Williams v Department of Environment and Resource Management

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

LAND APPEAL COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: Williams v Department of Environment and Resource Management [2014] QLAC 10
PARTIES:

RICHARD FRED WILLIAMS and
MARY OLIVE WILLIAMS
 (appellants)

v

CHIEF EXECUTIVE, DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENT AND RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
(respondent)

FILE NO:

Appeal No. LAC009-13

Land Court No. WAA022-07

ORIGINATING COURT: Land Court of Queensland
PROCEEDING: Appeal
DELIVERED ON: 18 December 2014
DELIVERED AT: Cairns
HEARD ON: 6 March 2014 and 29 April 2014
HEART AT: Cairns
THE COURT:

Henry J
CAC MacDonald, President of the Land Court
MD Evans, Member of the Land Court

Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, Henry J and MacDonald P agreeing as to the orders made, Evans M dissenting.

ORDER:

The appeal is allowed.1.        

The order below is set aside.2.        

The respondent pay 70 per cent of the appellants’ costs of the appeal to the Land Court from and including 23 June 2008 on the indemnity basis.3.        

Submissions as to the costs of this appeal shall be in writing with:4.        

the appellants’ written submissions (not exceeding five pages) to be filed and served within 21 days of these orders;(a)      

the respondent’s written submissions (not exceeding five pages) to be filed and served within 28 days of these orders; and(b)      

the appellants’ written submissions in reply (not exceeding two pages) to be filed and served within 35 days of these orders.(c)      

CATCHWORDS:

COSTS – WATER ACT – where the appellants were successful in an appeal to the Land Court, but their application for costs was dismissed – whether the learned member erred in failing to find the respondent had engaged in unmeritorious conduct as described in s 882(4) of the Water Act 2000 – where the respondent had resisted the appeal – where the respondent had rejected a Calderbank offer – where there had been maladministration by the respondent of previous water licence applications – where the respondent failed to disclose certain documents – where the respondent had changed expert witnesses in the course of the appeal

COSTS – DISCRETION OF COURT – whether the discretion to order costs, once enlivened, ought to be exercised – consideration of the cost consequences of the respondent’s failure to properly discharge its responsibilities in the appeal – whether costs should be awarded on the indemnity basis

District Court of Queensland Act 1967
Judicature Act 1873 (UK)
Land Court Act 2000 (Qld) s 34, s 27
Local Government (Planning and Environment) Act 1990
Water Act 2000 (Qld) s 35, s 210, s 880(2), s 882

Calderbank v Calderbank [1976] 3 All ER 333 applied
Chrismel v Department of Natural Resources and Mines [2005] 26 QLCR 87, distinguished
Colgate Palmolive Co & Anor v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 118 ALR 248, applied
De Tournouer v Chief Executive, Department of Natural Resources and Water (2008) QLC 0151
De Tournouer v Chief Executive Dept. of Environment and Resource Management [2011] 1 Qd R 200, considered
Fraser Property Developments Pty Ltd v Sommerfeld (No 1)

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Williams v Department of Environment and Resource Management and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] QLAC 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Williams v Department of Environment and Resource Management, the appellants, Williams and others, appealed against the decisions of the Department of Environment and Resource Management, which had denied their applications for water licences. The Land Court had previously dismissed the Department’s application for review of the appellants’ appeal. The appellants were successful in their appeal but had their application for costs dismissed. They sought to appeal the decision on the basis of the Department’s unmeritorious conduct and the court’s discretion in awarding costs.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Department had engaged in unmeritorious conduct as described in section 882(4) of the Water Act 2000, and whether the court should exercise its discretion to order costs, particularly on an indemnity basis. The appellants argued that the Department had acted unreasonably by resisting the appeal, rejecting a Calderbank offer, and engaging in maladministration of previous water licence applications. They also contended that the Department had failed to disclose certain documents and changed expert witnesses during the course of the appeal.

