Zdziarski v Telstra Corporation Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Zdziarski v Telstra Corporation Limited [2022] FCA 1296   

Appeal from: Zdziarski v Telstra Corporation Limited [2022] AATA 145
File number: NSD 143 of 2022
Judgment of: RAPER J
Date of judgment: 4 November 2022
Catchwords: WORKER’S COMPENSATION – appeal from a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal – where the Tribunal determined that the applicant’s entitlements under s 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) should be re-calculated (and reduced) having regard to the average weekly overtime hours worked by comparable employees – whether the Tribunal failed to exercise its jurisdiction by not determining objections made by the applicant to three of the first respondent’s statements – appeal dismissed
EVIDENCE – whether an objection on the basis of “weight” is truly an objection – whether the Tribunal is required to specifically identify in its reasons the weight given to particular evidence
Legislation:

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 2A, 2A(b), 33(1), 33(1)(b), 33(1)(c), 33(1A), 33(2A), 40(1)(a), 40(3), 40(5), 40A(1), 43(2B), 44(1)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 8(10), 8(10)(b)(i), 19

Cases cited:

Australian Postal Corporation v Hughes [2009] FCA 1057; 111 ALD 579

Bridges v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 1647; 114 FCR 456

Brown v The Repatriation Commission [1985] FCA 236; 7 FCR 302

Division: Fair Work Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Employment and Industrial Relations
Number of paragraphs: 46
Date of hearing: 11 October 2022
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr I Roberts SC with Mr E O’Neill
Solicitor for the Applicant: Cardillo Gray Partners
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr P Knowles SC with Mr B Kelly
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Sparke Helmore Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 143 of 2022
BETWEEN:

STEPHEN ZDZIARSKI

Applicant

AND:

TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

RAPER J

DATE OF ORDER:

4 NOVEMBER 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

2.The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs as agreed or taxed pursuant to r 40.12 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth).

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

RAPER J

Introduction

  1. By notice of appeal filed on 4 March 2022, the applicant appeals a decision of the second respondent, the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Zdziarski v Telstra Corporation Limited [2022] AATA 145 (T)) pursuant to s 44(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth). In that decision, the Tribunal set aside and remitted to Telstra Corporation Limited, the first respondent, its reviewable decision dated 23 September 2019, with the direction that the applicant’s entitlements under s 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (SRC Act) be re-calculated.  

  2. In reaching its conclusion that the applicant’s entitlements needed to be recalculated (and reduced), the Tribunal accepted evidence from Mr Tony Considine, Telstra Field Manager, as to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Zdziarski v Telstra Corporation Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 1296
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the applicant appeals a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) regarding the recalculation of his worker's compensation entitlements under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth). The applicant had been a long-term employee of Telstra Corporation Limited and sustained a work-related injury in 2001. Following this injury, he received various types of workers' compensation payments. His employment with Telstra ended in December 2003. In 2011, the AAT determined that the applicant's normal weekly earnings (NWE) should include 9.25 hours of overtime per week. In 2016, Telstra determined that it was liable to pay compensation to the applicant for periods of incapacity from August 2015 to February 2017, amounting to a total of $146,480.46.

In 2019, Telstra recalculated the applicant's NWE based on the average annual overtime hours worked by comparable employees. The Tribunal accepted evidence from Mr Tony Considine, Telstra Field Manager, regarding the reduced average weekly overtime hours worked by comparable employees after the applicant's injury. The Tribunal concluded that the applicant's entitlements needed to be recalculated (and reduced) and set aside Telstra's reviewable decision, directing Telstra to recalculate the applicant's entitlements. The applicant appealed this decision, arguing that the Tribunal had failed to exercise its jurisdiction by not deciding objections made to three statements of Mr Considine, adduced by Telstra.

The court found that the Tribunal had not failed to exercise its jurisdiction, as the applicant had the opportunity to object to the evidence during the Tribunal hearing and had chosen to proceed without cross-examining Mr Considine or seeking an adjournment. The court also noted that the request for "particulars" associated with statements of evidence was not applicable in this context, as there were no pleadings and evidence is typically challenged by objection, cross-examination, or by bringing forward competing evidence. The court dismissed the appeal and ordered the applicant to pay Telstra's costs as agreed or taxed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs as agreed or taxed pursuant to r 40.12 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth).

