| IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA |
| Office of the Registry |
Adelaide No Al0 of 1992 B e t w e e n -
WORKERS REHABILITATION AND
COMPENSATION CORPORATION
Applicant
and
SIMON JAMES
Respondent
Application for special leave
to appeal
DEANE J
GAUDRON J'.
MCHUGH J
| Workers | 1 | 24/6/92 |
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT BRISBANE ON WEDNESDAY, 24 JUNE 1992, AT 2.59 PM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
| MR D.F. JACKSON, QC: | May it please the Court, I appear with |
my learned friend, MRS J. GRUNDY, for the
applicant. (instructed by Thomson Simmons & Co)
| MR T.M. McRAE: If the Court | pleases, I appear for the |
respondent, with my learned friend, MR P.J. HUMPHRIES. (instructed by Reilly Downs & Humphries)
| DEANE J: | Mr Jackson? |
| MR JACKSON: | Your Honours, the issue which merits the |
grant of special leave in this case concerns the
factors to be taken into account in the assessment
of compensation by way of income maintenance is, as
it is described, pursuant to section 35(1)(b)(ii)
of the Workers Compensation and Rehabilitation Act
1986 of South Australia.
Your Honours, the issue applies or arises in
cases of partial incapacity for work and in respect
of the period after the first two years of
incapacity. Your Honours, the importance of the issue, if I could deal with that first, is apparent
from two matters. May I give Your Honours a reference to the observation of Mr Justice Mullighan
at first instance, at page 15 about point 3, where
he refers to the fact that the present application
was one of about 400 similar applications awaiting
hearing. If Your Honours go through the remainder
of the paragraph, he refers to the number of other
cases that fall into the category.
Now, Your Honours, could I refer also to
paragraph 12.4 of the affidavit in support of the
~pplication at page 125. Your Honours, I should
say in passing, in relation to the importance of
the matter, that it is a case where, of course, if
the Court were otherwise minded to grant special leave, our side would pay the costs of the matter. So we would submit on the issue of importance the case is one which would merit the grant of special
leave.May I turn then, Your Honours, to the issue in
the case, and as I said it concerns the
application of section 35 of the Act, and it
concerns the relationship between
section 35(l)(b)(ii) and the several provisions of
section 35(2). Your Honours should have a volume
which contains as the first document in
it section 35.
Your Honours, may I go to the opening words of
section 35(1), and Your Honours will see that it
creates an entitlement to weekly payments where a
| Workers | 2 | 24/6/92 |
worker has received a compensable disability, and
the opening words of section 35(l)(a) relate to the
period of up to a year from the date of injury.
And Your Honours will see from section 35(l)(a)
that subparagraph (i) refers to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Corporation v James and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1992] HCATrans 191
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issue before the Court was the relationship between section 35(1)(b)(ii) and the provisions of section 35(2) of the Act. Section 35(1) establishes entitlements to weekly payments for workers with a compensable disability, distinguishing between total and partial incapacity and different time periods following injury. Section 35(1)(a) covers the first year, while section 35(1)(b) addresses the period after the first year, reducing the maximum entitlement to 80 per cent of notional weekly earnings. The specific question revolved around how to calculate the income maintenance for a partially incapacitated worker after the initial two-year period, particularly when the worker is not in actual employment.
The applicant's argument focused on the interpretation of section 35(1)(b)(ii) in conjunction with section 35(2). Section 35(1)(b) provides for weekly payments of 80 per cent of notional weekly earnings in cases of partial incapacity after the first year. However, the amount to be subtracted from this entitlement, if the worker is not in actual employment, is the amount the worker could earn in suitable employment. The applicant sought clarification on the factors to be considered in determining this "could earn" amount for the purposes of calculating compensation beyond the initial two-year period.
Background
Background to the litigation
Simon James, the respondent, was injured in a workplace accident, resulting in partial incapacity for work. Following the injury, he received compensation under the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 (S.A.). The dispute arose concerning the calculation of ongoing compensation payments for income maintenance after the initial two-year period. The Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Corporation argued that the compensation should be based on the availability of suitable employment in the general job market, while Simon James contended that the assessment should be limited to employment for which he was physically capable of doing. This led to a legal battle over the interpretation of the statutory provisions and the factors that should be considered in assessing the worker's capacity to obtain suitable employment. The Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia provided its interpretation, but the applicant sought further clarification from the High Court.
