Virgin Blue Airlines Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Virgin Blue Airlines Pty Ltd v Australian Competition & Consumer Commission
[2001] FCA 1271

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW –  TRADE PRACTICES – Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review Act) 1977 (Cth) – whether applicant established sufficient interest in “decision” made by Australian Competition and Consumer Commission to accept certain undertakings by competitor pursuant to s 87B Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) for purposes of s 5 of ADJR Act – whether applicant “person aggrieved” – whether applicant has standing for purposes of ADJR Act or pursuant to s 39B Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) – where question of standing of applicant reserved for determination at final hearing – context of scheme and purpose of Trade Practices Act relevant to final determination of standing of applicant in the circumstances

TRADE PRACTICES – judicial review of acceptance by Australian Competition and Consumer Commission of undertakings pursuant to s 87B

WORDS AND PHRASES – “person aggrieved”

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 2, 45, 50, 80, 81, 82, 87B, 88, 163A
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) ss 5, 13, Sch 2
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B

Maritime Union of Australia v Anderson (2000) 100 FCR 58 cited
Transurban City Link Ltd v Allan (1999) 95 FCR 553 cited
Australian Conservation Foundation Inc v Commonwealth (1980) 146 CLR 493 cited
Truth About Motorways Pty Ltd v Macquarie Infrastructure Investment Management Ltd (2000) 200 CLR 591 cited
Onus v Alcoa of Australia Ltd (1981) 149 CLR 27 cited
Right to Life Association v Department of Human Services (1995) 56 FCR 50 referred to
Alphapharm Pty Ltd v SmithKline Beecham (Australia) Pty Ltd (1994) 49 FCR 250 cited
Bateman’s Bay Local Aboriginal Land Counsel v Aboriginal Community Benefit Fund Pty Ltd (1998) 194 CLR 247 cited
QIW Retailers Ltd v Davids Holdings Pty Ltd(No 1) (1992) 36 FCR 386 referred to
Big Country Developments Pty Ltd v Australian Community Pharmacy Authority (1995) 60 FCR 85 referred to
Boots Company (Australia) Pty Ltd v SmithKline Beecham Health Care Pty Ltd (1996) 65 FCR 282 cited
Tooheys Ltd v Minister for Business & Consumer Affairs (1981) 54 FLR 421 referred to
Ricegrowers Co-operative Mills Ltd v Bannerman (1981) 56 FLR 443 referred to
Air Express Ltd v Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty Ltd (1981) 146 CLR 249 referred to
Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty Ltd v Commonwealth (1977) 139 CLR 54 referred to

Murphy v KRM Holdings Pty Ltd (1985) 8 FCR 349 cited
Department of Foreign Affairs & Trade v Boswell (1992) 36 FCR 367 cited
Hatfield v Health Insurance Commission (1987) 77 ALR 103 cited
Collins & Dunn v Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs  (No 3) (1982) 5 ALN N3a cited

VIRGIN BLUE AIRLINES PTY LIMITED v AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION and QANTAS AIRWAYS LIMITED
N 977 OF 2001

GYLES J
SYDNEY
6 SEPTEMBER 2001

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 977 OF 2001

BETWEEN:

VIRGIN BLUE AIRLINES PTY LIMITED
APPLICANT

AND:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Virgin Blue Airlines Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Co... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 1271
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Virgin Blue Airlines Pty Ltd versus the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, the Federal Court was presented with three preliminary questions concerning the scope of Virgin Blue's application for judicial review under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (ADJR Act). The primary issues revolved around the nature of the decision made by the ACCC, the applicability of the ADJR Act to that decision, and Virgin Blue's standing to seek relief under the Judiciary Act. The ACCC filed an Amended Notice of Objection to Competency, questioning whether Virgin Blue had the requisite standing to challenge the decision.

The court was tasked with interpreting the statutory framework provided by the Trade Practices Act, particularly sections 50, 80, 81, 87B, and 88, and determining their interaction with the ADJR Act. The court also needed to consider the merger guidelines issued by the ACCC to understand the context and purpose of the Commission's decision. Section 5 of the ADJR Act was central to determining who could request reasons for a decision, while Section 13 of that Act specified the types of decisions that were not subject to such requests. The court had to assess whether the ACCC's decision fell within the scope of these exclusions.

The court found that the questions concerning Virgin Blue's standing, the applicability of the ADJR Act, and the nature of the ACCC's decision required a more comprehensive examination of the statutory texts and the guidelines. It was not appropriate to resolve these issues on a preliminary basis without considering the full context and implications of the decision in question. Consequently, the court decided to defer the determination of these questions until the final hearing, reserving costs pending the outcome of the substantive proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The separate questions stand over for determination at the final hearing.

