Dempsey Project Pty Ltd v Perpetual Corporate Trust Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Dempsey Project Pty Ltd & Ors v Perpetual Corporate Trust Limited [2019] QCA 234

PARTIES:

DEMPSEY PROJECT PTY LTD
ACN 616 215 073
(first appellant)
DEMPSEY PROFITS PTY LTD
ACN 167 045 427
(second appellant)
JEFFREY RAYMOND WALTERS
(third appellant)
ANDREW KARL SHOFAY
(fourth appellant)
v
PERPETUAL CORPORATE TRUST LIMITED
ACN 000 341 533
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 4305 of 2019
SC No 1102 of 2019

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane – Unreported, 18 April 2019 (Dalton J)

DELIVERED ON:

29 October 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

26 August 2019

JUDGES:

Sofronoff P and Gotterson JA and Flanagan J

ORDERS:

1.   Appeal dismissed.

2.   The appellants are to pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal to be assessed on the indemnity basis.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – INTERFERENCE WITH DISCRETION OF COURT BELOW – IN GENERAL – PARTICULAR CASES – CONTROL OVER PROCEEDINGS – ADMISSION OF EVIDENCE – where the respondent commenced proceedings against the appellants to recover money owed by the appellants under a loan agreement and written guarantees and to recover possession of a property mortgaged to them – where the respondent succeeded in obtaining summary judgment against the appellants – where the appellants contended on appeal that the learned primary judge erred in admitting an affidavit of the respondent which annexed true copies of the security agreements and the registered mortgage – whether the learned primary judge erred in admitting the affidavit

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – INTERFERENCE WITH DISCRETION OF COURT BELOW – IN GENERAL – PARTICULAR CASES – CONTROL OVER PROCEEDINGS – REFUSAL OF ADJOURNMENT – where the respondent commenced proceedings against the appellants to recover money owed by the appellants under a loan agreement and written guarantees and to recover possession of a property mortgaged to them – where the respondent applied for summary judgment against the appellants – where, at the beginning of the hearing of the summary judgment application, counsel for the appellants sought an adjournment to allow them time to obtain further evidence and to amend their pleadings in accordance with the further evidence – where the learned primary judge refused the application – whether the refusal to grant a short adjournment denied justice to the appellants and materially prejudiced them in resisting the application

Hanson Construction Materials Pty Ltd v Davey & Anor [2010] 79 ACSR 668; [2010] QCA 246, distinguished
Maxwell v Keun
[1928] 1 KB 645, considered

COUNSEL:

A P J Collins for the appellants
M D Martin QC for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Tonio Lawyers for the appellants
Mills Oakley for the respondent

  1. SOFRONOFF P:  I agree with Gotterson JA.

  2. GOTTERSON JA:  Perpetual Corporate Trust Limited (“PCTL”) is a Custodian for certain funds managed by GPS Investment Fund Limited (“GPS”).  Dempsey Profits Pty Ltd (“Profits”) is the trustee for the Dempsey Profits Trust and for the Walters Family…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dempsey Project Pty Ltd v Perpetual Corporate Trust Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCA 234
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dempsey Project Pty Ltd, the appellant, sought to appeal against a decision of the primary judge of the Supreme Court of Queensland who had dismissed its application to set aside a summary judgment in favour of Perpetual Corporate Trust Limited, the respondent. The primary judge had also dismissed the appellant's application for an adjournment to allow it to obtain further evidence and to amend its pleadings. The appellant argued that the primary judge had erred in admitting an affidavit of the respondent and in refusing to adjourn the hearing of the summary judgment application. The appeal raised questions about the admission of evidence and the exercise of judicial discretion in relation to adjournments.

The court examined the primary judge's decision to admit the affidavit of the respondent. The affidavit contained details of the security agreements and the registered mortgage. The court held that the primary judge had not erred in admitting the affidavit as it provided additional information that was relevant to the application for summary judgment. The court also considered the primary judge's decision to refuse the adjournment. The appellant had argued that the late service of the affidavit and the amended statement of claim had prejudiced it. However, the court found that the primary judge had correctly exercised her discretion in refusing the adjournment, as the appellant had failed to provide a meritorious reason for the adjournment.

The court dismissed the appeal and ordered the appellant to pay the respondent's costs of the appeal on an indemnity basis. The court held that the primary judge had not erred in admitting the affidavit or in refusing the adjournment. The court found that the primary judge had correctly exercised her discretion in relation to the adjournment and that the appellant had failed to demonstrate any prejudice caused by the late service of the affidavit or the amended statement of claim.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal be dismissed and that the appellant pay the respondent's costs of the appeal on an indemnity basis. The court held that the primary judge had correctly exercised her discretion in relation to the adjournment and that the appellant had failed to demonstrate any prejudice caused by the late service of the affidavit or the amended statement of claim. The court found that the primary judge had not erred in admitting the affidavit and that the appeal was without merit.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal dismissed.

2. The appellants are to pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal to be assessed on the indemnity basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Perpetual Corporate Trust Limited (PCTL) commenced proceedings against Dempsey Project Pty Ltd (Dempsey) to recover money owed under a loan agreement and written guarantees, as well as to recover possession of a property mortgaged to Dempsey. PCTL filed an application for summary judgment on 2 April 2019 and served it on the same day. This application was listed for hearing on 18 April 2019. PCTL filed several affidavits to support the application, including affidavits sworn by Mr J Hoare, PCTL's Portfolio Manager, on 15 April 2019 and 18 April 2019. At the beginning of the hearing of the summary judgment application, counsel for Dempsey sought an adjournment to allow them time to obtain further evidence and to amend their pleadings in accordance with the further evidence. The learned primary judge refused the application for an adjournment and granted summary judgment in favour of PCTL.