The court found that the Department had indeed engaged in unmeritorious conduct by resisting the appeal despite the overwhelming evidence supporting the appellants' case, rejecting a Calderbank offer, and by maladministration of previous water licence applications. The court held that the Department's failure to disclose certain documents and changing expert witnesses further supported the finding of unmeritorious conduct. Given these findings, the court exercised its discretion to order costs, awarding 70 per cent of the appellants' costs on the indemnity basis. This decision recognised the significant cost consequences of the Department’s failure to properly discharge its responsibilities in the appeal.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal was allowed, the order below was set aside, and the Department was required to pay 70 per cent of the appellants' costs of the appeal on the indemnity basis. Written submissions regarding the costs of the appeal were to be filed and served within specific timeframes as outlined in the orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

The appeal is allowed.1.

The order below is set aside.2.

The respondent pay 70 per cent of the appellants’ costs of the appeal to the Land Court from and including 23 June 2008 on the indemnity basis.3.

Submissions as to the costs of this appeal shall be in writing with:4.

the appellants’ written submissions (not exceeding five pages) to be filed and served within 21 days of these orders;(a)

the respondent’s written submissions (not exceeding five pages) to be filed and served within 28 days of these orders; and(b)

the appellants’ written submissions in reply (not exceeding two pages) to be filed and served within 35 days of these orders.(c)

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 6 September 2007 the respondent sent a letter to the appellants’ solicitors in respect of their appeal, and that of the Gallos and Cowies, stating in respect of those appeals:“I confirm that Mr Lait of Australasian Groundwater and Environmental Consultants Pty Ltd (“AGE”) has been retained to give evidence for the chief executive in the three appeals listed above, as well as those appeals brought on behalf of John and Maria Gallo and on behalf of Ms Margaret De Tourneour. The outcome of Mr Lait’s investigations will also be used in the broader water resource planning process in the Barron Catchment.”[32] (emphasis added)[32]Vol 7 p1439. The letter went on to mention that Mr Hair, hydrologist, retained to give evidence on behalf of Ms De Tournouer, had agreed Mr Lait’s proposed tests would be useful. The letter again sought access to the Gallo property to conduct the bore pump tests sought by Mr Lait.[33] [33]Vol 7 pp1439-1440. On 13 September 2007 the Land Court ordered in respect of the appellants’ appeal, as well as that of the Gallos and Cowies:“(1)The hearing of these appeals is deferred pending the conduct of bore pump tests on Bore 109245, and other bores if agreed between the experts retained by each party, along with associated monitoring of the effects of these tests.(2)The chief executive will make the results of the tests conducted on RN109245, RN109627, RN109380 and any other bores agreed between the experts available to the appellants 7 calendar days after the test conducted on each bore is completed.(3)The parties make disclosure of all relevant documents by list of documents on or before 22 October 2007.(4)The parties inspect disclosed documents on or before 5 November 2007. …”[34] (emphasis added) On 27 February 2008 the appellants’ solicitors wrote to the respondent, again in respect of all three appeals, enclosing correspondence from Gilbert and Sutherland Agricultural and Environmental Scientists. It was noted those consultants had had the opportunity to review the evidence prepared by Mr Lait and Mr Hair for the purpose of the De Tournouer appeal. The attached correspondence from Gilbert and Sutherland said, inter alia:“We have now had the benefit of the reports of two experts who have prepared groundwater allocation reviews for both the department and another landholder in the immediate locale, Mrs Margaret De Tournouer. A critical point of agreement between these two experts is the apparent lack of connectivity between the local creeks and the deep underlying basalt aquifer, also known as the Quincan aquifer.”[35][35]Vol 7 p1447. The consultants noted the generally common ground view of the experts that there was no interconnectivity between the aquifer and streams and creeks saying:“This represents a threshold point. Both experts accept there is limited or no connection between the aquifer and the surrounding creeks. The Department’s current allocation of water within the catchment has taken into account a requirement for environmental flows in surrounding creeks, and considers an allocation for agricultural and other uses outside of the catchment. As there is limited or no connection, these matters should not properly be taken into account. For this reason, groundwater drawdown will only affect the groundwater users within this catchment and a detailed statement of evidence from Mr Neil Sutherland at this stage would be superfluous based on the agreement of those experts.”[36] (emphasis added)

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established