PHILMAC PTY LTD v STRINGER
Full Court: Doyle CJ, Millhouse and Nyland JJ
DOYLE CJ
This is an appeal against a decision by the Workers’ Compensation Appeal Tribunal (“the Tribunal”). By s100(3) of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 (“the Act”) the appeal is limited to a question of law.
In my opinion the appellant has not identified any error of law made by the Tribunal. Indeed, I doubt whether a question of law arises at all. I would dismiss the appeal. My reasons for so concluding are as follows.
It is not now in dispute that the worker has suffered from a partial incapacity for work at all relevant times. That incapacity arose from a compensable disability suffered on 26 August 1994. The disability was an injury to the worker’s back. The result of the injury was that the worker was able to perform only certain types of the work that she had previously performed. The worker returned to work on 29 August 1994. The employer provided work that was within the limitations that the disability imposed upon the worker, and the worker performed that work.
But the worker resigned from her employment on 29 September 1994. That followed a meeting between the worker and two other workers, each of whom appears to have occupied a supervisory position in relation to the worker.
The issue before the Tribunal, as it was before the Review Officer, was whether the worker was entitled to weekly payments in respect of her disability. The worker being partially incapacitated for work, her entitlement was to receive payments equal to the difference between her “notional weekly earnings” and earnings that she “could earn in suitable employment”: see s35(1)(a) of the Act. It is relevant to mention that her partial incapacity for work is to be treated as total incapacity unless it is established “that suitable employment is reasonably available to the worker”: s35(2)(b). There was no dispute before us that in deciding upon the availability of suitable employment, the Tribunal was entitled to have regard to more than the task assigned to the worker. As the High Court said in R J Brodie (Holdings) Pty Ltd v Pennell (1968) 117 CLR 665, at 669-670, the performance of a contract of service involves the co-operation of both employer and employee. When considering the work offered by an employer to a worker who is partially incapacitated for work, it is appropriate to take account of the conditions under which the worker is expected to work. There can be situations in which a worker is offered work within the physical capabilities of the worker, but under circumstances such that it cannot be said that the work is suitable employment. An example of this is a situation in which there is a real risk of a worker suddenly confronting a task beyond the worker’s physical limitations, in circumstances such that there is the risk of the worker instinctively performing the task and suffering a further injury. Another…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Philmac Pty Ltd v Stringer No. Scgrg-97-991 Judgment No. S66... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1998] SASC 6687
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court involved the determination of whether the worker was entitled to receive weekly payments for her partial incapacity, considering that suitable employment was not reasonably available to her. The worker argued that the employer failed to provide suitable work and a supportive environment, which led to her resignation. The employer contended that the worker could have performed the work offered, and that the Tribunal's findings were flawed.
The court examined the reasoning of the Tribunal and the Review Officer, focusing on the elements of mutuality and the availability of suitable employment. The Tribunal had found that the worker was left without support and faced a hostile work environment, which contributed to her resignation. The court found that the Tribunal's conclusions were supported by the evidence and did not reveal any error of law. The findings regarding the employer's lack of cooperation and the hostile atmosphere were based on factual evidence and were open to the Tribunal.
The appeal was dismissed, as the court found no error of law in the Tribunal's approach or findings. The court upheld the Tribunal's decision that suitable employment was not reasonably available to the worker due to the employer's failure to provide the necessary support and a conducive work environment.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Workers’ Compensation Appeal Tribunal following an appeal by the employer, Philmac Pty Ltd, against a decision by the Review Officer. The appeal was limited to a question of law under section 100(3) of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986. The Tribunal reviewed the evidence and findings of the Review Officer and dismissed the employer's appeal. The employer then appealed to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia, which heard the case and delivered its judgment.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Has the Tribunal identified any error of law in its approach to the issues before it?
2. Are the findings made by the Review Officer and the Tribunal findings of fact or law?
3. Does the finding that the employment offered was not suitable employment because of the environment and arrangements under which the worker was to work involve any error of law?
Held
1. Has the Tribunal identified any error of law in its approach to the issues before it?
The Court concluded that the Tribunal did not identify any error of law in its approach to the issues before it. The appeal should be dismissed.
2. Are the findings made by the Review Officer and the Tribunal findings of fact or law?
The Court concluded that the findings made by the Review Officer and the Tribunal are findings of fact and do not involve any question of law.
3. Does the finding that the employment offered was not suitable employment because of the environment and arrangements under which the worker was to work involve any error of law?
The Court concluded that the finding, despite lacking precision, does not involve any error of law as it was open to the Tribunal based on the evidence before it.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court examined the appeal against a decision by the Workers’ Compensation Appeal Tribunal, limited to a question of law. The Tribunal's decision was reviewed in light of the worker's partial incapacity due to a compensable disability. The worker resigned from employment due to perceived and real threats in the workplace, and the Tribunal found that the employer had poorly managed the provision of suitable work, leading to a hostile atmosphere. The Court found that the Tribunal's approach to the issues did not disclose any error of law. The findings of the Review Officer and the Tribunal were deemed to be findings of fact, supported by evidence, and not involving any question of law. Although there was some criticism regarding the specificity of the findings, the Court concluded that the lack of detail did not amount to an error of law. The Court also found that the Tribunal's conclusion on the suitability of the employment offered was consistent with the ultimate decision and did not stand alone as an error. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed as there was no error of law in the Tribunal's approach.