Zdziarski and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation) [2022] AATA 145 (3 February 2022)
Division:GENERAL DIVISION
File Number: 2019/6834
Re:Stephen Zdziarski
APPLICANT
AndTelstra Corporation Limited
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Senior Member A Poljak
Date:3 February 2022
Place:Sydney
The reviewable decision dated 23 September 2019 is set aside and remitted to the respondent with the direction that the applicant’s entitlements under section 19 of the SRC Act, for the relevant period, should be re-calculated having regard to the average weekly overtime hours worked by comparable employees from the Newcastle Wireline team as detailed in these reasons at [21].
..................................[sgd]......................................
Senior Member A Poljak
CATCHWORDS
COMPENSATION – incapacity payments – normal weekly earnings (NWE) – inclusion of overtime – whether the applicant’s NWE should be reduced in the relevant period – where comparable employees at the time were working less overtime than the applicant – reviewable decision set aside and remitted
LEGISLATION
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988(Cth) ss 8, 19
CASES
Bortolazzo v Comcare [1997] FCA 515; 75 FCR 385
Comcare v Simmons [2014] FCAFC 4; 220 FCR 102
John Holland Group Pty Ltd v Robertson [2010] FCAFC 88
REASONS FOR DECISION
Senior Member A Poljak
3 February 2022
Stephen Zdziarski, the applicant, seeks review of a reviewable decision of the respondent dated 23 September 2019. By that reviewable decision, determinations dated from 25 June 2015 to 4 July 2019 were revoked. In substitution, the respondent re-determined the amount per week of incapacity payments the applicant was entitled to receive in the period between 2 July 2015 and 18 September 2019 (the relevant period) pursuant to section 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (the SRC Act) in accordance with sub-section 8(10) of the SRC Act.
Specifically, the respondent found that the inclusion of 9.25 hours of overtime in the calculation of the applicant’s normal weekly earnings (NWE) was no longer correct as the average overtime hours per week worked by comparable employees employed in the Newcastle Wireline Team were:
(a)2.85 hours in the financial year ending 30 June 2016;
(b)4.62 hours in the financial year ending 30 June 2017;
(c)1.21 hours in the financial year ending 30 June 2018;
(d).92 hours in the financial year ending 30 June 2019;
(e).20 hours from 1 July 2019 to 18 September 2019.
Issues
The applicant was totally incapacitated for work as a result of an accepted claim for compensation under the SRC Act for “aggravation of degenerative changes in both knees with meniscal tears in the right knee, lumbar spine, left shoulder and major depressive disorder” which occurred on 17 September 2001 (the injury) in the relevant period.
The issue before the Tribunal in this application is:
(a) Whether at any time in the relevant period, the applicant’s NWE payable to the applicant in relation to his incapacity for work in the relevant period pursuant to section 19 of the SRC Act should be reduced in accordance with…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Zdziarski and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] AATA 145
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Tribunal was required to determine whether the applicant's NWE, as calculated under section 19 of the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (SRC Act), should be reduced in accordance with section 8(10)(b)(i) or (ii) of the SRC Act. This involved considering whether the applicant's pre-injury overtime hours were representative of what comparable employees were working at the relevant time, given a general reduction in overtime expenditure by the respondent.
The Tribunal applied section 8(10) of the SRC Act, which provides a cap on NWE by requiring a reduction if the calculated amount exceeds certain thresholds. The court noted that section 8(10)(b)(i) involves a notional continuation of the pre-injury employment to ascertain likely earnings. Drawing on the reasoning in *John Holland Group Pty Ltd v Robertson*, the Tribunal emphasised that this section requires an inquiry into likely earnings based on the terms of employment applicable at the date of injury, rather than a notional formulation of employment conditions that never existed. The Tribunal found that the applicant's NWE should be re-calculated by considering the average weekly overtime hours worked by comparable employees.
Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the reviewable decision of 23 September 2019 and remitted the matter to the respondent. The direction was that the applicant's entitlements under section 19 of the SRC Act for the relevant period should be recalculated, taking into account the average weekly overtime hours worked by comparable employees from the Newcastle Wireline team as identified in the decision.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Mr Considine also said that presently, Telstra’s OHS representatives attend one meeting per month and that these employees were communication technicians who had volunteered or been elected by their peers. He said all was done during ordinary work hours. Additionally, Telstra also has HS&E specialists who oversaw the OHS area and managed compliance. They were not communications technicians. Consideration Sub-section 8(10) of the SRC Act provides:(10) If the amount of the normal weekly earnings of an employee before an injury, as calculated under the preceding subsections, would exceed:(a) where the employee continues to be employed by the Commonwealth or a licensed corporation—the amount per week of the earnings that the employee would receive if he or she were not incapacitated for work; or(b) where the employee has ceased to be employed by the Commonwealth or a licensed corporation—whichever is the greater of the following amounts:(i) the amount per week of the earnings that the employee would receive if he or she had continued to be employed by the Commonwealth or the licensed corporation in the employment in which he or she was engaged at the date of the injury;(ii) the amount per week of the earnings that the employee would receive if he or she had continued to be employed by the Commonwealth or the licensed corporation in the employment in which he or she was engaged at the date on which the employment by the Commonwealth or the licensed corporation ceased;the amount so calculated shall be reduced by the amount of the excess. Sub-section 8(10) is designed to reduce the amount of the NWE in certain circumstances. As Perry J observed in Comcare v Simmons [2014] FCAFC 4; 220 FCR 102 at [71], the effect of sub-section 8(10) is to impose a cap upon the amount of pre-injury NWE of an employee which has been calculated under the preceding sub-sections of section 8. It does so by requiring a reduction to be made of NWE by the amount of any excess which is arrived at by applying either sub-paragraph (a) or (b). In this matter, determination of the amount of overtime to be included in the applicant’s NWE, and, therefore, the appropriate amount of the applicant’s total NWE in the relevant period should be done by applying the provisions in section 8(10)(b) of the SRC Act. Section 8(10)(b)(i) contemplates the notional continuation of the previous employment to identify likely earnings in the event the employment had been extended. The Tribunal must simply take the terms of employment applicable to the employee when injured and enquire as to likely earnings pursuant to those terms at the date of calculation. In John Holland Group Pty Ltd v Robertson [2010] FCAFC 88, Dowsett J said at [74]-[76]: [74] Clearly, s 8(10) seeks to limit the compensation payable to an injured employee by reference to his or her notional earnings derived from employment with the same employer had he or she not been injured. Section 8(10)(a) demands a notional enquiry which commences with the employee’s actual current employment. The enquiry is as to his or her earnings in that employment had he or she not been injured. Such enquiry would involve consideration of how, in those circumstances, the employee would have been employed, including consideration of whether he or she would have continued to perform the same duties as were being performed at the time of the accident.[75] Section 8(10)(b) involves different considerations. It assumes continuation of either the pre-injury employment or other actual employment undertaken subsequent to the injury with the same employer. The decision-maker is not directed to assume that the employee was not incapacitated. The enquiry pursuant to s 8(10)(b)(ii) involves only consideration of the employee’s actual employment at the date at which he or she ceased to be employed by the employer and of the earnings which would have been derived had the employee been in such employment in the week for which he or she is to be compensated. It seems unlikely that the basis for comparison was meant to be anything other than the actual earnings, adjusted to reflect changes in circumstances between the cessation of employment and the date of calculation. In particular, it seems unlikely that it was intended that the actual terms of employment were to be ignored, and the calculation based on the notional employment at rates payable to persons in a particular trade, calling or classification.[76] I also see no reason for requiring such a notional exercise in connection with s 8(10)(b)(i). The section contemplates the notional continuation of the previous employment. The purpose of the notional extension is to identify likely earnings in the event that such employment had been so extended. The section does not contemplate the notional formulation of conditions of employment which had never existed. The decision-maker must simply take the terms of employment applicable to the employee at the date of injury and enquire as to likely earnings pursuant to those terms as at the date of calculation.