Wilson and K & S Freighters Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

Wilson and K & S Freighters Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2018] AATA 464 (9 February 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2017/0030

Re:Larry Wilson

APPLICANT

AndK & S Freighters Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President S Boyle

Date:9 February 2018

Place:Perth

The Tribunal decides:

1.to set aside the Reviewable Decision and substitute a decision that the determination made 3 July 2012 which accepted liability not be varied; and

2.the Respondent pay the costs of these proceedings incurred by the Applicant.

....[sgd]................................................................

Deputy President S Boyle

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – reviewable decision – deny liability – serious and wilful misconduct – wilful and false representation – voluntarily and unreasonably submitted to an abnormal risk – decision set aside

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988(Cth) – s 5A(1)(a), s 5A(1)(b), s 5B(1)(b), s 6(1), s 6(3), s 7(7), s14, s 14(3), s 16, s 19, s 60(1), s 61, s 62, s 62(1), s 64, s 67(1), s 67(8)

Cases

Comcare v Calipari [2001] FCA 1534
Comcare v Porter (1996) 70 FCR 139
Iannella v French (1968) 119 CLR 84
Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May [2016] HCA 19
R v Aspinall (1876) 2 QBD 48

Re Schofield v Comcare (1995) 38 ALD 124

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President S Boyle

9 February 2018

THE APPLICATION

  1. This is an application for the review of a decision made by the Respondent pursuant to s 62 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (the SRC Act) on 22 December 2016 (the Reviewable Decision).

  2. The Reviewable Decision was:

    The determination made on 3 July 2012 in respect of “bruising over left elbow, left lateral foot and left hip” (where the compensable injury was amended by a reconsideration on Own Motion dated 25 September 2015 to read “pain and paraesthesia left elbow and forearm to ulnar border left hand side, left foot, left hip, lower back and lateral chest wall”) sustained on 12 June 2012 which accepted liability to pay compensation in accordance with s.14 of the SRC Act, be varied to find that K&S Freighters is not liable to pay compensation in accordance with s.14 of the SRC Act for “pain and paraesthesia left elbow and forearm to ulnar border left hand side, left foot, left hip, lower back and lateral chest wall” sustained on 12 June 2012.

  3. The determination of 3 July 2012 to which the Reviewable Decision relates was a decision accepting liability under sections 14, 16 and 19 of the SRC Act in respect of “bruising over left elbow, left lateral foot and left hip” sustained on 12 June 2012 (T36, page 143).

  4. This application is made pursuant to s 64(1) of the SRC Act.

    BACKGROUND

  5. The Applicant was born in 1951. He commenced employment with Regal Transport as a truck driver in May 2011 (paragraph 4 of the Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (the Respondent’s SFIC)). It is not disputed that at some point Regal Transport…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wilson and K & S Freighters Pty Ltd (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 464
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Mr Wilson, sought a review of a decision by K & S Freighters Pty Ltd (the respondent) to deny liability for compensation under the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (Cth) (SRC Act). Mr Wilson sustained injuries when he was struck by a forklift at the respondent's business premises. The respondent initially accepted liability for certain injuries but later reconsidered its decision, asserting that Mr Wilson's actions constituted serious and wilful misconduct, thereby precluding compensation under section 14(3) of the SRC Act.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Mr Wilson's conduct in being struck by the forklift amounted to serious and wilful misconduct as defined by section 14(3) of the SRC Act. This required the court to determine if Mr Wilson had voluntarily and unreasonably submitted to an abnormal risk of injury, or if his actions constituted a wilful and false representation, as contemplated by other provisions of the Act. The respondent argued that Mr Wilson had breached various occupational health and safety rules, including entering a forklift exclusion zone, failing to make eye contact with the forklift driver, and not using designated pedestrian walkways.

The court considered the respondent's arguments regarding Mr Wilson's alleged breaches of site rules and safety training. It noted that for conduct to constitute serious and wilful misconduct, it must be serious in itself, not merely the outcome of the conduct. The respondent relied on evidence of Mr Wilson's training, company policies, and site rules concerning pedestrian safety and exclusion zones. However, the court found that the respondent had not established that Mr Wilson's actions met the threshold for serious and wilful misconduct under section 14(3) of the SRC Act. The court also considered whether Mr Wilson had voluntarily and unreasonably submitted to an abnormal risk of injury under section 6(3) of the SRC Act, but ultimately found this defence was not made out.

