Millar v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Millar v Commissioner of Police [2022] QDC 254

PARTIES:

ANDREW JOHN MILLAR

(appellant)

v
COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

1577/2022

DIVISION:

Criminal

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Brisbane Magistrates Court

DELIVERED ON:

25 November 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

3 August 2022; 14 October 2022; further written submissions from appellant and from respondent

JUDGES:

Dearden DCJ

ORDER:

1.   Appeal granted.

2.   Convictions in respect of enter premises with intent, and stealing after previous conviction, set aside.

3.   Remit to the Brisbane Magistrate’s Court for retrial.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – PARTICULAR GROUNDS OF APPEAL – MISDIRECTION AND NON-DIRECTION – where the learned magistrate conducted a judge alone trial – where the appellant was convicted of one count of entering premises with intent to commit an indictable offence – where the appellant was convicted of one count of stealing – where the learned magistrate erred  by failing to direct themself on identification – where the learned magistrate erred  by failing to direct themself on circumstantial evidence – where the learned magistrate erred  by reversing the onus of proof

CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE – GROUNDS FOR INTERFERENCE – OTHER MATTERS – where the appellant was convicted of one count of entering premises with intent to commit an indictable offence – where the appellant was convicted of one count of stealing – where the appellant was sentenced to eight months imprisonment with a parole release date of 20 November 2022

COUNSEL:

The appellant appeared self-represented
R Byrne for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

The appellant appeared self-represented
Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions for the respondent

Introduction

  1. The appellant, Andrew John Millar, was convicted before the learned magistrate at Brisbane on 1 July 2022 of one count of entering premises with intent to commit an indictable offence (27/5/2019) and one count of stealing (27/5/2019) after previous conviction.[1]  Sentence proceedings were adjourned, and on 21 July 2022, the appellant was sentenced to eight months imprisonment with a parole release date set at 20 November 2022 (50% of the head sentence).[2]

    [1]Decision 1-6 ll 8-14 (1 June).

    [2]Sentencing decision 1-3 ll 1-3.

  2. The appellant’s appeal against conviction and sentence was heard by me on 3 August 2022.

    Grounds of appeal

  3. The applicant’s original notice of appeal filed 4 July 2022, set out eight “grounds” of appeal,[3] and in an amended ground of appeal added two further “grounds”.

    [3]Notice of appeal filed 4 July 2022.

  4. After the hearing of the appeal before me on 3 August 2022, with the decision reserved, the appeal was relisted for further hearing on 2 September 2022, given what appeared to be further potential grounds of appeal.  These grounds were articulated as follows:

    (a)That the learned magistrate erred by failing to direct himself on identification;

    (b)The learned magistrate erred by failing to direct himself on circumstantial evidence; and

    (c)The learned magistrate erred by reversing the onus of proof.

  5. Further submissions were filed by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Millar v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QDC 254
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Millar v Commissioner of Police, the appellant was convicted by a magistrate of one count of entering premises with intent to commit an indictable offence and one count of stealing, and sentenced to eight months imprisonment with a parole release date of 20 November 2022. The appellant appealed against both his conviction and sentence. The appeal was allowed, the convictions set aside, and the matter remitted for a retrial. The grounds of appeal included the magistrate's failure to direct themself on identification, failure to direct themself on circumstantial evidence, and reversal of the onus of proof. The court held that these errors were significant and affected the safety of the conviction.

The appellant's principal grounds of appeal were that the magistrate erred by failing to direct themself on identification, failed to direct themself on circumstantial evidence, and reversed the onus of proof. The court held that the magistrate's failure to direct themself on identification and circumstantial evidence were significant errors, as they went to the heart of the case. The court also held that the magistrate's reversal of the onus of proof was a serious error, as it undermined the fundamental principle of criminal law that the prosecution bears the onus of proving guilt beyond reasonable doubt. These errors affected the safety of the conviction, and the appeal was allowed.

The court allowed the appeal, set aside the convictions, and remitted the matter to the Brisbane Magistrates Court for a retrial. The court held that the magistrate's errors were significant and affected the safety of the conviction. The court noted that the appellant was not able to call any evidence in response to the complainant's evidence, and that the magistrate's errors went to the heart of the case. The court held that the magistrate's failure to direct themself on identification and circumstantial evidence were significant errors, and that the magistrate's reversal of the onus of proof was a serious error that undermined the fundamental principle of criminal law. The appeal was allowed, the convictions set aside, and the matter remitted for a retrial.

No further orders were made. The court held that the appellant's appeal was well-founded and that the convictions should be set aside. The court remitted the matter to the Brisbane Magistrates Court for a retrial, and did not make any further orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal granted.

