Wotton v State of Queensland (No 10)

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Wotton v State of Queensland (No 10) [2018] FCA 915

File number: QUD 535 of 2013
Judge: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 15 June 2018
Catchwords: REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – approval of settlement – where liability for breaches of Racial Discrimination Act already established – where proposed settlement in upper range of likely recovery – where apology by respondent of substantial benefit to applicants - settlement approved
Legislation:

Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth)

Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Caason Investments Pty Limited v Cao (No 2) [2018] FCA 527

Kelly v Willmott Forests Ltd (in liquidation) (No 4) [2016] FCA 323

Lopez v Star World Enterprises Pty Ltd [1999] FCA 104

P Dawson Nominees Pty Ltd v Brookfield Multiplex Ltd (No 4) [2010] FCA 1029

Wotton v State of Queensland (No 5) [2016] FCA 1457; 352 ALR 146

Wotton v State of Queensland (No 8) [2017] FCA 639

Date of hearing: 15 June 2018
Registry: Queensland
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 54
Counsel for the Applicants: Dr K Hanscombe QC and Mr D G Guidolin
Solicitor for the Applicants: Levitt Robinson
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr C Murdoch QC and Mr S McLeod
Solicitor for the Respondents: Crown Law

ORDERS

QUD 535 of 2013
BETWEEN:

LEX PATRICK WOTTON

First Applicant

AGNES WOTTON

Second Applicant

CECILIA ANNE WOTTON

Third Applicant

AND:

STATE OF QUEENSLAND

First Respondent

COMMISSIONER OF THE POLICE SERVICE

Second Respondent

JUDGE:

MURPHY J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 june 2018

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (“the Act”) and rule 2.32(3)(a) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (“the Rules”), that:

(a)the affidavit of Stewart Alan Levitt sworn 12 June 2018;

(b)the supplementary affidavit of Stewart Alan Levitt sworn 14 June 2018; and

(c)the document behind Tab 36 of the Application Book filed in this proceeding on 12 June 2018 identified as the Confidential Opinion of Dr Kristine Hanscombe QC and Dean Guidolin;

be kept confidential and, until further or other order of the Court, be sealed in an envelope and marked “Not to be opened without leave of the Court or a Judge” and placed on the Court file.

2.Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act, the Court authorises:

(a)the applicants on behalf of the group members;

(b)Delphine Dawn Clay as the Sub-group Representative of the Travel Restriction Sub-group claim, on behalf of the Travel Restriction Sub-group members; and

(c)Yvette Gail Wotton as the Sub-group Representative of the General Damages Sub-group claim, on behalf of the General Damages Sub-group members;

nunc pro tunc to enter into the Deed of Settlement dated 16 April 2018 between the applicants, Delphine Dawn Clay and Yvette Gail Wotton and the respondents (“the Deed”) and to give effect to the transactions contemplated by it for and on behalf of the group members, the Travel Restriction Sub-group…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wotton v State of Queensland (No 10) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 915
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Wotton v State of Queensland (No 10), the Federal Court of Australia was tasked with approving a settlement in a class action brought against the State of Queensland. The class action, which followed the death of Cameron Doomadgee in police custody on Palm Island in 2004, involved allegations of racial discrimination by the Queensland Police Service (QPS) and the State's mishandling of the events and community tensions that followed Doomadgee's death. The court had previously found in favour of the applicants and class members on several counts of racial discrimination, leading to the proposed settlement agreement.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the settlement terms were fair, reasonable, and in the best interests of the class members, and whether the court should approve the settlement. The court considered several factors, including the amount of the settlement, the benefits of the settlement to the class members, and the inclusion of an apology by the State of Queensland.

The court approved the settlement, noting that the amount was in the upper range of likely recovery and that the inclusion of a formal apology by the State was of substantial benefit to the applicants and class members. The settlement included provisions for the distribution of funds, the appointment of an administrator, and the fixing of various costs associated with the administration of the settlement. The court also made orders regarding the confidentiality of certain documents and the dismissal of the proceeding upon completion of the settlement administration.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (“the Act”) and rule 2.32(3)(a) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (“the Rules”), that:

(a) the affidavit of Stewart Alan Levitt sworn 12 June 2018;

(b) the supplementary affidavit of Stewart Alan Levitt sworn 14 June 2018; and

(c) the document behind Tab 36 of the Application Book filed in this proceeding on 12 June 2018 identified as the Confidential Opinion of Dr Kristine Hanscombe QC and Dean Guidolin;

be kept confidential and, until further or other order of the Court, be sealed in an envelope and marked “Not to be opened without leave of the Court or a Judge” and placed on the Court file.

2. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act, the Court authorises:

(a) the applicants on behalf of the group members;

(b) Delphine Dawn Clay as the Sub-group Representative of the Travel Restriction Sub-group claim, on behalf of the Travel Restriction Sub-group members; and

(c) Yvette Gail Wotton as the Sub-group Representative of the General Damages Sub-group claim, on behalf of the General Damages Sub-group members;

nunc pro tunc to enter into the Deed of Settlement dated 16 April 2018 between the applicants, Delphine Dawn Clay and Yvette Gail Wotton and the respondents (“the Deed”) and to give effect to the transactions contemplated by it for and on behalf of the group members, the Travel Restriction Sub-group members and the General Damages Sub-group members, respectively.

3. Pursuant to s 33V and s 33ZF of the Act settlement of the proceeding be and is approved by the Court upon the terms set out in:

(a) the Deed exhibited at pages 1 to 22 of exhibit “BRI-1” to the affidavit of Brett Richard Imlay sworn 16 April 2018; and

(b) the Palm Island Class Action Settlement Scheme (“the Scheme”) which is attached as Schedule 1 to these orders.

4. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act, Stewart Alan Levitt be appointed Administrator of the Scheme and be authorized to execute the provisions of the Scheme.

5. Pursuant to s 33ZF and s 33ZG of the Act, for the purposes of the Scheme

(a) the sum of $ 2,415,912.14 be fixed as the amount for “outstanding costs” as defined in the Scheme and be paid in accordance with the Scheme;

(b) the sum of $120,000 be fixed as the amount of “approval costs” as defined in the Scheme and be paid in accordance with the Scheme;

(c) the sum of $1,550,750 be fixed as the amount of “administration costs” as defined in the Scheme and be paid in accordance with the Scheme;

(d) the sum of $2,000 be fixed as the amount of the “sub-group representative payment” as defined in the Scheme and be paid in accordance with the Scheme.

6. Pursuant to s 33ZF, alternatively s 33ZG, of the Act, the Administrator of the Scheme may apply to the Court for approval of further costs associated with the administration of the Scheme in so far as they may exceed the amount fixed as “administration costs” in paragraph 5(c) of these orders.

7. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act, the applicants, the registered group-members (as identified in Schedule 1 to these orders) and the Administrator of the Scheme have liberty to apply to the Court by not less than 5 business days’ notice to each other party for orders in respect of any issue that arises in the administration of the Scheme.

8. Pursuant to s 33ZB and s 33ZF of the Act the persons affected and bound by paragraphs 1 to 6 of these orders are:

(a) the applicants;

(b) Delphine Dawn Clay Delphine Dawn Clay as the Sub-group Representative of the Travel Restriction Sub-group;

(c) Yvette Gail Wotton as the Sub-group Representative of the General Damages Sub-group;

(d) the respondents; and

(e) the registered group members identified in the document entitled “Amended List of all Persons who have registered as Group members and who Intend to Bring a Claim for Compensation or Other Redress” dated 9 April 2018 and filed in the proceeding, a copy of which is attached as Schedule 2 to these orders.

9. Within two business days of the completion of the administration of the Scheme, the Administrator is to apply to the Court for an order that the proceeding be dismissed with no order as to costs.

10. Elizabeth Clay Senior have liberty to apply within six months for an amendment to the Scheme to provide for any residue settlement monies, after distribution, to be provided to a different charity to that provided in the Scheme.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

