Whap v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Whap v Commissioner of Police [2023] QDC 128

PARTIES:

MAITUI ANAU WHAP

(appellant)

v
COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

26/23

DIVISION:

Appellate

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Magistrates Court, Cairns

DELIVERED ON:

24 May 2023

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

28 April 2023

JUDGE:

Dearden DCJ

ORDER:

1.   Application for leave to appeal out of time granted;

2.   Appeal granted;

3.   Vacate the parole eligibility date of 17/02/23 imposed at the Cairns Magistrate Court on 17/02/23 in respect of Charges 1-6;

4.   Vacate parole release date of 02/12/22 imposed at the Cairns Magistrates Court on 02/12/22 in respect of Charges 1-6;

5.   Vacate the sentence of 3 months imprisonment imposed on Charge 3 – Sexual Assault on 02/12/22 at Cairns Magistrates Court;

6.   Substitute it for an order of 9 months’ probation, commencing on 24/05/23 in respect of Charge 3 – Sexual Assault:-

Probation order
s.92(1)(a) Penalties and Sentences Act 1992
Conviction recorded
Order that the offender be released under the supervision of an authorised corrective services officer for a period of 9 months, effectively commencing on 24/05/23, and must comply with the requirements set out in Section 93(1) of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 and report within 2 business days from 24/05/23 to an authorised corrective services officer at Cairns; and

7.   Order for suspended sentence

s 144 Penalties and Sentences Act 1992
Conviction recorded
Order that the whole terms of imprisonment imposed in respect of Charges 1,2,4,5 & 6 at Cairns Magistrates Court on 02/12/22 be wholly suspended forthwith; and defendant must not commit another offence punishable by imprisonment within a period of 12 months, effective from 24/05/23 if the defendant is to avoid being dealt with for the suspended term of imprisonment.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE – SENTENCE MANIFESTLY EXCESSIVE OR INADEQUATE – ERROR AT LAW – where a parole release date was imposed on sexual offences – where on the reopening of the proceeding the learned magistrate imposed a parole eligibility date – where the learned magistrate sentenced the appellant to imprisonment in his absence whether the learned magistrate failed to accord procedural fairness

LEGISLATION:

Corrective Services Act 2006 (Qld)

Justices Act 1886 (Qld) s 222

Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld) ss 160, 160D, 188

CASES:

Bawden v ACI Operations Pty Ltd [2003] QCA 293

R v Cunningham [2005] QCA 321

Dempsey Project Pty Ltd v Perpetual Corporate Trust Limited [2019] QCA 234

EH v QPS; GS v QPS [2020] QDC 205

R v Hyatt [2011] QCA 55

Maxwell v Keun [1928] 1 KB 645

Millar v Commissioner of Police [2022] QDC 254

R v Rollason [2009] QCA 157

Sali v SPC Ltd (1993) 116 ALR 625

COUNSEL:

R Logan for the appellant
T Watkins (sol) for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Fisher Dore Lawyers for the appellant
Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions for the respondent

Background

  1. On 2 December 2022 the appellant, Maitui Anau Whap, was sentenced at the Cairns Magistrates Court in respect of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Whap v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QDC 128
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Whap v Commissioner of Police, the appellant, Maitui Anau Whap, appealed against the sentence imposed by the learned magistrate at the Cairns Magistrates Court. The appellant challenged the sentence on the grounds that the learned magistrate failed to accord procedural fairness and erred at law in various respects, including by not taking into account relevant considerations and not providing adequate reasons for the decision.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the learned magistrate erred in not considering the appellant’s performance on parole, in failing to provide adequate reasons for the sentencing decision, and in unduly fettering her sentencing discretion by not considering all available sentencing options. The court found that the learned magistrate's failure to take into account the appellant's parole performance and to provide adequate reasons amounted to errors of law. Furthermore, the learned magistrate had not considered all available sentencing options, which resulted in an undue limitation of her discretion.

