Ward v State of Western Australia (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Ward v State of Western Australia (No 4) [2016] FCA 358

File number: WAD 86 of 2012
Judge: BARKER J
Date of judgment: 13 April 2016
Catchwords:

NATIVE TITLE – where State made admissions of exclusive native title in compensation proceedings – where tenure searches late in proceedings discovered potentially extinguishing tenure – where Court granted leave for State to withdraw admissions made – whether in all the circumstances it was unreasonable for State to not conduct tenure searches earlier in proceedings – whether in all the circumstances it was unreasonable for State to withdraw admissions in light of new tenure information – whether Court should exercise discretion under s 85A of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) to order costs on an indemnity basis against State

COSTS – discretion of Court to award costs in native title proceedings under s 85A of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth)

Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37M, s 37N, s 43, s 43(1), s 43(2)

Mining Act 1904 (WA)

Mining Act Amendment Act 1920 (WA)

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) s 13(2), s 47A, s 47B, s 62A, s 85A, s 85A(1), s 85A(2)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) R 26.12(2)(b), R 26.12(7)

Cases cited:

Akiba v The Commonwealth of Australia and Others (2013) 250 CLR 209; [2013] HCA 33

Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175; [2009] HCA 27

Banjima People v State of Western Australia and Others(No 2) (2013) 305 ALR 1; [2013] FCA 868

Cheedy v Western Australia and Others (No 2) (2011) 199 FCR 23; [2011] FCAFC 163

Daniel on behalf of the Ngarluma People v State of Western Australia [2003] FCA 666

Graham on behalf of the Ngadju People v State of Western Australia [2014] FCA 516

Mineralogy Pty Ltd v National Native Title Tribunal and Others (1997) 150 ALR 467

Oil Basins Limited v Watson [2014] FCAFC 154

Pathway Investments Pty Ltd and Doystoy Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank Limited [2012] VSC 97

Scheff v Columbia Pictures Corp Ltd [1938] 4 All ER 318

Ward and Others v Western Australia and Another (No 3) (2015) 233 FCR 1; [2015] FCA 658

Ward v State of Western Australia (No 2) [2014] FCA 825

Watson v State of Western Australia (No 3) [2014] FCA 127

Date of hearing: 3 February 2016
Registry: Western Australia
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Native Title
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 162
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr VB Hughston SC and Ms T Jowett
Solicitor for the Applicant: Central Desert Native Title Services Limited
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr TC Russell
Solicitor for the First Respondent: State Solicitor’s Office

ORDERS

WAD 86 of 2012
BETWEEN:

FRED (KUMPARI) WARD, ROBERT JENNINGS, NORMA (NUMANU) GILES AND JANET JENNINGS ON BEHALF OF THE TRADITIONAL OWNERS OF THE GIBSON DESERT NATURE RESERVE

Applicant

AND:

STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

First Respondent

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Second…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ward v State of Western Australia (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 358
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ward v State of Western Australia (No 4) involved the claimants seeking an order for costs on an indemnity basis from the State. The claimants argued that the State had unreasonably caused them to incur costs by withdrawing its admissions of exclusive native title in compensation proceedings, and by not conducting tenure searches earlier in the proceedings. The State argued that it had not acted unreasonably in withdrawing its admissions, and that the claimants' costs should be awarded on a party-party basis.

The legal issues the court had to decide were whether it was unreasonable for the State to not conduct tenure searches earlier in the proceedings, whether it was unreasonable for the State to withdraw its admissions in light of new tenure information, and whether the court should exercise its discretion under s 85A of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) to order costs on an indemnity basis against the State.

The court found that the State had not acted unreasonably in withdrawing its admissions, as it had conducted a tenure search which revealed potentially extinguishing tenure. The court also found that it was not unreasonable for the State to not have conducted a tenure search earlier in the proceedings, as the claimants had not provided any evidence to suggest that the State had acted unreasonably in this regard. The court held that the claimants' costs should be awarded on a party-party basis, as the State had not acted unreasonably in causing the claimants to incur costs.