This matter arose from proceedings originally filed by PCTL in the Supreme Court of New South Wales seeking recovery of money owed under a loan agreement and written guarantees, as well as possession of a property mortgaged to Dempsey. PCTL applied for summary judgment and served the application on 2 April 2019. The application was listed for hearing on 18 April 2019. At the beginning of the hearing, Dempsey's counsel sought an adjournment to allow them time to obtain further evidence and to amend their pleadings in accordance with the further evidence. The learned primary judge refused the application for an adjournment and granted summary judgment in favour of PCTL. Dempsey appealed the decision of the learned primary judge and the appeal came before the Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

A Reply and Answer was filed on 28 March 2019[22] in which clause 8(k) of the GPS Commercial Loan Terms was pleaded. It provided that Project was to make payments due under the Loan Agreement “in cleared funds and free of any set-off or deduction”.[23] A provision to similar effect in clause 5.2 of the Deeds of Guarantee and Indemnity was also pleaded.[24][22]AB 1 25-27 subsequently amended on 5 April 2019: AB 1 28-30.[23]Ibid paragraph 10.[24]Ibid paragraph 13.The summary judgment application and the hearing PCTL filed and served an application for summary judgment on 2 April 2019.[25] It was listed for hearing on 18 April 2019. PCTL also filed and served a number of affidavits for the purpose of proving the factual matters alleged in its Statement of Claim.[25]AB 2 55-56. The application came on for hearing before a judge of the Trial Division on 18 April 2019. At the commencement of the hearing counsel for the four defendants indicated that his clients were applying for an adjournment.[26] He filed and read by leave an affidavit sworn by Mr F Dzelalija, solicitor, in support of that application.[27] It was received without objection.[26]Transcript 1-2 ll9-10: AB 2 520.[27]AB 2 510-512. Counsel advanced a number of arguments for the adjournment. One of them related to two affidavits sworn by Mr J Hoare, PCTL’s Portfolio Manager, sworn respectively on 15 April 2019[28] and 18 April 2019,[29] which the defendants complained had been served less than eight business days before the hearing, thus short of the period stipulated by UCPR r 296(1) for the filing and serving of an applicant’s material. A second argument was that PCTL had amended its statement of claim, the amended pleading having been served on 8 April 2018, some seven business days before the day of the hearing. Thirdly, reliance was placed on statements by Mr Dzelalija in his affidavit that he was seeking counsel’s advice on filing an amended defence and counterclaim and that preparation of draft affidavits to resist the summary judgment application was substantially advanced. Mr Dzelalija referred to grounds for defending and counterclaiming which, in substance, mirrored those that had already been pleaded.[28]AB 2 451-497.[29]AB 2 504-506. The learned primary judge granted leave for the filing and reading of this affidavit notwithstanding the respondents’ objection: Transcript 1-2 l47. The learned primary judge refused the application for an adjournment. In reasons given ex tempore, her Honour said:“Well, I refuse the application for an adjournment. The basis upon which it was sought was, in my view, quite unmeritorious. This application was filed and served on the 2nd of April 2018. The substantive affidavit material was served that day. Another affidavit was filed shortly thereafter, and no complaint was made, but it is late. After that, two affidavits of Mr Hoare were filed and served; one three days ago, and one with leave this morning. The affidavit with leave this morning could not properly have been the subject of complaint, in my view. It is the kind of affidavit that every lender makes on an application such as this, simply giving the judge the up to date amount of monies owing at the time the lender seeks judgment from the court. That leaves the affidavit which is court document 14. It is a document which has six substantive paragraphs. And it simply adds some more details to what has already been sworn.There was nothing in particular about it that was argued to cause the defendants any particular difficulties. And in circumstances where there’s been absolutely no attempt to file a proper defence, file affidavits on this application or explain the reason for not doing so, I really do not think there is any meritorious point at all in the complaint that this affidavit was served late. Rule [296] is, in its terms, mandatory and it has, in my view, most substantially been complied with. And I’d excuse anything else as an irregularity under the rules. The last point was that 13 days ago, a statement of claim – an amended statement of claim was filed and served.The point is taken that because it was served after 4 o’clock in the afternoon, in fact, it was deemed to be served at a time when there have only been seven clear business days between that service and now. It, again, is a most unmeritorious argument in circumstances where the defendant respondents are aware that a summary judgment application has been made to rely on technical points, such as service being effected after 4 o’clock in the afternoon, really are the type of points made by defendants without any substantive defence. So in – for all of those reasons, I refuse the adjournment.”[30][30]Transcript 1-9 l29 – 1-10 l11.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining whether the learned primary judge erred in admitting the affidavit of the respondent which annexed true copies of the security agreements and the registered mortgage. The appellants argued that the affidavit was not properly served and thus should not have been admitted. The court noted that while the affidavit was served shortly before the hearing, the appellants had not demonstrated how this affected their ability to prepare a defence. The court held that the service complied substantially with the mandatory requirements of the rules and that any non-compliance was not significant enough to warrant an adjournment. The court also found the arguments regarding the late service of the affidavit to be unmeritorious.

Next, the court assessed whether the refusal to grant a short adjournment denied justice to the appellants and materially prejudiced them in resisting the application. The appellants had sought an adjournment to obtain further evidence and amend their pleadings. The learned primary judge denied the adjournment, finding the application unmeritorious. The court reviewed the reasons provided by the learned primary judge and found that the refusal to adjourn did not prejudice the appellants. The court noted that the appellants had not filed a proper defence or affidavits to support their case and that their reliance on procedural points without substantive defence was unmeritorious. Therefore, the court held that the refusal to grant an adjournment did not constitute a denial of justice.