The matter of Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Corporation v James came before the High Court as an application for special leave to appeal. The applicant, Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Corporation, sought to appeal the decision of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia in James v Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Corporation. The appeal sought to challenge the interpretation of certain sections of the Workers Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 1986 of South Australia, specifically sections 35 and 36, concerning the assessment of compensation for income maintenance after a period of partial incapacity for work. The Full Court had already narrowed the issues before it, focusing on questions of statutory interpretation rather than the particular circumstances of the respondent, Simon James. The High Court, after considering the submissions, found that the questions did not raise matters of general legal principle and that there was insufficient doubt about the correctness of the Full Court’s decisions to merit a grant of special leave to appeal. Consequently, the application for special leave to appeal was refused.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What factors should be considered in the assessment of compensation by way of income maintenance for workers with partial incapacity for work under section 35(1)(b)(ii) of the Workers Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 1986 of South Australia?
2. Does the phrase "suitable employment that the worker has a reasonable prospect of obtaining" in section 35(1)(b)(ii) of the Act refer to the work available generally or only to the work the worker is physically capable of doing?
3. Are the factors listed in section 35(2)(b) of the Act an exhaustive list of considerations to be taken into account when assessing a worker's prospects of obtaining employment?
4. Does the language of the provisions in the Act relating to suitable employment and the availability of work create ambiguity that requires judicial interpretation?
Held
1. The court concluded that the application for special leave to appeal was refused as the answers provided by the Full Court to the questions on the construction of sections 35 and 36 of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 (S.A.) did not give rise to any matters of general legal principle. As a result, the special leave to appeal was denied.
2. The court held that the phrase "suitable employment that the worker has a reasonable prospect of obtaining" in section 35(1)(b)(ii) of the Act refers to the work available generally, not only the work the worker is physically capable of doing.
3. The court found that the factors listed in section 35(2)(b) of the Act are not an exhaustive list of considerations to be taken into account when assessing a worker's prospects of obtaining employment. Other factors may be considered in addition to those listed in section 35(2)(b).
4. The court determined that the language of the provisions in the Act relating to suitable employment and the availability of work does not create ambiguity that requires judicial interpretation. The court found the language to be loose rather than exact, but it did not find it necessary to provide an interpretation.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The case of Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Corporation v James addressed several critical issues surrounding the interpretation and application of sections 35(1)(b)(ii) and 35(2) of the Workers Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 1986 of South Australia. The central issue pertained to the factors to be considered in the assessment of compensation for workers with partial incapacity for work. The court examined the phrase "suitable employment that the worker has a reasonable prospect of obtaining" and whether it refers to work generally available or only to work the worker is physically capable of doing.
The applicant argued that the phrase should be interpreted to mean only the work the worker is physically capable of doing, whereas the respondent contended that it referred to the work available generally. The court considered the language of section 35(1)(b)(ii) and noted that the use of the words "that the worker has a reasonable prospect of obtaining" might initially suggest a narrower interpretation. However, the court acknowledged that this section does not stand alone and must be read in conjunction with section 35(2).
Section 35(2)(a) applies to the first two years and involves an onus of proof provision, which addresses the availability of suitable employment. Section 35(2)(b) lists specific factors to be considered in assessing a worker's prospects of obtaining employment, and the applicant argued that these factors are exhaustive and relate only to the worker's capacity. The respondent, however, suggested that factors such as the location and availability of work should also be considered.
The court emphasized that the language of the Act is loose rather than exact, which creates ambiguity that requires judicial interpretation. It noted the importance of ensuring consistency in applying the test for determining suitable employment over different periods. The court concluded that the language in section 35(2)(b) implied that the listed factors were intended to be an exhaustive list of considerations, focusing on the worker's capacity rather than the general availability of work.
The court also considered whether the language of the provisions created ambiguity that required judicial interpretation. It found that the loose language did indeed create some ambiguity, necessitating a careful reading of the provisions to ensure coherent application across different periods of incapacity.
In sum, the ratio decidendi of the case is that the factors listed in section 35(2)(b) of the Act are to be considered exhaustive when assessing a worker's prospects of obtaining employment, focusing on the worker's capacity rather than the general availability of work. This interpretation ensures consistency in applying the test for determining suitable employment over different periods of incapacity. The court's decision clarified the scope of the factors to be considered in the assessment of compensation for workers with partial incapacity for work, providing guidance on the application of the Act's provisions.