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

As observed by Bowen CJ, Fisher and Lockhart JJ in Brown v The Repatriation Commission [1985] FCA 236; 7 FCR 302 at 304, this requirement is not merely a qualifying condition, “rather, it and it alone is the subject matter of the appeal, and the ambit of the appeal is confined to it”. Background The applicant had been a long term employee of the first respondent. Following an injury at work on 17 September 2001, he has received payments of different kinds of workers’ compensation under the SRC Act. The applicant’s employment with the first respondent ended in December 2003. On 21 March 2011, the Tribunal made a decision by consent upon an application that the applicant’s normal weekly earnings (NWE) be calculated to include overtime of 9.25 hours per week. On 20 December 2016, the first respondent determined that it was liable to pay compensation to the applicant in respect of periods of incapacity from 27 August 2015 up to 22 February 2017 amounting to a total of $146,480.46. On 16 January 2017, the applicant sought reconsideration of the first respondent’s determination of 20 December 2016. On 10 August 2017, the first respondent affirmed its determination made on 20 December 2016. Later in 2017, the applicant made a further application before the Tribunal challenging the first respondent’s decision of 10 August 2017 to affirm the determination dated 20 December 2016 (the 2017 application). As part of those proceedings, the first respondent served two statements from Mr Considine dated 6 July and (incorrectly) 12 August 2018 (prepared in September 2018), respectively the first statement and the second statement. On 18 September 2018, the applicant withdrew his 2017 application. One part of the applicant’s compensation entitlements was calculable by reference to his NWE (as had been recalculated in 2011, as referred to at [7] above). This included an amount referable to the overtime the applicant would have worked if he had remained in the employ of the first respondent. On 23 September 2019, the first respondent made a determination (the reviewable decision), which was the subject of the Tribunal decision now on appeal. The first respondent recalculated the applicant’s NWE based on the average annual overtime hours worked by current employees of the first respondent who were considered to be comparable to the applicant. In effect, this decision – if correct – demonstrated that the applicant had been overpaid the sum of $99,397.62, for the period between 1 July 2015 and 18 September 2019 (the relevant period). The first respondent concluded that it was no longer correct to include 9.25 hours of weekly overtime in the applicant’s NWE. On p. 3 of the reviewable decision, the first respondent indicated that the wage records demonstrated that the average overtime hours worked by comparable employees (Newcastle Wireline team, Band 4 level) for the relevant period were: On 22 October 2019, the applicant made an application for review of the reviewable decision before the Tribunal.Pre-hearing processes