The court held that due to the identified errors, the sentence imposed on 17 February 2023 should be set aside. After considering submissions and with the appellant present, the court resentenced the appellant, substituting the original sentence with an order of 9 months’ probation for the charge of sexual assault, commencing on 24 May 2023. Additionally, the court ordered that the terms of imprisonment imposed for other charges be wholly suspended, with the condition that the appellant must not commit another offence punishable by imprisonment within 12 months to avoid the suspended term being enforced.

The final orders made by the court included granting the appellant leave to appeal out of time, vacating the original parole eligibility and release dates, vacating the sentence of 3 months imprisonment for the sexual assault charge, and imposing a new sentence of 9 months’ probation for the same charge. The terms of imprisonment for other charges were to be wholly suspended, subject to the appellant not committing another imprisonable offence within 12 months.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Application for leave to appeal out of time granted;

2. Appeal granted;

3. Vacate the parole eligibility date of 17/02/23 imposed at the Cairns Magistrate Court on 17/02/23 in respect of Charges 1-6;

4. Vacate parole release date of 02/12/22 imposed at the Cairns Magistrates Court on 02/12/22 in respect of Charges 1-6;

5. Vacate the sentence of 3 months imprisonment imposed on Charge 3 – Sexual Assault on 02/12/22 at Cairns Magistrates Court;

6. Substitute it for an order of 9 months’ probation, commencing on 24/05/23 in respect of Charge 3 – Sexual Assault:-

Probation order

s.92(1)(a) Penalties and Sentences Act 1992

Conviction recorded

Order that the offender be released under the supervision of an authorised corrective services officer for a period of 9 months, effectively commencing on 24/05/23, and must comply with the requirements set out in Section 93(1) of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 and report within 2 business days from 24/05/23 to an authorised corrective services officer at Cairns; and

7. Order for suspended sentence

s 144 Penalties and Sentences Act 1992

Conviction recorded

Order that the whole terms of imprisonment imposed in respect of Charges 1,2,4,5 & 6 at Cairns Magistrates Court on 02/12/22 be wholly suspended forthwith; and defendant must not commit another offence punishable by imprisonment within a period of 12 months, effective from 24/05/23 if the defendant is to avoid being dealt with for the suspended term of imprisonment.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The appellant identifies that between the sentence date (2 December, 2022) and the reopening hearing (17 February, 2023), the appellant had been on parole for 77 days. The appellant himself in his affidavit[18] opined that he was doing well on parole. It would have been a straightforward exercise for the learned magistrate to have obtained either a written or oral report as to the appellant’s performance on parole, and in that respect, it would have been appropriate to adjourn the reopening hearing pending obtaining such a report. The failure to take into account the performance by the appellant on parole, which would have informed the learned magistrate as to the progress of the appellant’s rehabilitation on parole, is an error, given the obvious relevance of a parole supervision report to the reopening process. Error 6 – did the learned magistrate err at law by failing to provide adequate reasons for her decision.[18]Appeal Ex. 2 - Affidavit of Maitui Anau Whap sworn 26 April 2023, [13]. As the appellant identifies, it is well established that there is a duty on the part of judicial tribunals to give reasons for their decisions, and failure to give reasons which ought to have been given can amount to an appellable error.[19] It is also clear that sentencing remarks are required not only to communicate with the offender, the victim and the public, but should be “able to withstand the scrutiny of appellate courts”, and a “sentencing court may more easily infer error when reasons are not expressed.”[20][19]Bawden v ACI Operations Pty Ltd [2003] QCA 293, [29].[20]R v Hyatt [2011] QCA 55, [11] (per Wilson AJA). With respect, the learned magistrate’s reasons for the imposition of the parole eligibility date (without identification of and consideration of the alternatives which were clearly open and available) represented an error in the circumstances of this matter. In the light of the view this court takes on appeal in respect of the errors identified above, it is clear that the sentence imposed by way of reopening on 17 February 2023 should be set aside and the appellant sentenced afresh. After hearing submissions on that resentence, and with the appellant being present for the process, I made the orders set out at [9], above. However, in the Further Outline of Submissions on behalf of the Appellant,[21] the appellant, relying on Hemmett v Commissioner of Police [2021] QDC 318, [20] – [21] and Gallaher v Commissioner of Queensland Police Service [2014] QDC 26, [31], submits that the orders made on 28 April , 2023 (see [9] above) should be varied, so as to operate from the date of delivery of these further reasons, and adjusted to practically reflect the delay between those orders and the delivery of these further reasons. The respondent does not oppose that course. [21] Appeal Ex. 4 – Further Outline of Submissions on behalf of the Appellant. Accordingly, I make the following amended orders, which substitute for the orders set out at [9] above made on 28 April, 2023:- 1. Application for leave to appeal out of time granted;2. Appeal granted; 3. Vacate the parole eligibility date of 17/02/23 imposed at the Cairns Magistrate Court on 17/02/23 in respect of Charges 1-6;4. Vacate parole release date of 02/12/22 imposed at the Cairns Magistrates Court on 02/12/22 in respect of Charges 1-6;5. Vacate the sentence of 3 months imprisonment imposed on Charge 3 – Sexual Assault on 02/12/22 at Cairns Magistrates Court;6. Substitute it for an order of 9 months’ probation, commencing on 24/05/23 in respect of Charge 3 – Sexual Assault: Probation orders.92(1)(a) Penalties and Sentences Act 1992Conviction recordedOrder that the offender be released under the supervision of an authorised corrective services officer for a period of 9 months, effectively commencing on 24/05/23, and must comply with the requirements set out in Section 93(1) of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 and report within 2 business days from 24/05/23 to an authorised corrective services officer at Cairns; and

