Wolstencroft and Commissioner of Superannuation

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2001] AATA 1011

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No  V00/887

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      NOEL WILLIAM WOLSTENCROFT      
  Applicant
           And    COMMISSIONER FOR SUPERANNUATION  
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Mrs Joan Dwyer,     Senior Member Mr G Friedman    Member Mr W G McLean            Member         

Date12 December 2001

PlaceMelbourne

Decision      The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the matter to the Commissioner for reconsideration in accordance with the direction that the election made by Mr Wolstencroft on 17 May 1990 be treated as if it had been made within the period allowed by s 137(1) of the Act.
  (sgd) Joan Dwyer
  Senior Member
SUPERANNUATION - Commonwealth Superannuation Scheme - preservation of superannuation rights - election to preserve benefits more than 21 days after resigning - discretion to recognise late election - incorrect information given to applicant regarding options available - whether in the interests of justice that time be extended - consideration of Commonwealth Superannuation Scheme Board approved guidelines – decision set aside

Superannuation Act 1976 s 137 (1), 157 (1)

Re Lander and Commissioner for Superannuation (1993) 29 ALD 870

Re Liddle and Commissioner for Superannuation (1991) 14 AAR 456

Re Boardman and Commissioner for Superannuation (1993) 30 ALD 619

Re Chalk and Commissioner for Superannuation (1993) 30 ALD 537

Re Secourable and Commissioner for Superannuation (unreported W92/117, 19 March 1993)

Re Schofield and Commissioner for Superannuation (AAT 10006, 14 February 1995)

Chalk v Commissioner for Superannuation (1994) 33 ALD 420

Commissioner for Superannuation v Boardman (1994) 33 ALD 569

Comcare v A'Hearn (1993) 45 FCR 441

Bond Corporation Holdings Limited v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal (1988) 84 ALR 669

Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 2 ALD 60

Re Boardman and Commissioner of Superannuation (1993) 30 ALD 619

Re Lamb and Commissioner for Superannuation (AAT 11014, 17 June 1996)

Re Charles and Commissioner for Superannuation (1993) 18 AAR 61

Re McKnight and Commissioner for Superannuation (1998) 49 ALD 84

Re Morgan and Commissioner for Superannuation (unreported W92/200, 12 March 1993

Re Schwarze and Commissioner for Superannuation (unreported A94/123, 3 February 1995

REASONS FOR DECISION

12 November 2001  Mrs Joan Dwyer,                Senior Member  Mr G Friedman             Member  Mr W McLean,  Member         

  1. This is an application under ss 154(6) of the Superannuation Act 1976 ("the Act") for review of a reviewable decision made on 8 November 1991. A delegate of the Commissioner for Superannuation decided not to direct, under s 157(1) of the Act, that the election made by Mr Wolstencroft on 17 May 1990 (T14 p28) be treated as if it had been made within the period allowed by s 137(1) of the Act. That decision was confirmed on I9 July 1994.

  2. Mr G Moore of Counsel appeared for Mr Wolstencroft. Mr B Dubé, in-house Counsel with the Australian Government Solicitor, appeared for the respondent. Mr Wolstencroft gave evidence. Evidence on his behalf was also given by his wife and by Mr Sexton. The respondent did not call any evidence. The Tribunal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wolstencroft and Commissioner of Superannuation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] AATA 1011
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Wolstencroft and Commissioner of Superannuation involved a dispute regarding the superannuation entitlements of Mr. Wolstencroft. The matter was heard in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. Mr. Wolstencroft sought recognition of a late election to preserve his superannuation rights upon his resignation from Telecom in 1980. The Commissioner of Superannuation, however, denied the application on the basis that Mr. Wolstencroft's understanding and knowledge of the preservation option at the time of his resignation was insufficient.

The central legal issue was whether Mr. Wolstencroft's limited understanding of the preservation option at the time of his resignation, coupled with his failure to seek clarification, negated his entitlement to have the late election recognised. This required the tribunal to determine the extent to which an individual's knowledge and understanding of superannuation options must be assessed when considering the recognition of a late election. Furthermore, the tribunal had to consider the weight to be given to the applicant's belief that he was only entitled to a refund of contributions upon resignation.

