HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Kitto, Taylor, Menzies, Windeyer and Owen JJ.
R.J. BRODIE (HOLDING) PTY. LTD. V. PENNELL
7 November 1968
Workers' Compensation (N.S.W.)
Workers' Compensation (N.S.W.)—Partial incapacity—Failure by employer to provide worker with suitable employment—Compensation payable as if totally incapacitated—Worker earning some moneys—Whether employer relieved from compensating on basis of total incapacity—"Failure . . . to provide suitable employment"—Workers' Compensation Act, 1926-1964 (N.S.W.), s. 11 (1) (2)*.
Decisions
November 7.
The following written judgments were delivered:-
KITTO, TAYLOR, WINDEYER AND OWEN JJ. On 6th November 1964 the respondent, as a "worker" within the meaning of the Workers' Compensation Act, 1926-1964 (N.S.W.), obtained an award which, inter alia, provided for compensation in respect of partial incapacity resulting from injuries arising out of or in the course of his employment with the appellant. Partial incapacity was found to exist from 1st September 1964 onwards and the weekly amount of compensation, assessed pursuant to s. 11 (1) of the Act, was 10 pounds, that being the difference between his average weekly earnings before the injury and the amount which the Commission found he would be able to earn after the injury and during the period of partial incapacity. (at p666)
2. At the relevant time the material portion of s. 11 (1) of the Act was in the following terms:
"(a) In the case of partial incapacity, the weekly payment shall in no case exceed the difference between the amount of the average weekly earnings of the worker before the injury, and the average weekly amount he is earning, or is able to earn, in some suitable employment or business, after the injury, but shall bear such relation to the amount of that difference as under the circumstances of the case may appear proper."whilst s. 11 (2), to which it will be necessary to refer, was as follows:
"An employer shall provide suitable employment for his injured worker during the worker's partial incapacity for his pre-injury employment. Upon any failure by such employer to provide suitable employment as aforesaid the worker's incapacity for work shall be deemed to be total, and he shall be compensated accordingly." (at p667)
3. It was with the provisions of s. 11 (2) in mind that on 28th November 1964 the respondent wrote to the appellant requesting it to "provide me with suitable employment" but on 4th December 1964 the appellant replied and regretted "that we are unable to offer you suitable light employment". Thereupon, on 23rd February 1965, the respondent, contending that in the circumstances his compensation should be assessed as for total incapacity, applied to the Commission for a variation of the existing award. In the result the application was successful and compensation payable to the respondent was re-assessed "on the basis of notional total incapacity". (at p667)
4. Although it was conceded before the Commission that the respondent was a worker whose compensable injuries had resulted at all material times in partial incapacity for his pre-injury employment, his right…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read RJ Brodie (Holdings) Pty Ltd v Pennell and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1968] HCA 73
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues before the Court were whether the restrictive covenants, which purported to prevent the vendor from engaging in a competing business within a specified geographical area and for a defined period, were void as being contrary to public policy. Specifically, the Court had to determine if the covenants went beyond what was reasonably necessary to protect the legitimate interests of the purchaser, thereby constituting an unreasonable restraint of trade.
The Court's reasoning focused on the principles governing restraints of trade. It was held that for a restrictive covenant to be valid, it must be no wider than is reasonably necessary to protect the proprietary interests of the party seeking to enforce it. This involves a consideration of the nature of the business, the geographical scope of the restriction, and the duration of the restraint. The Court examined the specific terms of the covenants in light of these principles, assessing whether they unduly restricted the vendor's ability to earn a livelihood without providing a commensurate benefit to the purchaser in terms of protecting the goodwill of the business sold.
The High Court ultimately found that the restrictive covenants were void and unenforceable as they constituted an unreasonable restraint of trade.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi