Westgyp Pty Ltd v Northline Ceilings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

CITATION:   WESTGYP PTY LTD -v- NORTHLINE CEILINGS PTY LTD  [2018] WASC 244

CORAM:   VAUGHAN J

HEARD:   11 - 13 JUNE 2018

DELIVERED          :   15 AUGUST 2018

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2552 of 2016

BETWEEN:   WESTGYP PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

NORTHLINE CEILINGS PTY LTD

First Defendant

GIUSEPPE CRUPI

Second Defendant


Catchwords:

Contract law - Whether contract formed - Contractual construction - Whether director personally liable for company debt

Competition and consumer law - Misleading and deceptive conduct - Australian Consumer Law s 18 - Whether representation made

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), sch 2

Result:

Action dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff : M Curwood
First Defendant : No appearance
Second Defendant : A P Hershowitz

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : J King Legal
First Defendant : No appearance
Second Defendant : Forbes Kirby Lawyers

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd v Manasseh [2016] WASCA 41

Black Box Control Pty Ltd v Terravision Pty Ltd [2016] WASCA 291

Bradshaw v McEwans Pty Ltd (1951) 217 ALR 1

Brambles Holdings Ltd v Bathurst City Council [2001] NSWCA 61; (2001) 53 NSWLR 153

Briginshaw v Briginshaw [1938] HCA 34; (1938) 60 CLR 336

Brogden v Metropolitan Railway Co (1877) 2 App Cas 666

Campbell v Backoffice Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 25; (2009) 238 CLR 304

Clark Equipment Credit of Australia Ltd v Kiyose Holdings Pty Ltd (1989) 21 NSWLR 160

Coast Reo Pty Ltd v O'Brien [2006] NSWSC 1098

Crane Distribution Ltd v Yang [2016] NSWSC 620

EDWF Holdings 1 Pty Ltd v EDWF Holdings 2 Pty Ltd [2010] WASCA 78; (2010) 41 WAR 23

Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd [2014] HCA 7; (2014) 251 CLR 640

Empirnall Holdings Pty Ltd v Machon Paull Partners Pty Ltd (1988) 14 NSWLR 523

Equuscorp Pty Ltd v Glengallan Investments Pty Ltd [2004] HCA 55; (2004) 218 CLR 471

Ermogenous v Greek Orthodox Community of SA Inc [2002] HCA 8; (2002) 209 CLR 95

Fazio v Fazio [2012] WASCA 72

Fox v Percy [2003] HCA 22; (2003) 214 CLR 118

Gestmin SGPS SA v Credit Suisse (UK) Ltd [2013] EWHC 3560 (Comm)

Hendriks v McGeoch [2008] NSWCA 53; (2008) Aust Torts Reports 81‑942

Integrated Computer Services Pty Ltd v Digital Equipment Corp (Aust) Pty Ltd (1988) 5 BPR 11,110

Kriketos v Livschitz [2009] NSWCA 96; (2009) 14 BPR 26,717

Laidlaw v Hillier Hewitt Elsley Pty Ltd [2009] NSWCA 44

McGuiness v Norwich and Peterborough Building Society [2011] EWCA Civ 1286

Meates v Attorney-General [1983] NZLR 308

Miller & Associates Insurance Broking Pty Ltd v BMW Australia Finance Ltd [2010] HCA 31; (2010) 241 CLR 357

Morrison v Town of Victoria Park [2007] WASCA 164

Mount Bruce Mining Pty Ltd v Wright Prospecting Pty Ltd [2015] HCA 37; (2015) 256 CLR 104

Neat Holdings Pty Ltd v Karajan Holdings Pty Ltd [1992] HCA 66; (1992) 110 ALR 449

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Westgyp Pty Ltd v Northline Ceilings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] WASC 244
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Westgyp Pty Ltd commenced legal action against Northline Ceilings Pty Ltd, and subsequently against Joe Crupi, the sole director of Northline Ceilings, for alleged breaches of contract and misleading and deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law. The dispute centred on a credit agreement from 2012, the validity of which was contested by Westgyp, as well as the supply of products to Northline Ceilings that were allegedly on-supplied to another entity, NCCP. The court was required to determine whether a valid contract existed between the parties, whether Mr Crupi was personally liable for the debts of Northline Ceilings, and whether misleading and deceptive conduct had occurred. The court found that the 2012 credit agreement was valid and that Mr Hudston, as the sole director of Westgyp, was not personally liable for the company's debts. Regarding misleading and deceptive conduct, the court found that no representation was made that would constitute such conduct under the Australian Consumer Law. Consequently, Westgyp's action against Mr Crupi was dismissed, and the court ordered Westgyp to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