In assessing the case, the tribunal took into account Mr. Wolstencroft's evidence that he believed, and that those with whom he worked, were only entitled to a refund of contributions upon resignation. This belief was supported by the Telecom booklet "Conditions of Employment" which stated that on resignation, a contributor is refunded all contributions, plus interest. Mr. Wolstencroft testified that the concept of preserving superannuation rights was foreign to him and he did not seek further information about the preservation option. The tribunal concluded that while Mr. Wolstencroft's lack of understanding and failure to seek clarification were factors, they did not entirely preclude the recognition of the late election. The tribunal found that the Commissioner's denial of the application was not justified given the circumstances.

The tribunal ordered that the Commissioner of Superannuation recognise Mr. Wolstencroft's late election to preserve his superannuation rights. This decision underscores the importance of considering an individual's actual understanding and the context in which they made their election, rather than strictly adhering to procedural missteps.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The delegate acknowledged there would be benefit to Mr Wolstencroft if his late election were recognised, but said this was not the only or the most important consideration.the evidence for the applicant One relevant issue is Mr Wolstencroft's knowledge and understanding of the preservation option when he signed T8. Mr Wolstencroft said that his belief, and that of those with whom he worked at Telecom, prior to 1980, was that if you resigned all you were entitled to in respect of superannuation was a refund of contributions. As an example, he recounted a conversation he had had with one of his workmates, a senior technical person. He did not enjoy working at Telecom but had a lovely tenor voice and sang in opera in his spare time. Mr Wolstencroft said he had asked him why he did not leave and do what he enjoyed and his response was (trans. p23):Well I'd lose all the contributions of my superannuation. Mr Wolstencroft produced the Telecom booklet "Conditions of Employment" which was current at the time of his resignation (A7). It states:6. ResignationOn resignation a contributor is refunded all contributions, plus interest which has accumulated since 1 July 1976. Mr Wolstencroft's evidence is supported not only by the 1979 booklet (A7), but also by its successor (A3), issued in 1983. It states:6. ResignationOn resignation a contributor is refunded all contributions, plus interest which has accumulated since 1 July 1976. P&IR Guidelines Section B10/3/11. Mr Wolstencroft produced the letter dated 18 March 1983 (A1) which he received advising him of his obligatory superannuation contributions on his rejoining Telecom. He also produced (A2) a circular enclosed with that letter as to which the letter (A1) stated:Details of benefits under the scheme are explained in the attached circular. Mr Moore asked Mr Wolstencroft what he thought about the reference to preservation in the form (T8), which he received in the mail with a covering letter asking him to complete the form. Mr Wolstencroft replied (trans. pp23-24):Well, I thought it was a common form such as we have with our leave forms and so on which has sick leave and long service leave and all that sort of thing on it and you usually tick the appropriate box or the particular leave that you wish and this form was a similar sort of thing and I thought, well, the only thing that applies to me was apply for a refund of accumulated contributions which is the only knowledge I had at that time.That is why you struck out the other two options in the middle of the first boxed part?---That's why I struck out the other – that was the only thing I considered applicable.Yes. So - - -?---The words preservation of superannuation rights never meant anything to me. It's gobbledegook as far as - - - When the Tribunal asked Mr Wolstencroft whether the two sections he crossed out in the form did not trigger him to ask someone what they meant, he said they did not (trans. p49):Well I thought that was applicable to something else, that the form could be used forWhat else did you think they were applicable to?---Well, I didn't know. I thought it was a common form which you could use for other things and you crossed out which was applicable to what you were applying for.But what I am asking you is if you didn't know, why didn't you ask?---I wish I had have.Yes?---But I thought that I did know and I didn't ask because I thought I did know.Even though you just said you didn't know what they were for?---Well I didn't know what those words meant but I thought that I knew what my entitlements were, that the only option I had was to take what I was given and that was it. I didn't know that I could roll it over.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established