfax Group Pty Ltd and another, which were complex in nature and involved significant costs. The respondents applied for security for their costs, given the applicants' lack of assets within Australia and their residency outside the jurisdiction. This application was heard by the Federal Court of Australia. The primary legal issue was whether the court had the discretion to order security for costs in such circumstances and, if so, what the appropriate amount should be. The court had to consider the evidence presented by the respondents, which included detailed costs incurred to date, including those verified by costs consultants. The court's decision hinged on balancing the need to protect the respondents from potential financial loss against the applicants' rights to fair legal proceedings.

The Federal Court found that it had the discretion to order security for costs, particularly given the complexity of the litigation and the risk of non-recovery. The court noted that while the applicants had no assets in Australia, the proceedings were of significant importance, which justified the imposition of security. The court decided to order a provisional amount of $100,000 from each applicant, which was to be available to meet any order for costs. This amount was deemed provisional and not indicative of the costs incurred for any specific period or work. The court ordered a Deputy Registrar to prepare a provisional estimate of the costs incurred since the commencement of the litigation. The Deputy Registrar was directed to report on this estimate, allowing both parties to submit evidence and make further submissions. The court also set out a timeline for these processes, with the final report due by 26 July 1991, and scheduled further directions for 28 June 1991.

In summary, the Federal Court granted the respondents' application for security for costs, ordering each applicant to provide $100,000. This amount was provisional and not a finding on the costs incurred by any respondent for a particular period. The court directed a Deputy Registrar to prepare a provisional estimate of the costs incurred, considering submissions from both parties. The applicants were also required to pay the respondents' costs of the motions for security for costs. The matter was listed for further directions on 28 June 1991.

Orders

Orders of the court

Each of the applicants in matter No. G28 of 1991 and the applicant in matter No. G100 of 1991 provide, by way of security for each respondent's costs of the proceedings, the sum of $100,000.

The amounts so ordered are provisional and are not to be treated as a finding that they represent the costs incurred by any respondent for any particular period or for any particular work.

Each of the amounts is to be available in its entirety to meet any order for costs which any respondent may recover against any one or more of the applicants.

Such security is to be provided on or before 14 June next in such manner and form as the parties may agree or, in default of agreement, as the Registrar or, on reference by him to a judge, a judge, may determine.

A Deputy Registrar of this Court make a further report setting out a provisional estimate of the costs incurred, or to be incurred, by each respondent since the commencement of the litigation down to and including 31 July next.

Each respondent furnish to the Deputy Registrar such evidence or other material as it may wish to rely upon for the purposes of the report referred to in paragraph 5 on or before 21 June 1991.

The applicants furnish to the Deputy Registrar such affidavits or other material as they may wish to rely upon for that purpose on or before 28 June 1991.

The Deputy Registrar give such further directions as he may think necessary, including directions as to when, and in what manner, each party is to be heard on or before 5 July next.

The Deputy Registrar circulate to the parties and to me a draft report on or before 12 July 1991, and afford parties an opportunity then of making further submissions to him.

The Deputy Registrar circulate a final report to the parties and to myself on or before 26 July 1991.

The applicants pay the costs of each respondent of the motions for security for costs up to and including today.

Leave to tax bills of costs forthwith.

The matter be listed for further directions on 28 June at 9.30a.m. before me as already fixed.

NOTE: Settlement and entry of Orders is dealt with by Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

Airlie Group Pty Ltd and others (the applicants) brought proceedings against John Fairfax Group Pty Ltd and others (the respondents). The applicants sought to have the respondents provide security for costs in relation to the proceedings. The applicants were entities with limited assets and operations outside Australia, complicating the assessment of their ability to meet any costs orders against them. The respondents, on the other hand, were established Australian entities with significant assets and operations within the country. The respondents had incurred substantial costs in defending the applicants' actions and were seeking an order for security to cover these expenses. The proceedings were complex, involving multiple parties and extensive litigation.

The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia as an application for security for costs under the Federal Court Rules. The application was made in two separate proceedings, numbered G28 of 1991 and G100 of 1991. Prior to this application, the parties had engaged in preliminary litigation, including the filing of statements of claim and defences, and various procedural exchanges. The court had to consider the evidence of costs incurred by the respondents, which included detailed submissions and affidavits, as well as reports from costs consultants. The applicants contested the amount of costs claimed and the necessity of providing security. The court referred certain materials to a taxing officer to assess the appropriateness of the amounts claimed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Court has the discretion to order the applicants to provide security for the respondents' costs given the applicants' limited assets and operations outside Australia.
2. What amount of security, if any, should be ordered, considering the evidence of costs incurred by the respondents.
3. Whether the evidence provided by the respondents, including the reports from costs consultants, is sufficient to support the claimed amounts of costs and the need for security.

Held
1. The Court has the discretion to order the applicants to provide security for the respondents' costs despite the applicants' limited assets and operations outside Australia.
2. The Court ordered that each of the applicants provide $100,000 as security for each respondent's costs, resulting in a total of $300,000 in security.
3. The evidence provided by the respondents, including the reports from costs consultants, was considered sufficient to support the claimed amounts of costs and the need for security.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining whether to exercise its discretion to order the applicants to provide security for the respondents' costs, the Court considered the nature of the litigation and the applicants' limited assets and operations outside Australia. The Court noted that complex litigation often involves significant costs, and the applicants' limited resources could potentially leave the respondents exposed to unrecoverable costs. The Court found that the discretion to order security was applicable in this case, despite the applicants' circumstances. Regarding the amount of security, the Court ordered $100,000 for each respondent, considering the evidence of costs incurred by the respondents and the need for a provisional amount to cover potential future costs. The Court emphasised that the amounts ordered were provisional and not a finding on the actual costs incurred by any respondent. The Court also directed the Deputy Registrar to prepare a report on the costs incurred by the respondents and to afford the parties an opportunity to make further submissions. This process was intended to provide a more accurate estimate of the costs incurred and to be incurred, ensuring that the security ordered was fair and reasonable. The Court found the evidence provided by the respondents, including the reports from costs consultants, to be sufficient to support the claimed amounts of costs and the need for security. The Court also referred the costs consultants' material to a taxing officer for a report on the appropriateness of the amount to be awarded. The Court did not depart from or distinguish any prior authority but applied the well-established principles regarding the Court's discretion to order security for costs in complex litigation. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the Court has the discretion to order security for costs in complex litigation, even when the applicants have limited assets and operations outside Australia, and this discretion may be exercised based on the nature of the litigation and the applicants' financial circumstances.