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It was clear that at the original sentence, and on the reopening, it was open to the learned magistrate to partly or fully suspend all prison sentences imposed; to partly or fully suspend all but one of the prison sentences and impose a probation order on one of the charges; to place a parole release date on the non-sexual offences (charges 1 and 2) and fully or partly suspend the four sexual assault charges; or impose (with the appellant’s consent) an intensive correction order in respect of all or some of the offences. With all of those options available (subject, of course, where appropriate to the appellant’s consent and to an assessment of the utility and appropriateness of each of those options), it is clear that the learned magistrate has fallen into error by unduly fettering her sentencing discretion.Error 5 - did the learned magistrate err at law by failing to take into account a relevant consideration, namely how the appellant had been performing on parole. The appellant identifies that between the sentence date (2 December, 2022) and the reopening hearing (17 February, 2023), the appellant had been on parole for 77 days. The appellant himself in his affidavit[18] opined that he was doing well on parole. It would have been a straightforward exercise for the learned magistrate to have obtained either a written or oral report as to the appellant’s performance on parole, and in that respect, it would have been appropriate to adjourn the reopening hearing pending obtaining such a report. The failure to take into account the performance by the appellant on parole, which would have informed the learned magistrate as to the progress of the appellant’s rehabilitation on parole, is an error, given the obvious relevance of a parole supervision report to the reopening process. Error 6 – did the learned magistrate err at law by failing to provide adequate reasons for her decision.[18]Appeal Ex. 2 - Affidavit of Maitui Anau Whap sworn 26 April 2023, [13]. As the appellant identifies, it is well established that there is a duty on the part of judicial tribunals to give reasons for their decisions, and failure to give reasons which ought to have been given can amount to an appellable error.[19] It is also clear that sentencing remarks are required not only to communicate with the offender, the victim and the public, but should be “able to withstand the scrutiny of appellate courts”, and a “sentencing court may more easily infer error when reasons are not expressed.”[20][19]Bawden v ACI Operations Pty Ltd [2003] QCA 293, [29].[20]R v Hyatt [2011] QCA 55, [11] (per Wilson AJA). With respect, the learned magistrate’s reasons for the imposition of the parole eligibility date (without identification of and consideration of the alternatives which were clearly open and available) represented an error in the circumstances of this matter. In the light of the view this court takes on appeal in respect of the errors identified above, it is clear that the sentence imposed by way of reopening on 17 February 2023 should be set aside and the appellant sentenced afresh. After hearing submissions on that resentence, and with the appellant being present for the process, I made the orders set out at [9], above.