A detailed account of the facts I turn now to an account of the facts. In doing so I am making factual findings based on the evidence adduced at trial. Where, however, the factual findings are the subject of serious contest, I will defer making factual findings until I specifically address the relevant issue. In particular, Westgyp's contention that the 2012 credit agreement is a fabrication is considered as part of Issue 1; and whether Mr Hudston was informed that supplies to Northline Ceilings were to be on-supplied to NCCP is considered as part of Issue 4. The parties Westgyp is a company.[136][136] Statement of Claim par 1; Defence par 1. Matthew Hudston is Westgyp's sole director. Since about 2006 Westgyp has supplied ceiling and plaster products to the construction industry in Western Australia. Westgyp took over an earlier business commenced in about 2001 which Mr Hudston operated as a sole proprietor. Northline Ceilings was incorporated on 4 July 2006.[137] Joe Crupi was at all times the sole director of Northline Ceilings.[138] Northline Ceilings provided ceiling fixing services. It worked on both commercial and residential projects.[137] Agreed Facts par 1(a).[138] Agreed Facts par 2. NCCP was incorporated on 15 January 2015. At all times Joe Crupi was the sole shareholder of NCCP; Nathan Crupi, Joe Crupi's son, was the sole director of the company.[139] Joe Crupi gave evidence, which I accept as the matter is uncontroversial, that he and Nathan set up NCCP. NCCP was incorporated to establish Nathan Crupi in the construction industry. Once NCCP was stable it was intended that Joe Crupi would retire from the business and Nathan Crupi would run NCCP on his own.[140] Westgyp's supply of product on credit[139] Agreed Facts par 6.[140] Exhibit 16A pars 40 - 41. At all relevant times Westgyp had a credit approval system in place. In 2012 the process for approval of credit applications was that, upon receipt of a completed credit application, a copy of the application was sent to a credit receivable manager, CMSA. CMSA provided a recommendation to Westgyp as to whether the applicant should be approved for credit. CMSA did so having investigated the creditworthiness of the intended customer. The final decision on whether to supply a customer was a matter for Mr Hudston. In 2012 Ms Avni was the director of CMSA who carried out the credit management services for Westgyp. Ms Avni gave evidence as to the process carried out by CMSA on behalf of Westgyp. A system was in place whereby:•on receipt by Westgyp, completed credit applications were sent to CMSA;•CMSA performed a credit check on the applicant and any guarantor ‑ this involved searching any property registered in the relevant names; and•based on the result of the investigation CMSA provided a recommendation as to whether the applicant should be approved for the supply of product on credit. CMSA retained the credit applications which Westgyp had sent it over the years 2009 to 2012. There were some 116 such credit applications.[141] [141] Exhibit 14B par 5.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Approach to evidence There was a substantial contest as to three factual matters. First, as discussed earlier, Westgyp disputed that the 2012 credit application was signed by Mr Crupi and witnessed by Mr Hutton on the date that it bears, being 30 March 2012. Westgyp contended that the document was a fabrication. Second, almost as a counterpoise to the first matter, Mr Crupi contended ‑ albeit in the alternative ‑ that Westgyp had received the 2012 credit application after it was signed but had deliberately disregarded it because the new guarantee had been struck through.[77] Third, there was a dispute about whether Mr Crupi disclosed to Westgyp that orders being made by Northline Ceilings on its credit account with Westgyp were for the benefit of NCCP.[77] ts 23, 25, 26, 68 ‑ 70. The contemporary materials are of some assistance in resolving the second issue. They are, however, of limited assistance as to the first and third issues. There, apart from my views as to the credibility and the reliability of the witnesses, I must predominantly look to the objectively established facts and the apparent logic of events.[78][78] Fox v Percy [2003] HCA 22; (2003) 214 CLR 118 [31]. To the extent that some witnesses gave evidence based on recollection (in at least one case - that of Mr Crupi - as to one critical aspect refreshed 'recollection' that I consider to be reconstruction rather than true recollection) there are the usual difficulties in determining the reliability of the recollection of events which occurred a number of years ago. There is a view that in the trial of a commercial case the best approach in such circumstances is to place little, if any, reliance on witnesses' recollections of what was said in meetings and conversations.[79] I acknowledge the doubt that necessarily attends the recollection of conversations many years in the past.[80] But it does not follow that the correct starting point is to simply place little reliance on oral recollection. Rather, I should assess that evidence in light of its inherent probabilities in the context of the objectively established facts.[79] Gestmin SGPS SA v Credit Suisse (UK) Ltd [2013] EWHC 3560 (Comm) [15] - [22] (especially [22]).[80] See eg Fazio v Fazio [2012] WASCA 72 [42] - [43]. The approach of Black J in Re Swan Services Pty Ltd (in liq)[81] is apposite:In assessing the evidence in this case … I am conscious of the importance of the credit of witnesses where there is, in respect of some issues, inconsistencies in the oral evidence. I also recognise that the credibility of a witness and his or her veracity may be tested by reference to the objective facts proved independently of the testimony given, in particular by reference to the documents in the case, his or her motives and the overall probabilities. I have also had regard to Atkin LJ's observation … that 'an ounce of intrinsic merit or demerit in the evidence, that is to say, the value of the comparison of evidence with known facts, is worth pounds of demeanour'; substantially the same view was taken by Keane JA in Camden v McKenzie [and] by Leeming JA (with whom Barrett JA and Tobias AJA agreed) in New South Wales v Hunt … (citations omitted)[81] Re Swan Services Pty Ltd (in liq)[2016] NSWSC 1724 [6]. See also Re Colorado Products Pty Ltd (in prov liq) [2014] NSWSC 789; (2014) 101 ACSR 233 [10] - [11].