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

By notice of appeal filed on 4 March 2022, the applicant appeals a decision of the second respondent, the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Zdziarski v Telstra Corporation Limited [2022] AATA 145 (T)) pursuant to s 44(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth). In that decision, the Tribunal set aside and remitted to Telstra Corporation Limited, the first respondent, its reviewable decision dated 23 September 2019, with the direction that the applicant’s entitlements under s 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (SRC Act) be re-calculated. In reaching its conclusion that the applicant’s entitlements needed to be recalculated (and reduced), the Tribunal accepted evidence from Mr Tony Considine, Telstra Field Manager, as to the different (and reduced) average weekly overtime hours worked by comparable employees in the Newcastle Wireline Team after the applicant had sustained his injury and no longer worked in the team. This appeal concerns whether the Tribunal had failed to exercise its jurisdiction by not deciding a material issue raised by the applicant, namely whether it should take into account, when reaching its decision, three statements of Mr Considine it considered, adduced by the first respondent, which the applicant objected to. For the reasons set out below, I dismiss the appeal. Jurisdiction – questions of law Jurisdiction is conferred on this Court to hear an appeal from a decision of the Tribunal under s 44(1) of the AAT Act, whereby a party may “appeal” to the Court “on a question of law”. Whilst s 44(1) employs the language of “appeal”, this jurisdiction is exercised in the Court’s original jurisdiction and not its appellate jurisdiction, and is constrained to appeals on such questions. As observed by Bowen CJ, Fisher and Lockhart JJ in Brown v The Repatriation Commission [1985] FCA 236; 7 FCR 302 at 304, this requirement is not merely a qualifying condition, “rather, it and it alone is the subject matter of the appeal, and the ambit of the appeal is confined to it”. Background The applicant had been a long term employee of the first respondent. Following an injury at work on 17 September 2001, he has received payments of different kinds of workers’ compensation under the SRC Act. The applicant’s employment with the first respondent ended in December 2003. On 21 March 2011, the Tribunal made a decision by consent upon an application that the applicant’s normal weekly earnings (NWE) be calculated to include overtime of 9.25 hours per week. On 20 December 2016, the first respondent determined that it was liable to pay compensation to the applicant in respect of periods of incapacity from 27 August 2015 up to 22 February 2017 amounting to a total of $146,480.46. On 16 January 2017, the applicant sought reconsideration of the first respondent’s determination of 20 December 2016. On 10 August 2017, the first respondent affirmed its determination made on 20 December 2016. Later in 2017, the applicant made a further application before the Tribunal challenging the first respondent’s decision of 10 August 2017 to affirm the determination dated 20 December 2016 (the 2017 application). As part of those proceedings, the first respondent served two statements from Mr Considine dated 6 July and (incorrectly) 12 August 2018 (prepared in September 2018), respectively the first statement and the second statement. On 18 September 2018, the applicant withdrew his 2017 application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Notably, with respect to the unusual request for “particulars” associated with statements of evidence: There is no right for a party to these kinds of proceedings to request particulars at all: The provision of particulars relates to pleadings – there were no pleadings. In any event, the request for particulars was made in respect of evidence – however, there is never an entitlement to request “particulars” of evidence; in the ordinary course evidence is challenged by objection, or in cross-examination, or by bringing forward competing evidence. However, I do accept that care must be taken not to adopt adversarial procedure given the non-adversarial, inquisitorial nature of procedure in the Tribunal: s 2A of the AAT Act. As observed by Flick J in Australian Postal Corporation v Hughes [2009] FCA 1057; 111 ALD 579 (at [47]):…Even prior to the amendments to the 1975 Act which introduced ss 2A and 33(1AA), in Re Beigman and Secretary, Department of Social Security (1992) 29 ALD 332 the Tribunal, comprised of the then President, a Deputy President and a Member, observed (at [24]): [24] Proceedings before this tribunal are not adversarial but are designed to enable the tribunal to reach the correct or preferable decision in the circumstances of the case. To this end the role of the parties is to assist the tribunal in reaching its decision. The tribunal expects departments and agencies involved in the review process to have an understanding of that role. It was open to the applicant, at any time during Tribunal proceedings, to: (a)request that the matter be listed for a directions hearing at which time he would make an application seeking that the Tribunal exercise its powers under the AAT Act and direct the first respondent to provide information which is relevant to the issues in dispute and which will assist the Tribunal to make the correct or preferable decision: ss 33(1A) and 33(2A)(a) of the AAT Act; and/or(b)apply for a summons: s 40A(1) of the AAT Act. The applicant did not require Mr Considine for cross-examination, a course which was available to him and to the extent that there was a change of position on the day of the Tribunal hearing (where the applicant (through his then counsel) wanted to ask Mr Considine some questions when he was no longer available), it was open to the applicant to seek an adjournment. As indicated by the transcript, a choice was made to proceed without cross-examination. The conduct of the Tribunal hearing The hearing was conducted on 7 May 2021. Documents were tendered, no oral evidence was adduced and oral submissions were made. When the first respondent tendered the third statement from Mr Considine, the Tribunal asked if there was an objection. It is appropriate to set out the exchange between the Tribunal and the applicant’s (then) counsel, as to the way in which the matter would proceed:[APPLICANT’S COUNSEL]: Yes, in the sense that it’s part of a more global objection to the evidence of Mr Considine that I take generally. That’s based upon – and I can articulate this further at a convenient point. It’s based upon particulars that we have sought previously and understand you’ve been provided with a bundle of material, Senior Member, with the request, the reply and then a subsequent request. So my submission will be that it’s patently unfair for the respondent to rely upon Mr Considine’s evidence at all in circumstances of the nature of replies or responses to those requests that we have made.SENIOR MEMBER: All right, can we deal with it this way? That if the evidence is taken in, but I note your objection, it can be dealt with by way of submissions as to what I can do with that evidence and what way it should be attributed to it.[APPLICANT’S COUNSEL]: I’d be content with that course, Senior Member, because the points that I would make about the deficiencies in the particulars, which flows into the effect that it gives on the evidence would really be almost the same in terms of the final submissions that I would make as to what the outcome should be. So I don’t have any difficulty with that, it seems to be probably a convenient course to avoid that repetition when you’re otherwise dealing with the matter on the papers as it were.(Emphasis added.)