SCHEDULE 1

SCHEDULE 2

Background

Background to the litigation

The Court thanks counsel for the applicants and class members, Dr K P Hanscombe QC and Dean Guidolin, for the quality of their detailed written submissions and for their comprehensive confidential opinion in support of settlement approval. I have directly drawn upon the submissions at some points. I join with Justice Mortimer in thanking the respondents and their legal representatives for the manner in which they conducted the litigation, which was entirely consistent with their obligations as model litigants.The factual and procedural background The events that gave rise to the class action were triggered by the death on 19 November 2004 of a 36-year-old Aboriginal man, Cameron Doomadgee, known posthumously as Mulrunji, while he was in police custody on Palm Island. Mulrunji was arrested on a suburban street on Palm Island by Senior Sergeant Christopher Hurley of the QPS on the morning of 19 November 2004 for, as SS Hurley said, yelling abuse directed at him and at an Aboriginal police liaison officer who was on duty with him. SS Hurley took Mulrunji, who was affected by alcohol and was protesting and struggling, to the Palm Island Police Station. On the way into the police station, Mulrunji and SS Hurley fell through the rear door of the police station as they were entering it. The trial judge found that Mulrunji ended up on the floor of the police station, and was dragged, limp and unresponsive, into a police cell. Within the hour he had died. The class action broadly concerns the role that race played in the investigation by QPS officers into Mulrunji’s death in custody, and the QPS’s management of community concerns and protests, tensions and anger in the weeks after Mulrunji’s death and in the police responses to the protests and fires that occurred on Palm Island on 26 November 2004. The proposed settlement follows judicial determination of the applicants’ personal claims and of the common questions of fact and law, in favour of the applicants and class members. On 5 December 2016 following a trial that ran over 22 sitting days, in an important judgment for the Palm Island community, the QPS and the State of Queensland, the Court found that QPS officers had breached the Racial Discrimination Act in some of the ways alleged, through:(a)the inappropriate and partial treatment of SS Hurley;(b)the treatment of Aboriginal witnesses;(c)the conduct of Detective Senior Sergeant Kitching in relation to the autopsy report on Mulrunji;(d)the failure to suspend SS Hurley;(e)the failure to communicate with Palm Islanders and defuse tensions in the intervening week between Mulrunji’s death and the protests and fires;(f)the continuation of the declaration of an emergency situation on Palm Island (emergency declaration) after the evening of 26 November 2004; and(g)the arrests, entries and searches of the houses of the applicants and a number of other class members.: see Wotton v State of Queensland (No 5) [2016] FCA 1457; 352 ALR 146 (Liability Judgment) at [1540].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In Wotton v State of Queensland (No 8) [2017] FCA 639 (Common Questions Judgment) the Court decided the issues of law and fact common to the claims of the applicants, the class members and the members of the SERT Subgroup, the sole subgroup which had been established at the time of that judgment. That subgroup comprises persons who allege they suffered loss and damage through arrests, home entries and searches by members of the QPS, including officers of the Special Emergency Response Team (SERT). In the Common Questions Judgment Mortimer J held, in relation to the applicants and the class members, that:(a)the investigation by members of the QPS into the death of Mulrunji lacked independence and impartiality in the ways the Court found in the Liability Judgment at [1028]-[1032];(b)the emergency declaration had a lawful basis at the time was made until (as an outer limit) the early morning of 27 November 2004. Its continuation until the morning of Sunday, 28 November 2004 had no lawful basis, as there was nothing which could be characterised as an “emergency situation after, at the latest, early in the morning of 27 November 2004;(c)the conduct of QPS officers set out in the Liability Judgment at [1028]-[1032], [1096]-[1100], [1196]-[1200] and [1458]-[1462] contravened s 9(1) of the Racial Discrimination Act and constituted unlawful discrimination for the purposes of the Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth), and that the State of Queensland was liable for the officers’ conduct;(d)the applicants and group members are entitled to the declaratory relief sought, set out in the Liability Judgment at [1545]. The declarations of specific contraventions by named officers included unlawful discrimination:(i)by failure to treat SS Hurley as a suspect in the death of Mulrunji and allowing him to continue to perform policing duties;(ii)in their treatment of Aboriginal witnesses interviewed, and in treatment of information supplied by those witnesses, for the purposes of the investigation;(iii)by submitting inaccurate information to the coroner and failing to supply relevant information to the coroner; and(iv)by failure to communicate effectively with the Palm Island community and to defuse tensions. In relation to SERT Subgroup members her Honour held that:(a)the use of SERT officers to effect the arrests of the first applicant and SERT Subgroup members and to enter and search the houses of the applicants and subgroup members was