Decision

Reasons for decision

Conclusion and orders Westgyp has failed on the various material issues for determination. I will order that Westgyp's action against Mr Crupi is dismissed. Prima facie, costs should follow the event. However, I will hear from counsel on the precise terms of the costs order. Strictly speaking the caveat proceedings (action CIV 2316 of 2017) are not before me (although the costs of that action are costs in the cause in these proceedings). However, it would be sensible if the parties were to consider what further orders ought to be made in relation to the caveat proceedings having regard to the determination of this action. Following conferral between the parties I will, if necessary, hear any application considered necessary to finally dispose of the caveat proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Elaboration on Issue 1: Westgyp's contention that the 2012 credit agreement was a fabrication[50] Agreed Issues pars 1, 4. [51] Agreed Issues par 5. [52] Agreed Issues par 6.1. [53] Agreed Issues par 6.3. It will not be apparent from my recounting of the parties' pleaded cases that there was a contest between them as to the authenticity of the 2012 credit agreement. But whether the 2012 credit agreement was a fabrication was a central issue at trial. The issue emerged in Westgyp's opening. Having pre-read the witness statements Westgyp intended to rely on, I raised with counsel for Westgyp in his opening whether Westgyp was alleging that the 2012 credit agreement was not executed on or about the date that it bears, ie whether Westgyp was alleging that the 2012 credit agreement was a fabrication.[54] Counsel informed me that his intention was to test the relevant witnesses, Mr Crupi and Mr Hutton, as to the date the document was executed, how it was executed and where it went. It was said, however, that counsel did not have a basis to open the case on the basis that the 2012 credit agreement was a fabrication.[55][54] ts 8, 9.[55] ts 9. I suggested to counsel for Westgyp that this was unsatisfactory: it appeared that Westgyp were trying to have it both ways; and the second defendant ought to know from the opening whether he was facing a case of fabrication.[56] Counsel sought an opportunity to take further instructions.[57] That was provided. At the conclusion of his opening counsel for Westgyp was provided with a 25 minute adjournment to take instructions.[56] ts 9, 10.[57] ts 9. After the adjournment counsel for Westgyp informed me that Westgyp did not accept that the 2012 credit application was signed on 30 March 2012. In answer to my question of whether Westgyp was contending that the document was a fabrication counsel informed me that there was no contention that the signatures were a fabrication, but that it was contended that 2012 credit application was not created on the date that it bears.[58] Essentially, as was later put in the cross‑examination of Mr Crupi,[59] it was Westgyp's case that the 2012 credit application was not signed until mid-2016 (although Mr Hutton was only cross-examined on the basis that he was asked to sign the document on a date later than 30 March 2012).[60][58] ts 22.[59] ts 207, 211.[60] ts 237. At trial I had reservations about whether Westgyp's contention that the 2012 credit application was a fabrication had been adequately disclosed before the commencement of trial. I am unable to identify the contention as having been advanced in Westgyp's written opening submissions. The most that is said appears in par 8 of those submissions:Westgyp's position on issue 2 [equivalent to my Issue 1] is that no contract was made in terms of the 30 March 2012 document. Even if it is found that the 2012 Credit Application came into its possession as alleged by Mr Crupi, Westgyp did not accept the terms of the document, in so far as it purported to exclude the operation of the guarantee and indemnity from Mr Crupi. In a contractual sense, if the execution of the 30 March 2012 document constituted an offer, Westgyp did not accept that offer. (emphasis added)