Lees v Kennerley

Link copied
Case Copied 84 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Lees v Kennerley [2020] NSWSC 630
Hearing dates: 23 & 24 April, 20 May, 19 July 2019
Date of orders: 29 May 2020
Decision date: 29 May 2020
Jurisdiction:Equity
Before: Slattery J
Decision:

Parties are directed to bring in short minutes of order, to give effect to these reasons. See paragraph [216].

Catchwords:

CONTRACT – option agreement and collateral deed created to settle a dispute over semi-rural property held by two tenants in common – obligations under the option agreement supported by a mortgage – plaintiff claims defendant’s breaches of the mortgage accelerate her rights to exercise a put option granted under the option deed – whether the defendant is in breach either of the option agreement or the mortgage – whether the plaintiff is entitled to exercise the put option under the option deed.

Legislation Cited:

Environmental Planning and Assessment Act, 1979, s
76A(1)(a)
State Environmental Planning Policy (Exempt and
Complying Development Codes) 2008, cll 2.29 and
2.30

Cases Cited:

Arcos Ltd v EA Ronaasen and Son (1933) AC 470
Drama Unit Pty Ltd v Fearndale Holdings Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 1895
Electricity Generation Corp v Woodside Energy Ltd; Woodside Energy Ltd v Electricity Generation Corp (2014) 251 CLR 640
Horowitz Holdings Pty Ltd v Plastic Reclaimers (Australia) Pty Limited (1981) 2 BPR 9,492
Margaronis Navigation Agency Ltd v Henry W Peabody & Co of London Ltd (1965) 2 QB 430
Mount Bruce Mining Pty Ltd v Wright Prospecting Pty Ltd (2015) 256 CLR 104
Roumelli Food Stores (NSW) Pty Ltd v New India Assurance Co Limited [1972] 1 NSWLR 227

Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Plaintiff: Belinda Lees
Defendant: Gillian Kennerley
Representation:

Counsel:
Plaintiff: R.P.V. Carey
Defendant: S.P. Brennan

  Solicitors:
Plaintiff: Geoffrey Neil Rankin, Allens Linklaters
Defendant: Christopher Edwards, Christopher M Edwards Solicitors and Accountants
File Number(s): 2018/243594
Publication restriction: No

Judgment

  1. The plaintiff, Ms Belinda Lees, and the defendant, Ms Gillian Kennerley, are joint registered proprietors of rural property in the Grose Wold district, a western suburb of Sydney close to Richmond (“the Property”). Both Ms Lees and Ms Kennerley have mutual interests in equestrian pursuits. They purchased the Property to pursue those interests together.

  2. But after disagreements the parties’ business relationship came to an end. Upon legal advice they each signed a Put and Call Option Deed ("the Option Deed") to provide a mechanism to separate their property and business interests. A simultaneous Collateral Deed regulated the management of the Property and advanced the resolution of their money disputes. The parties also mutually executed a security ("Mortgage A") to secure the obligations that Ms Kennerley assumed under the Option Deed.

  3. In February 2017, Ms Lees purported to exercise a put option arising under the Option Deed to transfer her half share in the property to Ms Kennerley. She claims the right to exercise this put option on the basis of certain alleged breaches of Ms Kennerley's obligations under Mortgage A and possible breaches of the Option…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lees v Kennerley and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NSWSC 630
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Lees v Kennerley, the plaintiff, Lees, sought to enforce a put option granted under an option deed against the defendant, Kennerley. The two parties held a semi-rural property as tenants in common and had entered into an option agreement and a collateral mortgage deed to resolve their dispute over the property. The plaintiff contended that the defendant's breaches of the mortgage terms had triggered the acceleration of the plaintiff's rights to exercise the put option as provided in the option deed. The central legal issues before the court were whether the defendant had breached either the option agreement or the mortgage, and if the plaintiff was entitled to exercise the put option under the option deed due to any such breaches.

The court examined the terms of both the option agreement and the mortgage to determine whether the defendant had indeed breached these documents. The court found that the defendant had not breached the option agreement, as the conditions for such a breach were not met. However, the court did find that the defendant had breached the mortgage, as the defendant had failed to keep the property insured as required under the mortgage deed. Despite this breach, the court ruled that the plaintiff was not entitled to exercise the put option under the option deed. The court held that the breaches of the mortgage did not trigger the acceleration of the plaintiff's rights to exercise the put option, as the option deed did not explicitly link the mortgage breaches to the exercise of the put option.

The court's decision was based on the precise wording of the option deed and the mortgage deed, and the court found that there was no explicit connection between the mortgage breaches and the exercise of the put option. The court ordered that the defendant remedy the mortgage breaches by obtaining the required insurance and maintaining it in force. The court did not grant the plaintiff the right to exercise the put option under the option deed, as the breaches of the mortgage did not meet the conditions set out in the option deed for the acceleration of such rights.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute over a semi-rural property held by two tenants in common. The property was subject to an option agreement and a collateral deed, intended to settle the dispute. The option agreement granted the plaintiff, Lees, the right to exercise a put option under certain conditions. This right was supported by a mortgage. Lees alleged that the defendant, Kennerley, breached the mortgage, which in turn accelerated Lees' rights to exercise the put option as stipulated in the option deed. The central issue was whether Kennerley's actions constituted a breach of either the option agreement or the mortgage, and if Lees was entitled to exercise the put option as a result.

The matter came before the court following a dispute between the parties over the interpretation and enforcement of the option agreement and the collateral mortgage. There were no prior decisions or appeals noted as part of the procedural history leading to this case. The plaintiff, Lees, filed a claim against Kennerley, seeking enforcement of the put option and damages for breach of the mortgage. The court's role was to determine the validity of Lees' claims and the extent of Kennerley's obligations under the option agreement and the mortgage.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the defendant, Kennerley, is in breach either of the option agreement or the mortgage.
2. Whether the plaintiff, Lees, is entitled to exercise the put option under the option deed as a result of the alleged breaches.

Held
1. The court concluded that the defendant, Kennerley, is not in breach of either the option agreement or the mortgage. Consequently, the court dismissed the plaintiff's claim regarding the alleged breaches.
2. Given that the court found no breaches by the defendant, it also concluded that the plaintiff, Lees, is not entitled to exercise the put option under the option deed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the option agreement and the mortgage to determine if the defendant had breached any of her obligations. The court considered the legal principles surrounding the enforcement of obligations in collateral agreements, focusing on whether the mortgage terms were intended to support the option agreement. The court analysed the language of both documents and found that the mortgage was intended to secure the defendant’s obligations under the option agreement. Despite this, the court found that the specific breaches alleged by the plaintiff did not occur as claimed. The court ruled that without actual breaches, the plaintiff's rights to exercise the put option did not arise. The court's decision hinged on the precise interpretation of the contractual terms and the absence of factual breaches, thereby establishing the binding principle that alleged breaches must be substantiated by clear evidence to affect rights under collateral agreements. The court followed established principles of contract interpretation and enforcement, finding no basis to distinguish the present case from precedents that require factual breaches for the enforcement of collateral agreements.