disproportionate and unnecessary;(b)the arrests of the first applicant and those subgroup members who were arrested were unlawful, except for in relation to two named persons;(c)given that there was no lawful basis for the arrest of the first applicant and the subgroup members who were arrested, and that no independent source of lawful authority was otherwise identified, the entry and searches of the houses of the subgroup members was also unlawful;(d)having found that QPS officers contravened s 9(1) of the Racial Discrimination Act in the ways set out in the Liability Judgment at [1028]-[1032], [1096]-[1100], [1196]-[1200] and [1458]-[1462] in relation to the applicants, the subgroup members and the class members, the subgroup members may be entitled to damages under s 46PO of the Racial Discrimination Act, to be assessed in accordance with the Liability Judgment;(e)the evidence demonstrates that SERT officers had the same appearance and adopted the same methods and the same tactical response, as set out at [351] of the Liability Judgment, at each of the houses of subgroup members they attended as they used at the applicants’ houses;(f)aside from the arrests of two named persons all of the arrests of subgroup members were unlawful;(g)all of the entries and searches of the houses were unlawful;(h)given the appearance, methods and tactics of SERT officers with the same at each house they attended, the use of SERT to effect arrests of subgroup members and the entries and searches of the identified houses was an arbitrary and unlawful interference with the rights of the subgroup members to family, privacy and home under Art 17 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights;(i)the entries and searches of the homes of subgroup members were acts involving distinctions and restrictions based on race, as set out in the Liability Judgment at [1366]-[1462]; and(j)the arrests of subgroup members in the course of the entries and searches of the homes of subgroup members were acts involving distinctions and restrictions based on race, as set out in the Liability Judgment at [1366]-[1462].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The proposed settlement follows judicial determination of the applicants’ personal claims and of the common questions of fact and law, in favour of the applicants and class members. On 5 December 2016 following a trial that ran over 22 sitting days, in an important judgment for the Palm Island community, the QPS and the State of Queensland, the Court found that QPS officers had breached the Racial Discrimination Act in some of the ways alleged, through:(a)the inappropriate and partial treatment of SS Hurley;(b)the treatment of Aboriginal witnesses;(c)the conduct of Detective Senior Sergeant Kitching in relation to the autopsy report on Mulrunji;(d)the failure to suspend SS Hurley;(e)the failure to communicate with Palm Islanders and defuse tensions in the intervening week between Mulrunji’s death and the protests and fires;(f)the continuation of the declaration of an emergency situation on Palm Island (emergency declaration) after the evening of 26 November 2004; and(g)the arrests, entries and searches of the houses of the applicants and a number of other class members.: see Wotton v State of Queensland (No 5) [2016] FCA 1457; 352 ALR 146 (Liability Judgment) at [1540]. In Wotton v State of Queensland (No 8) [2017] FCA 639 (Common Questions Judgment) the Court decided the issues of law and fact common to the claims of the applicants, the class members and the members of the SERT Subgroup, the sole subgroup which had been established at the time of that judgment. That subgroup comprises persons who allege they suffered loss and damage through arrests, home entries and searches by members of the QPS, including officers of the Special Emergency Response Team (SERT). In the Common Questions Judgment Mortimer J held, in relation to the applicants and the class members, that:(a)the investigation by members of the QPS into the death of Mulrunji lacked independence and impartiality in the ways the Court found in the Liability Judgment at [1028]-[1032];(b)the emergency declaration had a lawful basis at the time was made until (as an outer limit) the early morning of 27 November 2004. Its continuation until the morning of Sunday, 28 November 2004 had no lawful basis, as there was nothing which could be characterised as an “emergency situation after, at the latest, early in the morning of 27 November 2004;(c)the conduct of QPS officers set out in the Liability Judgment at [1028]-[1032], [1096]-[1100], [1196]-[1200] and [1458]-[1462] contravened s 9(1) of the Racial Discrimination Act and constituted unlawful discrimination for the purposes of the Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth), and that the State of Queensland was liable for the officers’ conduct;(d)the applicants and group members are entitled to the declaratory relief sought, set out in the Liability Judgment at [1545]. The declarations of specific contraventions by named officers included unlawful discrimination:(i)by failure to treat SS Hurley as a suspect in the death of Mulrunji and allowing him to continue to perform policing duties;(ii)in their treatment of Aboriginal witnesses interviewed, and in treatment of information supplied by those witnesses, for the purposes of the investigation;(iii)by submitting inaccurate information to the coroner and failing to supply relevant information to the coroner; and(iv)by failure to communicate effectively with the Palm Island community and to defuse tensions.