2. Costs be reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Three questions have been isolated for preliminary determination, pursuant to O29 r 2 of the Federal Court Rules:1.Whether Virgin is a person entitled to make an application under s 13 of the ADJR Act in respect of the decision;2.Whether the decision is a decision to which s 13 of the ADJR Act applies;3.Whether Virgin has standing to seek relief pursuant to s 39B of the Judiciary Act.The last question is raised by an Amended Notice of Objection to Competency filed by the ACCC. STATUTORY BACKGROUND The relevant sections of the TP Act include:“50 Prohibition of acquisitions that would result in a substantial lessening of competition(1)A corporation must not directly or indirectly:(a) acquire shares in the capital of a body corporate; or(b) acquire any assets of a person;if the acquisition would have the effect, or be likely to have the effect, of substantially lessening competition in a market.…80Injunctions(1)Subject to subsections (1A), (1AAA) and (1B), where, on the application of the Commission or any other person, the Court is satisfied that a person has engaged, or is proposing to engage, in conduct that constitutes or would constitute:(a)a contravention of any of the following provisions:(i)a provision of Part IV, IVA, IVB or V;(ii)section 75AU or 75AYA;(b)attempting to contravene such a provision;(c)aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring a person to contravene such a provision;(d)inducing, or attempting to induce, whether by threats, promises or otherwise, a person to contravene such a provision;(e)being in any way, directly or indirectly, knowingly concerned in, or party to, the contravention by a person of such a provision; or(f)conspiring with others to contravene such a provision;the Court may grant an injunction in such terms as the Court determines to be appropriate.…(1A)A person other than the Commission is not entitled to make an application under subsection (1) for an injunction by reason that a person has contravened or attempted to contravene or is proposing to contravene, or has been or is proposing to be involved in a contravention of, section 50, 75AU or 75AYA.…81Divestiture(1)The Court may, on the application of the Commission or any other person, if it finds, or has in another proceeding instituted under this Part found, that a person has contravened section 50, by order, give directions for the purpose of securing the disposal by the person of all or any of the shares or assets acquired in contravention of that section.…87B Enforcement of undertakings(1)The Commission may accept a written undertaking given by a person for the purposes of this section in connection with a matter in relation to which the Commission has a power or function under this Act (other than Part X).(2)The person may withdraw or vary the undertaking at any time, but only with the consent of the Commission.(3)If the Commission considers that the person who gave the undertaking has breached any of its terms, the Commission may apply to the Court for an order under subsection (4).(4)If the Court is satisfied that the person has breached a term of the undertaking, the Court may make all or any of the following orders:(a)an order directing the person to comply with that term of the undertaking;(b)an order directing the person to pay to the Commonwealth an amount up to the amount of any financial benefit that the person has obtained directly or indirectly and that is reasonably attributable to the breach;(c)any order that the Court considers appropriate directing the person to compensate any other person who has suffered loss or damage as a result of the breach;(d)any other order that the Court considers appropriate.…88Power of Commission to grant authorisations(1)Subject to this Part, the Commission may, upon application by or on behalf of a corporation, grant an authorization to the corporation:(a)to make a contract or arrangement, or arrive at an understanding, where a provision of the proposed contract, arrangement or understanding would be, or might be, an exclusionary provision or would have the purpose, or would have or might have the effect, of substantially lessening competition within the meaning of section 45; or(b)to give effect to a provision of a contract, arrangement or understanding where the provision is, or may be, an exclusionary provision or has the purpose, or has or may have the effect, of substantially lessening competition within the meaning of section 45;and, while such an authorization remains in force:(c)in the case of an authorization to make a contract or arrangement or to arrive at an understanding – subsection 45(2) does not prevent the corporation from making the contract or arrangement or arriving at the understanding in accordance with the authorization and giving effect in accordance with the authorization to any provision of the contract or arrangement so made or of the understanding so arrived at;(d)in the case of an authorization to give effect to a provision of a contract:(i)the provision is not unenforceable by reason of subsection 45(1); and(ii)subsection 45(2) does not prevent the corporation from giving effect to the provision in accordance with the authorization; or(e)in the case of an authorization to give effect to a provision of an arrangement or understanding – subsection 45(2) does not prevent the corporation from giving effect to the provision in accordance with the authorization.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GYLES J
Section 5 of the ADJR Act gives standing to a “a person who is aggrieved by a decision to which this Act applies” in relation to applying for an order of review. The relevant portions of s 13 of that Act are as follows:“13 Reasons for decision may be obtained(1)Where a person makes a decision to which this section applies, any person who is entitled to make an application to the Court under section 5 in relation to the decision may, by notice in writing given to the person who made the decision, request him or her to furnish a statement in writing setting out the findings on material questions of fact, referring to the evidence or other material on which those findings were based and giving the reasons for the decision.…(11)In this section, decision to which this section applies means a decision that is a decision to which this Act applies, but does not include:…(c)a decision included in any of the classes of decision set out in Schedule 2.” Included amongst the classes of decision that are not decisions to which s 13 applies by virtue of inclusion in Schedule 2 is the following:“(f)decisions in connection with the institution or conduct of proceedings in a civil court, including decisions that relate to, or may result in, the bringing of such proceedings for the recovery of pecuniary penalties arising from contraventions of enactments, and, in particular:(i)decisions in connection with the investigation of persons for such contraventions;(ii)decisions in connection with the appointment of investigators or inspectors for the purposes of such investigations;(iii)decisions in connection with the issue of search warrants or seizure warrants issued under Division 1 of Part XII of the Customs Act 1901 under enactments; and(iv)decisions under enactments requiring the production of documents, the giving of information or the summoning of persons as witnesses …” The parties also referred to the merger guidelines issued by the ACCC. Among the relevant provisions of the guidelines are the following:“2.16Under s 87B the Commission may accept a written undertaking in connection with a matter in relation to which it has a power or function under the Act, except Part X. If the undertaking is breached the Commission may seek orders from the Court directing compliance with the undertaking, the giving up of any financial benefit gained from the breach, compensation for any other loss or damage as a result of the breach, or any other appropriate orders.…4.16If the Commission concludes that a proposed acquisition would, or would be likely to have, the effect of substantially lessening competition, the Commission will advise the parties of its view. The parties may then take the following action:·abandon the proposal;·modify the proposal to address any of the likely anti-competitive consequences, either informally or formally by way of undertakings pursuant to s 87B of the Act (s 87B is discussed in Section 7);·apply for authorisation if the acquirer considers it may be able to establish that the proposal would result in a net public benefit (see Section 6);·take their own risk and seek to complete the acquisition; or·seek a declaration that the proposed acquisition does not contravene the Act.…7.1As stated in paragraph 2.16, s 87B allows the Commission to accept written undertakings in connection with matters where it has a power or function under the Act (other than Part X).7.2Undertakings pursuant to s 87B are one of the tools available under the Act to further its goals of improved competition and efficiency in markets. Undertakings pursuant to s 87B are a flexible alternative to simply opposing an acquisition where the Commission believes that the acquisition is likely to substantially lessen competition.7.3To date the Commission has accepted undertakings pursuant to s 87B of the Act from parties to an acquisition for either of two purposes:·to ensure that an acquisition is not completed until the Commission has had the opportunity to conduct the appropriate market inquiries; or·to resolve matters where the proposed acquisition is, in the Commission’s view, likely to contravene the Act.7.4Where, following its inquiries into a proposed acquisition, the Commission forms the view that it is likely to substantially lessen competition in breach of s 50, it will provide the parties with reasons for that view. If the parties consider that undertakings could be offered to reduce or eliminate the stated concerns, they may choose to offer to the Commission undertakings aimed at restructuring the proposal in such a way as to address the competition concerns.7.5In these circumstances the offer of such an undertaking designed to address the competition concerns is a matter for strategic decision by the parties to the acquisition, and presumably will be considered along with other options open to the parties, for example challenging the Commission in court, seeking authorisation, revising the proposal without undertakings, or even abandoning the proposal. It is not the policy or practice of the Commission to demand such undertakings.…7.16The scope of a s 87B undertaking is potentially wider and the terms more flexible than a court imposed remedy. For example, the court may be reluctant to make other orders requiring ongoing monitoring and supervision by the court, whereas the Commission does have the resources and functions of an administrative agency and may be prepared to accept undertakings with an ongoing obligation.7.17The scope of s 87B undertakings that the Commission is likely to accept in the mergers context will be determined by the Commission’s assessment of the anti-competitive effects of the merger. The test will be whether the arrangements envisaged by the proposed undertakings will address the reduction in competition. The focus is not necessarily on the assets to be acquired and this may mean that the Commission may accept an undertaking which is not directly related to the assets to be acquired where that is considered necessary to address the reduction to competition.…7.25The Commission may also need to assess the impact of third party rights and interests. Any merger will achieve some measure of structural change in a market and, therefore, any merger will be likely to impact on firms and consumers not party to the transaction. In its simplest terms, if a merger is anti-competitive it will have a direct impact on those parties dealing with the merged firm, whether in terms of increased prices or reduced service or quality. If a merger reduces competition in a market it may benefit rivals through lower competitive pressure and higher prices.7.26Just as any anti-competitive merger will have an impact on third parties, so too will any undertaking designed to address the anti-competitive consequences. Where the merger is likely to be anti-competitive the provision of undertakings to address that is likely to favour customers, but may remove the benefits that rival firms may have anticipated through the reduction in competition.7.27An assessment of these ‘third party’ interests is in effect subsumed within the general assessment of the competition effects of a merger and the capacity of the proposed undertakings to address those effects.7.28However, there may be other more specialised third party interests which need to be considered by the Commission and the merger parties. For example, merger parties which are proposing s 87B undertakings will need to consider their own obligations to third parties, for example whether the undertakings are consistent with existing contractual obligations with another party or whether the performance of the undertakings may give rise to some claim against the merger parties.7.29Generally it would not be appropriate for the Commission to conduct this assessment of the rights and obligations as between the merger parties and other third parties. Generally that will be a matter for the merger parties. However, in some cases where the presence of third party rights may give rise to a challenge to the s 87B undertakings or the undertakings being rendered impossible to comply with, it may be necessary for the proposed s 87B undertakings to make specific provision for those rights, for example by way of indemnification of the affected third party. This is likely to arise only in rare cases.”FACTS

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GYLES J