The court set aside the respondent's decision to deny liability. It found that the applicant's actions did not constitute serious and wilful misconduct that would disentitle him to compensation under the SRC Act. Consequently, the respondent was liable to pay compensation to the applicant in accordance with the Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This application is made pursuant to s 64(1) of the SRC Act.BACKGROUND The Applicant was born in 1951. He commenced employment with Regal Transport as a truck driver in May 2011 (paragraph 4 of the Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (the Respondent’s SFIC)). It is not disputed that at some point Regal Transport became, or was taken over, by the Respondent and that the Respondent is liable for any payment due to the Applicant under the SRC Act. At some time around 8.30 am on 12 June 2012 the Applicant was struck by a forklift at the Respondent’s business premises in South Guildford (the Respondent’s Yard). As far as the Tribunal is aware, it is not disputed that the force of the impact knocked the Applicant to the ground and that he was momentarily rendered unconscious. Immediately following the Applicant being struck he was taken by another employee of the Respondent to Dr Peter Brockhoff in Kewdale for medical treatment and review (T43, page 199). It is not disputed that when the Applicant was struck he was returning to his truck which was parked within the Respondent’s Yard. The Applicant made a claim for workers’ compensation on 13 June 2012 (T28, pages 116-123). Amongst other things, the workers’ compensation claim signed by the Applicant on 13 June 2012 stated as follows:8. What injury or illness are you claiming workers’ compensation for? - C/O pain and paraesthesia left elbow and forearm to ulnar border left hand also C/O pain left foot, hip, trunk and lateral chest wall.9. What parts of your body have been most affected by your injury or illness? Left side of the body, left elbow, left arm, neck, lower hip area.19. What is the address where you were injured or contracted your illness? -Regal Transport, 5 Kalamunda Road, South Guildford, walking in the yard.20. What started the chain of events that led to your injury or illness? - A forklift moving and me walking in the same area in the yard.21. What action, exposure or event happened to cause your injury or illness? - The forklift slid into me after applying the brakes (raining at the time).22. What actually injured you or made you ill? - The front mask (sic) and tines of the forklift and landing on the pavement. In a determination under s 61 of the SRC Act dated 3 July 2012 (T36) in respect of the claim for “bruising over left elbow, left lateral foot and left hip” sustained on 12 June 2012, it was determined by the Respondent that it was liable to pay compensation in accordance with s 14 of the SRC Act in respect of “bruising over left elbow, left lateral foot and left hip” sustained on 12 June 2012 with medical treatment and incapacity as deemed appropriate by a legally qualified medical practitioner pursuant to sections 16 and 19 respectively of the SRC Act. After the injury the Applicant has not returned to normal duties although he did return for a period on restricted suitable duties and restricted hours until October 2014. In a reconsideration on own motion under s 62(1)(a) of the SRC Act on 25 September 2015 (T41, pages 178-181) acceptance of liability was changed to:Pain and paraesthesia left elbow and forearm to ulnar border left hand side, left foot, left hip, lower back and lateral chest wall sustained on 12 June 2012.(Note that the Respondent at paragraph 5.4 of the Respondent’s SFIC identifies the date of the first reconsideration under s 62(1)(a) to be on 29/05/15. The Tribunal cannot find a document of that date and assumes that the date in the Respondent’s SFIC should be 25/09/15.)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal had before it the following documentary evidence:·T documents 1 – 45 and supplementary T documents ST46 – 56 together comprising 353 pages (Exhibit R2);·Witness statement of Applicant dated 19 May 2017 (Exhibit A2);·Supplementary witness statement of Applicant dated 20 October 2017 (Exhibit A3);·Work assessment report by Dr Durda Bacvic prepared for the Respondent dated 16 May 2013 (Exhibit A1);·Statement of Kelly Shaw (Hughes) dated 2 February 2017;·Respondent’s Policy: Pedestrian Safety (PS) – On-line Training Module dated 2 November 2007 (Exhibit R3);·Certificate of completion to certify the Applicant completed program for pedestrian safety on 10 May 2011 (Exhibit R3);·Aerial photograph of Respondent’s Yard (Exhibit A4); and·Excerpt (pages 18-22) of transcript of hearing on 22 March 2017 in Tribunal matters 2014/5639 and Ors (Exhibit R1).Oral evidence The application was heard by Deputy President Boyle on 21 November 2017. The Applicant and Kenneth McCallum gave evidence and were cross-examined at the hearing. Written closing submissions were filed by each of the parties following the hearing.LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK Section 14(3) of the SRC Act is as follows:(3) Compensation is not payable in respect of an injury that is caused by the serious and wilful misconduct of the employee but is not intentionally self-inflicted, unless the injury results in death, or serious and permanent impairment. Section 7(7) of the SRC Act is as follows:(7) A disease suffered by an employee, or an aggravation of such a disease, shall not be taken to be an injury to the employee for the purposes of this Act if the employee has at any time, for purposes connected with his or her employment or proposed employment by the Commonwealth or a licensed corporation, made a wilful and false representation that he or she did not suffer, or had not previously suffered, from that disease. Section 6(3) of the SRC Act is as follows:(3) Subsection (1) does not apply where an employee sustains an injury: (a) while at a place referred to in that subsection; or (b) during an ordinary recess in his or her employment; if the employee sustained the injury because he or she voluntarily and unreasonably submitted to an abnormal risk of injury. Section 6(1) of the SRC Act is, relevantly, as follows:(1) Without limiting the circumstances in which an injury to an employee may be treated as having arisen out of, or in the course of, his or her employment, an injury shall, for the purposes of this Act, be treated as having so arisen if it was sustained: (a) as a result of an act of violence that would not have occurred but for the employee's employment or the performance by the employee of the duties or functions of his or her employment; or(b) while the employee was at the employee's place of work, for the purposes of that employment, or was temporarily absent from that place during an ordinary recess in that employment; or… Section 62 of the SRC Act is as follows:(1) A determining authority may, on its own motion: (a) reconsider a determination made by it; or (b) cause such a determination to be reconsidered by a person to whom its power under this section is delegated, being a person other than the person who made, or was involved in the making of, the determination; whether or not a proceeding has been instituted or completed under this Part in respect of a reviewable decision made in relation to that determination.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 60 (1) of the SRC Act includes the definition of “reviewable decision” as follows;reviewable decision means a decision made under subsection 38(4) or section 62.CONSIDERATIONWas the injury caused by the serious and wilful misconduct of the Applicant for the purposes of s 14(3) of the SRC Act? The Respondent’s argument on the issue of wilful misconduct is set out in paragraph C.2.1 of the Respondent’s SFIC which is as follows: 2.1 Serious and WILFUL Misconduct under Subsection 14(3)2.1.1 The Applicant disobeyed Occupational Health and Safety training and general site rules by:(a) being in a working area exclusion zone of forklift/mobile equipment whilst it was in operation;(b) not ensuring that he made eye contact with any persons driving vehicles/mobile equipment in operational areas;(c) not using designated pedestrian walkways or making eye contact with drivers/operators before crossing from one location to another.2.1.2 The Applicant was disobeying company and site rules and in disregard of requirements as to the use of pedestrian walkways by walking through a loading and unloading exclusion zone and in disregard of any vehicle which may have been in the area. The Respondent’s SFIC reflects the findings in paragraph 9.1 to 9.12 of the Statement of Reasons provided with the Reviewable Decision (T43) (see paragraph 16 above). The Respondent’s case relies on it establishing a number of critical facts. They are:(a)the Applicant was in a work area exclusion zone when he was struck;(b)in the circumstances the Applicant should have made eye contact with the forklift driver; and(c)there was a designated pedestrian walkway that he Applicant should have been using when he was struck. Even if those facts are established, the Respondent must still satisfy the Tribunal that, in the circumstances, the Applicant’s conduct amounted to serious and wilful misconduct and that that serious and wilful misconduct caused the injury. In that regard the conduct must be serious, not the outcome of the conduct (Comcare v Calipari [2001] FCA 1534 at [3]). To argue that the Applicant’s conduct was serious and wilful misconduct, the Respondent relies on various company policies, training courses undertaken by the Applicant and toolbox site meetings. Mr McCallum’s witness statement refers to the following (T44, pages 201-206):·The Applicant underwent on-line induction at the commencement of his employment on 10-11 May 2011 (paragraph 4 – 7);·Relevantly the induction training included “Driver Exclusion Zone Policy” training, “Pedestrian Safety” and “Driver Exclusion Zone During Forklift Operations (SOP -24)” (paragraphs 8-10);·On 24 May 2011 the Applicant was sent a letter attaching “Guidelines for Loading, Unloading Exclusions Zones (LUEZ) (paragraph 11);·The theme of the June 2011 toolbox meeting, attended by the Applicant, was LUEZ (paragraph 12);·The General Site rules included (paragraph 14):LOADING AND UNLOADING EXCLUSION ZONES (LUEZ)Pedestrian traffic (including drivers and operators) are not to be within the working area (exclusion zone) of forklifts/mobile equipment whilst in operation. This includes not on top of trailer/trayAll requirements of industry guidelines – LUEZ are to be adopted. Also refer to SOP – 24 Loading and Unloading Exclusion Zones (LUEZ) BEWARE OF VEHICLESMake sure that you always make eye contact with any persons driving vehicles/mobile equipment in operational areas. Only approach vehicle/mobile equipment once you have received the approval from the driver/operator and it is safe to do so.PEDESTRAIN/WALKWAYSAlways use/follow pedestrian walkways.Eye contact and acknowledgement is to be made/received from drivers/operators before crossing form one location to another.·The theme of the monthly toolbox meeting in October 2011 attended by the Applicant was loading, unloading exclusion zones SOP 24 (paragraph 16).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.