In light of the above, the court dismissed the interlocutory application of the claimants for costs on an indemnity basis. The court held that the discretion to award costs under s 85A of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) should be exercised judicially, and that it was not a proper use of the power to award costs to punish either a successful or an unsuccessful party or as a deterrent to other would-be applicants.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The interlocutory application of the claimants dated 31 August 2015 be dismissed

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The principal issue for determination then is whether, having regard to s 85A(2) of the NTA, the Court, in its discretion, should award the costs of the proceeding on an indemnity basis or party‑party basis, to the claimants. Factual background to the costs application The factual background to the costs application is relatively uncontentious, at least so far as the chronology of events is concerned. The significance of particular events is, however, not commonly shared by the claimants and the State, as the submissions below illustrate. The claimants refer to and rely upon the history surrounding the lodgement and progress of the compensation application, in particular the circumstances in which the Court granted leave, shortly before the scheduled hearing of the compensation application in August 2014, to the State to make a third further amendment to its defence, including the withdrawal of admissions previously made that the claimants possessed an exclusive native title in the Nature Reserve area at material times. See Ward v State of Western Australia (No 2) [2014] FCA 825 (Ward (No 2)). At [3]-[15] of Ward (No 2) the Court stated as follows:[3]The filing of the compensation application followed the Ngaanyatjarra Lands determination.[4]The Reserve falls within the external boundaries of the application for a determination of native title which was the subject of the Ngaanyatjarra Lands proceeding which was settled by agreement between the parties, including the State and the Commonwealth and resulted in a consent determination of native title in 2005.[5]Recital G of the Ngaanyatjarra Lands determination stated:The State has agreed with respect to the areas set out in Schedule 2 of the Minute of Consent Determination of Native Title that, but for the complete extinguishment of native title effected over those areas, the Applicants in WAD 6004 of 2004 would have held native title rights and interests conferring the right to possession, occupation, use and enjoyment of the land and waters to the exclusion of all others, save in respect of flowing and subterranean water.[6]Schedule 2 described the areas excluded from the determination of native title as including:Reserve 34606 (Gibson Desert Nature Reserve) for the purpose of ‘Conservation of Flora and Fauna’ vested in and held in trust by the Western Australian Wildlife Authority pursuant to s 33 of the Land Act 1933 (WA) on 22 April 1977…[7]The parties to the Ngaanyatjarra Lands determination, including the State and the Commonwealth, agreed that native title within the Reserve had been extinguished by the vesting of the Reserve in the Western Australian Wildlife Authority.[8]A Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) was entered into between ‘Fred Ward on behalf of the Gibson Desert People native title claim group’ and the Executive Director of the Department of Conservation and Land Management (CALM) for the establishment of joint management of Reserve 34606. The MOU provided for the development of a working together project between the traditional owners of Reserve 34606 and CALM (now known as the Department of Parks and Wildlife and the Department of Environment Regulation). A grant agreement dated November 2005 was signed between the traditional owners of the Reserve and the State.[9]Clause 3.8 of the grant agreement recognised that a compensation liability existed on the part of the State for the extinguishment of native title rights and interests brought about by the creation and vesting of Reserve 34606. Clause 3.8 provided:3.8 Compensation under Native Title Act 1993 (Cth)The parties recognise that a compensation liability exists on the part of the State of Western Australia for the extinguishment of native title rights and interests in the Gibson Desert Nature Reserve. The Grantor is committed to negotiating a compensation package which will fully compensate those people who, but for the extinguishment of native title rights and interests, would have held those native title rights and interests in the Gibson Desert Nature Reserve. The parties acknowledge that the contribution of funds made under this Agreement may be added, and a form of land tenure over the Gibson Desert Nature Reserve transferred to the PGDNR (People of the Gibson Desert Nature Reserve) will be added, to the ‘mix’ of compensation options to be negotiated as part of any such ‘compensation package’.[10]The compensation package was never finalised and ultimately, with a change of Government, the State withdrew from the negotiations.[11]It appears the Central Desert Native Title Services Limited, which acts for the applicant, considered exclusive possession would not be in issue if an application for compensation for extinguishment of native title was then brought on behalf of the traditional owners of the Reserve.[12]The hearing of the compensation application is currently due to commence on country in the vicinity of the land the subject of the application – the Gibson Desert Nature Reserve – between 19 and 29 August 2014, when the first tranche of evidence will be taken from members of the compensation claim group. Further evidence is expected to be taken later in Perth.[13]For the purposes of the imminent hearing on country, counsel and solicitors for the applicant have been in the process of proofing and preparing a number of witnesses.[14]Senior counsel for the applicant has explained that the witnesses are being proofed on the basis that the compensation they claim should reflect the fact that the holders of the relevant native title would have held exclusive possession rights to the land in question, including the right to control the access of all other persons to that land, but for the extinguishment of native title by the creation of the Reserve in 1977.[15]There is no dispute that, until recently, the State of Western Australia, as the respondent, and the Attorney-General of the Commonwealth of Australia, as intervener in the proceeding, have proceeded on the basis that, but for the extinguishment of native title by the creation of the Reserve, the native title over the area at relevant times was exclusive in nature and would have included the right to exclude other persons from the land.Claimants’ submissions

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The claimants say the State has also not taken into account that had they not discontinued the proceeding, there would have been considerable additional expense and Court time.Consideration The costs issue is a difficult one to resolve, because there is force in many of the arguments made on each side of the costs equation. The various provisions of the FCA Act, particularly s 43, which gives the Court a wide discretion as to costs, to be exercised judicially; the terms of R 26.12(7) of the Rules, governing costs on the withdrawal of a proceeding; and the terms of s 85A of the NTA, have been set out above. What the Full Court said in Cheedy is relevant and should be repeated here:(1)section 85A(1) of the NTA removes the expectation that costs will follow the event, but the Court retains its discretion as to costs under s 43 of the FCA Act;(2)the “unreasonable conduct” of the parties is not a jurisdictional fact which preconditions the exercise of the discretion, and on the other hand, s 85A(2) of the NTA does not control or limit the discretion in s 85A(1);(3)whilst the exercise of the discretion when making a costs order should be judicial, the starting point is that each party will bear their own costs; and(4)it is not a proper use of the power to award costs to punish either a successful or an unsuccessful party or as a deterrent to other would-be applicants. In the submissions of the parties, s 85A(2) has been the subject of particular focus. The full terms of s 85A(2) should be noted:Without limiting the Court’s power to make orders under subsection (1), if the Federal Court is satisfied that a party to a proceeding has, by any unreasonable act or omission, caused another party to incur costs in connection with the institution or conduct of the proceeding, the Court may order the first‑mentioned party to pay some or all of those costs. The primary argument made by the claimants is that, having regard to the Ngaanyatjarra Lands determination and everything that surrounded it, they should have their costs from the meeting of the claim group authorising the making of the compensation claim because, at that point, as confirmed by the State’s subsequent original defence, exclusive native title was not in issue. It was only the subsequent withdrawal of that admission in August 2014, that changed that position. It is thus said that the State thereby did an “unreasonable act” which caused the claimants to incur costs in connection with the institution of the proceeding and the subsequent conduct of the proceeding. As I apprehend it, the claimants say that, by its conduct, the State made an “unreasonable omission” by not conducting a further tenure search before filing its original defence in the proceeding. They say, in the alternative, the State acted unreasonably in withdrawing its admissions in late 2014, when the hearing was imminent. There can be little doubt that when the claimants authorised the making of the compensation claim, they would have reasonably considered that the proposition that, but for the creation of the Nature Reserve, they, and their antecedents, would have held exclusive possession native title over that area, would not be disputed by the State. The fact of recital G of the Ngaanyatjarra Lands determination and the terms of cl 3.8 of the grant agreement all strongly pointed in that direction.