2. Convictions in respect of enter premises with intent, and stealing after previous conviction, set aside.

3. Remit to the Brisbane Magistrate’s Court for retrial.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It is useful then to consider the further grounds of appeal filed (by consent) on 14 October 2022.(a) That there was a failure by the Magistrate to direct himself on the identification evidence. Although evidence at the trial was given by the complainant, Kenneth Edward Quimby as well as Senior Constable Claire Nester and Detective Sergeant Gerard McCarthy (with the appellant choosing neither to call evidence as was his right) the key issues in the trial were two-fold, namely:(1)Was the appellant, Mr Millar, identified by Mr Quimby as the person Mr Quimby located 200 metres from the entry to the unit complex attempting to load Mr Quimby’s bike into the back of his vehicle, the same male person seen by Mr Quimby when he returned from his appointment trying to ride away on a bicycle at the front of his unit which looked similar to Mr Quimby’s bicycle? (2)Given that there was no eyewitness evidence, CCTV footage or other forensic evidence that the appellant entered the secure garage area of the unit complex where Mr Quimby resides and from where Mr Quimby’s bicycle was taken, has the learned magistrate correctly directed himself in respect of the circumstantial evidence in this trial. Relevantly, in respect of the evidence of the complainant, the magistrate made findings as follows:-[28]“Regarding the evidence, Mr Quimby gave evidence-in-chief and described his residence, his unit that he was living in at the time as a 10-unit security complex. He described a button or fob on his keyring, which when pushed activates the gate to the garage in his complex. He estimates that the gate takes 10 to 12 seconds to open and a further 10 to 12 seconds to close. Once inside the gate, he and any other person can access his garage space. He leaves his pushbike, a Trek X Caliber 7, as shown in photographs in Exhibit 1, in his garage space, freestanding against the wall.On the morning of the 27th May 2019, he left the complex in his car with his young daughter to take her to a medical appointment. He could not recall the time he left, but believed it was 8.00 or 9.00 am. Mr Quimby states that before he left, his bike was freestanding against his garage wall. Mr Quimby states that the medical appointment was at Arana Hills. He was questioned about the route he took to return to his residence. The route that he took upon his return was marked on a map, which is Exhibit 2. Mr Quimby stated that upon his return, he saw a bike that looked similar to his out the front of his unit near or on the driveway, with a man trying to ride off on it.After opening the security gate and driving into his garage, he realised that his bike was missing and realised that the bike that he had just seen was his. Mr Quimby then left the garage and unit complex in an attempt to find his bike. Mr Quimby stated that he drove around a corner to find a man trying to put his bike into the rear of a car. He estimated that it was approximately 200 metres from his complex when he located his bike. Mr Quimby stated that this was the same person that he had seen on the bike when he had arrived home at his residence. Mr Quimby stated that when he confronted this person, this person said that they found the bike. After Mr Quimby took the bike back, this person ran to his car and drove off. Mr Quimby took photos of this vehicle, as shown in Exhibits 3 and 4.Mr Quimby attended the front counter of the Ferny Grove Police Station a day later, and some days later he was contacted by a police officer from Indooroopilly and asked to come into the station to make a statement. At that time, he participated in a photo-board interview and identified Mr Millar as the man who was on his bike. The photo-board was tendered. That is Exhibit 5.During cross-examination of Mr Quimby, Mr Millar questioned him at length, at great length, about the photos of Mr Quimby’s bike, which police officer he first made contact with and the route that he took on his return from the doctors to his unit. Mr Quimby was further questioned at length regarding his turning into his complex and what he saw at that stage. Mr Millar in the absence of Mr Quimby stated that he knew ‘for a fact that he’ referring to Mr Quimby, ‘has lied’. Mr Millar stated that it was ‘to do with this detective’, and that is referring to Detective McCarthy, who has ‘a very particular history’ with Mr Millar. Shortly after this and still in the absence of Mr Quimby, Mr Millar stated that the complainant had ‘lied to stich me up’.Mr Millar did not put to Mr Quimby that he was lying. He did, however [ask] Mr Quimby about his interactions with Detective McCarthy and whether there were ‘a lot of negative comments about Mr Millar from Detective McCarthy’. Mr Quimby responded that he could not recall his conversations with Detective McCarthy from three years ago. It was put to Mr Quimby that he did not initially intend to make a complaint to police. Mr Quimby’s answer to this was ‘why would I have contacted police if that was the case?’”[28]Decision 1-3, ll 32-1-4, l 38.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established